Invasion and rebellion of the Five Barbarians
The Invasion and rebellion of the Five Barbarians is a Chinese expression referring to a series of rebellions between 304 - 316 A.D. by four non-Chinese peoples living in North China against the Jin dynasty (265–420), which had recently been weakened by a series of civil wars. The uprisings helped topple Emperor Huai of Jin in Luoyang and ended the Western Jin dynasty in northern China.
|Invasion and rebellion of the Five Barbarians (五胡亂華)|
Various armies including the Five Barbarians|
Han Chinese rebels led by Ji Sang and Wang Mi
(the Five Barbarian rebels did not include the Xianbei)
Murong in Liaodong (later Former Yan)
|Ba-Di Cheng Han in Sichuan||Southern aboriginal Nanman rebels in Hubei claiming to restore the Han dynasty|
|Commanders and leaders|
|Liu Yuan, Liu Xuan, Liu Cong, Shi Le and other tribal chieftains, Ji Sang, and Wang Mi||Sima Yue, Wang Yan, Wang Dao, Wang Dun, Liu Kun, Duan Pidi||
Zhang Chang (Li Chen)|
Qiu Shen (Liu Ni)
|c.100,000 Xiongnu, Jie, Di, Qiang and Han Chinese||100,000-200,000 Han Chinese and Xianbei||Ba-Di rebels and Han Chinese allies||Nanman aboriginal rebels|
|Casualties and losses|
|Invasion and rebellion of the Five Barbarians|
|Literal meaning||Five Barbarians disorderize China|
Rulers from four ethnic groups, the Xiongnu, Jie, Qiang and Di, then established a series of independent kingdoms in what is now northern China. The fifth group, the Xianbei in the north, were allied to the Western Jin and later Eastern Jin against the other four barbarians until turning on the Chinese much later. A series of revolts in southern China occurred at the same time by southern Ba-Di rebels aboriginal people in Sichuan and Nanman aboriginals in Hubei resulting in the establishment of the Cheng Han state in Sichuan. This chaotic period of Chinese history, known as the Sixteen Kingdoms (五胡十六國, "sixteen kingdoms of the five barbarians"), lasted over 130 years until the Northern Wei dynasty united northern China in the 5th century. The Eastern Jin dynasty survived in southern China.
The southward migration of nomadic tribes into the lands around the Yellow River had been ongoing since the Eastern Han dynasty for several reasons. the Han dynasty's defeated of the Xiongnu confederation in the Han–Xiongnu War by Han General Dou Xian led to the Han dynasty deporting the Southern Xiongnu along with their Chanyu into northern China. In 167 AD, Duan Jiong conducted an anti-Qiang campaign and massacred Qiang populations as well as settled them outside the frontier in northern China.
The wars of the later Three Kingdoms period also encouraged this immigration, which repopulated previously devastated areas and provided military power and labour.
By the end of the 4th century, the nomadic tribes had moved into the Guanzhong area, as well as the watersheds of the Wei and Xing rivers, practically surrounding the Jin capital in Luoyang. At the same time, the accession of Emperor Hui of Jin, who was possibly developmentally disabled, led to a struggle between the princes of the ruling Sima family to control him, sparking off the War of the Eight Princes.
Revolts by the five barbarians took place before such as in Shanxi and Shaanxi, He San's Xiongnu revolt in 294 and Qi Wannian's Qiang and Di revolt in Yong and Qin provinces and the Beidi region (Shaanxi) He Duyuan's Qiang revolt in 296.
Rise of Han ZhaoEdit
The War of the Eight Princes lasted for more than a decade, severely weakening the economy and military capacity of the Western Jin. At the same time, the nomads were also being enlisted by the princes as military forces; one such force of Xianbei, under the command of Sima Yue, captured Chang'an in 306.
Taking advantage of this period of weakness, the different non-Chinese peoples began to openly revolt and proclaim new regimes. The Jie chief Shi Le was sold as a slave by Western Jin officials before his uprising and owned by a Han Chinese called Shi Huan (師懽), and began his rebellion as a slave revolt against his Han Chinese masters. The Di chief Li Xiong captured Chengdu in 304, proclaiming the kingdom of Cheng Han. The most serious initial revolt, however, was Xiongnu chieftain Liu Yuan, who proclaimed the kingdom of Han Zhao in 304 as well, in the northern heartland of the Jin dynasty.[full citation needed]
A Sogdian merchant in China wrote a letter to another Sogdian referring to the Huns (Xiongnu) who had revolted as people who had previously been "property" of the Chinese Western Jin Emperor until their uprising against him and destruction of the capital at Luoyang. The Xiongnu rebel Liu Xuan (劉宣), a relative of Xiongnu rebel chief Liu Yuan said his own Xiongnu people were treated as slaves by their Han Chinese rulers and now was the time to revolt against their Han Chinese rulers after the Jin exhausted themselves in the War of the Eight Princes, saying "The Jin dynasty people use us like slaves. Now they are killing each other's flesh and blood. It is God's abandonment of them and let us recover the Han". The Jie chief Shi Le led a revolt of slaves against the Western Jin and joined Liu Yuan and the Han Chinese rebel Wang Mi. The Chinese had humiliated Shi Le and the other barbarian slaves by forcing them to wear cangues while transporting them. Ji Sang gave Shi Le his Chinese name. Shi Le originally joined a Han Chinese rebel, Ji Sang.
Jin defeat and Disaster of YongjiaEdit
The Jin dynasty was ineffective in its attempts to halt the uprising. The Jin capital, Luoyang was open to Liu Yuan's son Liu Cong (who was now commander of the rebellious forces), and he attacked Luoyang in 309 and 310 CE twice, without success. However, the Jin Chancellor Sima Yue fled Luoyang in 310CE with 40,000 troops to Xiangcheng in Henan in an attempt to flee this threat.[full citation needed]
After Sima Yue's death, the main Jin forces in Henan, led by Wang Yan, decided to proceed to Shantung to defeat Shi Le, a general of Jie ethnicity under Liu Cong, but was defeated by the rebel forces and more than 100,000 soldiers perished, including Wang Yan himself.[full citation needed]
The defeat of Wang Yan's forces finally exhausted the military capacity of the Jin, leaving the capital open to capture. Upon entering the city, the invaders engaged in a massacre, razing the city and causing more than 30,000 deaths. This event in Chinese history was known as the Disaster of Yongjia, after the era name of Emperor Huai of Jin; the emperor himself was captured, while his crown prince and clansmen were killed.[full citation needed]
Although the main Jin regime in the North was defeated, Jin forces continued to hold three provinces in the North, namely Youzhou, Liangzhou, and Bingzhou. These provinces, however, were cut off from the remnant Jin forces now in the South and eventually overrun, reducing Jin control to the area south of the Huai River.
The collapse of Jin authority in the North led other leaders to declare independence. Chinese history entered the period called Sixteen Kingdoms.
The collapse of the Western Jin had long-lasting effects. In the conquered areas, various non-Han leaders quickly established a large series of kingdoms and states, most of which were short lived; this era of fragmentation and state creation lasted for more than a century, until the Northern Wei regime finally conquered and "unified" the northern regions in 439 and became the first of the Northern Dynasties.
The chaos and devastation of the north also led to a mass migration of Han Chinese to the areas south of the Huai River, where conditions were relatively stable. The southward migration of the Jin nobility is referred to in Chinese as yī guān nán dù (衣冠南渡, lit. "garments and headdresses moving south"). Many of those who fled south were of prominent families, who had the means to escape; among these prominent northern families were the Xie clan and the Wang clan, whose prominent members included Xie An and Wang Dao. Wang Dao, in particular, was instrumental in supporting Sima Rui to proclaim the Eastern Jin dynasty at Jiankang and serving as his chancellor. The Eastern Jin, dependent on established southern nobility as well as exiled northern nobility for its survival, became a relatively weak dynasty dominated by regional nobles who served as governors; nonetheless it would survive for another century as a southern regime.
While the era was one of military catastrophe, it was also one of deep cultural interaction. The nomadic tribes introduced new methods of government, while also encouraging introduced faiths such as Buddhism. Meanwhile, the southward exodus of the cultured Jin elite, who then spread across the southern provinces including modern-day Fujian and Guangdong, further integrated the areas south of the Yangtze River into the Chinese cultural sphere.
The "Eight Great Surnames" were eight noble families who migrated from northern China to Fujian in southern China due to the uprising of the five barbarians when the Eastern Jin was founded, the Hu, He, Qiu, Dan, Zheng, Huang, Chen and Lin surnames.
Ming dynasty pirate Zheng Zhilong and his son Koxinga's ancestors in the Zheng family originated in northern China but due to the Uprising of the Five Barbarians and Disaster of Yongjia by the Five Barbarians, the Zheng family were among the northern Chinese refugees who fled to southern China and settled in Putian, Fujian. They later moved to Zhangzhou and moved on to Nan'an.
The different waves of migration such as the fourth century and Tang dynasty northern Han Chinese migrants to the south are claimed as the origin of various Chen families in Fuzhou, Fujian.
The Uprising of the Five Barbarians was one of several wars in northern China along with the An Lushan Rebellion, Huang Chao Rebellion, the wars of the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms and Jin–Song Wars which caused a mass migration of Han Chinese from northern China to southern China called 衣冠南渡(yì guān nán dù). These mass migrations led to southern China's population growth, economic, agricultural and cultural development as it stayed peaceful unlike the north. The Western Jin set up "emigrant counties" for the northern Han Chinese refugees as stated in the saying “皆取旧壤之名，侨立郡县”. The influx of northern Han Chinese refugees was called "侨寄法" and the refugees were called “侨人”. Yellow registers were used to record the original southern Han Chinese population before the migration and white registers were used to record the massive influx of commoner and aristocratic northern Han Chinese migrants by the Eastern Jin dynasty government.
After the establishment of the Northern Wei in northern China and a return to stability, a small reverse migration of southern defectors to northern China took place. In Luoyang a Wu quarter was set up for southerners moving north. Han Chinese male nobles and royals of the southern dynasties who fled north to defect married over half of Northern Wei Xianbei Tuoba princesses. Southern Chinese from the southern capital of Jiankang (Nanjing) were deported to the northern capital of Chang'an by the Sui dynasty after reuniting China.
Han Chinese refugees from the five barbarian uprising also migrated into the Korean peninsula and into the Murong Former Yan state. Eastern Jin maintained nominal suzerainty over the Murong state until 353 as the Murong accepted titles from them. An official in the Murong state, Dong Shou defected to Goguryeo. Han Chinese refugees migrated west into Han Chinese controlled Former Liang.
Yan Zhitui's aristocratic Yan family originally fled to southern China with the Eastern Jin during the uprising of the Five Barbarians in 317. Yan Zhitui was born in the Liang dynasty in 531 but upon the Chen dynasty replacing the Liang dynasty, Yan Zhitui refused to serve the new dynasty so he moved to northeastern China and defected to the Northern Qi dynasty, living through the Northern Zhou's conquest of the Northern Qi when he was brought to Chang'an in northwestern China and then serving the Sui dynasty which overthrew the Northern Zhou.
The descendants of northern Han Chinese aristocrats who fled the five barbarians uprising to move south with the Eastern Jin and the local southern Han Chinese aristocrats already in southern China combined to form the Chinese Southern aristocracy in the Tang dynasty, in competition with the northeastern aristocracy and the mixed Han-Xianbei northwestern aristocracy of the former Northern Zhou who founded the Sui dynasty and Tang dynasty. The southern aristocracy only intermarried with each other and viewed themselves as preserving Han culture.
Southern Chinese Daoism developed as a result of a merger of the religious beliefs of the local southern Han Chinese aristocrats and northern Han Chinese emigres fleeing the five barbarians. The Han aristocrats of both south and north were highly insular and closed against outsiders and descended from the same families who originally hailed from northern China.
Ming dynasty writer and historian Zhu Guozhen (1558-1632) remarked on how the Ming dynasty managed to successfully control Mongols who surrendered to the Ming and were relocated and deported into China to serve in military matters unlike the Eastern Han dynasty and Western Jin dynasty whose unsuccessfully management of the surrendered and defeated barbarians they imported into northern China who learned to study history and this led to rebellion : Late during the Eastern Han (25-220 C.E.), surrendering barbarians were settled in the hinterlands [of China]. In time, they learned to study and grew conversant with [matters of the] past and present. As a result, during the Jin dynasty (265-419), there occurred the Revolt of the Five Barbarian [Tribes](late in the third and early in the fourth centuries C.E.).184 During our dynasty, surrendering barbarians were relocated to the hinterlands in great numbers. Because [the court] was generous in its stipends and awards, [the Mongols are content to] merely amuse themselves with archery and hunting. The brave185 among them gain recognition through [service in] the military. [They] serve as assistant regional commanders and regional vice commanders. Although they do not hold the seals of command, they may serve as senior officers. Some among those who receive investiture in the nobility of merit may occasionally hold the seals of command. However [because the court] places heavy emphasis on maintaining centralized control of the armies, [the Mongols] do not dare commit misdeeds. As a consequence, during the Tumu Incident, while there was unrest everywhere, it still did not amount to a major revolt. Additionally, [the Mongols] were relocated to Guangdong and Guangxi on military campaign. Thus, for more than 200 years, we have had peace throughout the realm. The dynastic forefathers' policies are the product of successive generations of guarding against the unexpected. [Our policies] are more thorough than those of the Han. The foundations of merit surpass the Sima family (founders of the Eastern Jin) ten thousand fold. In a word, one cannot generalize [about the policies towards surrendering barbarians].186
- Knechtges, David R.; Chang, Taiping, eds. (2010). Ancient and Early Medieval Chinese Literature (vol.I): A Reference Guide, Part One. BRILL. p. 547. ISBN 978-9004191273.
- Chinese Literature, Essays, Articles, Reviews, Volume 28. Coda Press. 2006. pp. 13, 14, 54.
- A History of Chinese Letters and Epistolary Culture (illustrated ed.). BRILL. 2015. p. 216. ISBN 978-9004292123.
- Renditions, Issues 33-36. Centre for Translation Projects, Chinese University of Hong Kong. 1990. pp. 102, 103.
- Kleeman, Terry F. (1998). Great Perfection (illustrated ed.). University of Hawaii Press. p. 98. ISBN 0824818008.
- Seiwert, Hubert Michael (2003). Popular Religious Movements and Heterodox Sects in Chinese History. BRILL. p. 87. ISBN 9004131469.
- Li, Shi. The Political History in Wei, Jin, Southern and Northern Dynasty.
- Kleeman, Terry F. (1998). Great Perfection (illustrated ed.). University of Hawaii Press. pp. 97–98. ISBN 0824818008.
- Cosmo 2009, p. 104.
- Kleeman, Terry F. (1998). Great Perfection (illustrated ed.). University of Hawaii Press. pp. 90–91. ISBN 0824818008.
- Li and Zheng, pg 382
- Sinor, Denis (1997). Inner Asia. Psychology Press. p. 94. ISBN 0700708960.
- Zürcher, Erik (2007). The Buddhist Conquest of China: The Spread and Adaptation of Buddhism in Early Medieval China (2 ed.). BRILL. p. 84. ISBN 978-9047419426.
- Sinica Leidensia, Volume 11, Issue 1. E.J. Brill. 1972. p. 84.
- Sinor, Denis (1969). Uralic and Altaic Series, Volume 96. Indiana University. p. 94.
- Sima, Guang. Records of Jin Dynasty 晋纪: Zi Zhi Tong Jian资治通鉴; or Comprehensive Mirror in Aid of Governance; Volume 79 - 118.
- Li, Shi. Book of Jin Dynasty: 二十四史 晋书 (China Twenty-four Histories ed.). DeepLogic.
- Xiong, Victor Cunrui; Hammond, Kenneth J., eds. (2018). Routledge Handbook of Imperial Chinese History. Routledge. ISBN 978-1317538226.
- China Report: Political, Sociological and Military Affairs, Issues 378-380. Foreign Broadcast Information Service. 1983.
- Xiong, Victor Cunrui; Hammond, Kenneth J., eds. (2018). Routledge Handbook of Imperial Chinese History. Routledge. ISBN 978-1317538226.
- Mair, Victor H.; Chen, Sanping; Wood, Frances (2013). Chinese Lives: The People Who Made a Civilization (illustrated ed.). Thames & Hudson. ISBN 978-0500771471.
- China Report: Political, Sociological and Military Affairs, Issues 378-380. Foreign Broadcast Information Service. 1983.
- Xiong, Victor Cunrui (2009). Historical Dictionary of Medieval China (illustrated ed.). Rowman & Littlefield. p. xcii. ISBN 978-0810860537.
- Li and Zheng, pg 383
- Dean, Kenneth; Zheng, Zhenman (2009). "Appendix One. Legends Of The Main Surnames Of The Putian Plain (Based On The Account In Zhang Qin's Putian Xianzhi)". Ritual Alliances of the Putian Plain. Volume One: Historical Introduction to the Return of the Gods. BRILL. p. 341. doi:10.1163/ej.9789004176027.i-437.88. ISBN 978-9047429463.
- Xu, Bin; Xie, Bizhen (2013). "The Rise and Fall of Nestorianism in Quanzhou during the Yuan dynasty". In Li, Tang; Winkler, Dietmar W. (eds.). From the Oxus River to the Chinese Shores: Studies on East Syriac Christianity in China and Central Asia (illustrated ed.). LIT Verlag Münster. p. 270. ISBN 978-3643903297.
- Ni, Hao. Travel Guide of Fujian. Travelling in China. DeepLogic.
- Szonyi, Michael (2002). Practicing Kinship: Lineage and Descent in Late Imperial China (illustrated ed.). Stanford University Press. p. 27. ISBN 0804742618.
- Zheng, Zhenman (2001). Family Lineage Organization and Social Change in Ming and Qing Fujian (illustrated ed.). University of Hawaii Press. p. 190. ISBN 0824823338.
- Clark, Hugh R. (2007). Portrait of a Community: Society, Culture, and the Structures of Kinship in the Mulan River Valley (Fujian) from the Late Tang Through the Song (illustrated ed.). Chinese University Press. p. 223. ISBN 978-9629962272. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Dean, Kenneth (1998). "Transformations of the She (altars of the soil) in Fujian". Cahiers d'Extrême-Asie. 10 (10): 19–75. doi:10.3406/asie.1998.1236.
- 台湾《漳龙衍派鄱山氏之来龙去脉》（ 在2002年举行的纪念郑成功收复台湾340周年研讨会上 郑姓）
- Abt, Obed (January 2012). Muslim Ancestry and Chinese Identity in Southeast China (PDF) (Doctor of Philosophy). Tel Aviv University The Lester & Sally Entin Faculty of Humanities School of Historical Studies. p. 178. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2018-04-28.
- 从衣冠南渡到西部大开发．中国期刊网．2011-4-26 [引用日期2013-08-12]
- 中华书局编辑部．全唐诗．北京：中华书局，1999-01-1 ：761
- Yao, Yifeng (2016). Nanjing: Historical Landscape and Its Planning from Geographical Perspective (illustrated ed.). Springer. p. 95. ISBN 978-9811016370. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- "Six Dynasties". Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica. December 4, 2008.
- Entenmann, Robert Eric (1982). Migration and settlement in Sichuan, 1644-1796 (reprint ed.). Harvard University. p. 14. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Shi, Zhihong (2017). Agricultural Development in Qing China: A Quantitative Study, 1661-1911. The Quantitative Economic History of China. BRILL. p. 154. ISBN 978-9004355248. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Hsu, Cho-yun (2012). China: A New Cultural History. Masters of Chinese Studies (illustrated ed.). Columbia University Press. p. 194. ISBN 978-0231528184. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Pletcher, Kenneth, ed. (2010). The History of China. Understanding China (illustrated ed.). The Rosen Publishing Group, Inc. p. 127. ISBN 978-1615301096. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Chinese journal of international law, Volume 3. Chinese journal of international law. 2004. p. 631. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Gernet, Jacques (1996). A History of Chinese Civilization (illustrated, reprint, revised ed.). Cambridge University Press. pp. 182–3. ISBN 0521497817. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- The History of China. p. 236. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Ebrey, Patricia Buckley. East Asia: A Cultural, Social, and Political History, Volume II: From 160. Cengage Learning. p. 66. ISBN 1111808147. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Ebrey, Patricia Buckley; Walthall, Anne; Palais, James B. (2013). East Asia: A Cultural, Social, and Political History, Volume I: To 1800. Cengage Learning. p. 66. ISBN 978-1111808150. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Ebrey, Patricia Buckley; Walthall, Anne (2013). East Asia: A Cultural, Social, and Political History (3 ed.). Cengage Learning. p. 67. ISBN 978-1285528670. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Ebrey, Patricia Buckley; Walthall, Anne; Palais, James B. (2006). East Asia: A Cultural, Social, and Political History (illustrated ed.). Houghton Mifflin. p. 79. ISBN 0618133844. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Tang, Qiaomei (May 2016). Divorce and the Divorced Woman in Early Medieval China (First through Sixth Century) (PDF) (Doctor of Philosophy in the subject of East Asian Languages and Civilizations). Harvard University Cambridge, Massachusetts. pp. 151–153.
- Ebrey, Patricia Buckley; Smith, Paul Jakov, eds. (2016). State Power in China, 900-1325 (illustrated ed.). University of Washington Press. p. 309. ISBN 978-0295998480. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Holcombe, Charles (2001). The Genesis of East Asia: 221 B.C. - A.D. 907 (illustrated ed.). University of Hawaii Press. p. 170. ISBN 0824824652. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Dien, Albert E. (2007). Six Dynasties Civilization. Early Chinese civilization series (illustrated ed.). Yale University Press. p. 98. ISBN 978-0300074048. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Ji, Lu. Selected Biographies of Chinese Emperors in Major Dynasties. DeepLogic. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Li, Shi. The Political History in Wei, Jin, Southern and Northern Dynasty. DeepLogic. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Hanʼguk Chŏngsin Munhwa Yŏnʼguwŏn (2005). The Review of Korean Studies, Volume 8, Issues 3-4. Academy of Korean Studies. p. 105. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Holcombe, Charles (2017). A History of East Asia (illustrated, revised ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 85. ISBN 978-1107118737. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Spiro, Audrey G. (1990). Contemplating the Ancients: Aesthetic and Social Issues in Early Chinese Portraiture (illustrated ed.). University of California Press. p. 42. ISBN 0520065670. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Spiro, Audrey Jean Goldman (1987). Early Chinese Portraiture: Character as Social Ideal (reprint ed.). University of California, Los Angeles. p. 56. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Society for East Asian Studies (2002). Journal of East Asian Archaeology, Volume 4. Brill. p. 263. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Barnes, Gina (2013). State Formation in Korea: Emerging Elites. Durham East Asia Series. Routledge. p. 24. ISBN 978-1136841040. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Kroll, Paul W.; Knechtges, David R., eds. (2003). Studies in Early Medieval Chinese Literature and Cultural History: In Honor of Richard B. Mather & Donald Holzman. Tang studies. Tʻang Studies Society. p. 235. ISBN 0972925503. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- China Archaeology & Art Digest, Volume 2, Issues 3-4. Art Text (HK) Ltd. 1998. p. 246. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Graff, David (2003). Medieval Chinese Warfare 300-900. Warfare and History. Routledge. p. 57. ISBN 1134553536. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Li, Shi. The History of Thoughts in Wei, Jin , Southern and Northern Dynasty. Deep Into China Histories. DeepLogic. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Dardess, John W. (2010). Governing China, 150-1850 (illustrated ed.). Hackett Publishing. p. 7. ISBN 978-1603843119. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Chen, Jo-Shui (2006). Liu Tsung-yüan and Intellectual Change in T'ang China, 773-819. Cambridge Studies in Chinese History, Literature and Institutions (reprint, reissue ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 11. ISBN 0521030102. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Gernet, Jacques (1996). A History of Chinese Civilization (illustrated, reprint, revised ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 172. ISBN 0521497817. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Ebrey, Patricia Buckley; Walthall, Anne (2013). East Asia: A Cultural, Social, and Political History (3, illustrated ed.). Cengage Learning. p. 68. ISBN 978-1133606475. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Ebrey, Patricia Buckley (2010). The Cambridge Illustrated History of China. Cambridge Illustrated Histories (illustrated, reprint ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 86. ISBN 978-0521124331. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Ji, Xiao-bin (2003). Facts about China. Facts series (illustrated ed.). H.W. Wilson. p. 110. ISBN 0824209613. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Chen, Sanping (2012). Multicultural China in the Early Middle Ages. Encounters with Asia. University of Pennsylvania Press. p. 4. ISBN 978-0812206289. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- The Rough Guide to Southwest China. Rough Guides UK. 2013. ISBN 978-1409349525. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Robinson, David M. (June 2004). "Images of Subject Mongols Under the Ming Dynasty". Late Imperial China. Johns Hopkins University Press. 25 (1): 102. doi:10.1353/late.2004.0010. ISSN 1086-3257.