The Tribes of Crane
The Tribes of Crane was a turn-based game where players took on the role of leader of a tribe on the planet of Crane, and attempted to accumulate warriors, gold, and other resources. It was the first commercial play-by-mail game that was moderated by a human game master instead of a computer, although later the game master was assisted by a computer.
A new player started by picking what type of tribe they wished to lead (herdsmen, warriors, merchants or sea people), and what type of climate and terrain they wanted to start in. The player would then be sent details of how many people and livestock were in the tribe.
The player would mail a monthly turn, which consisted of a movement or stand-in-place order, a combat order, a transaction order, and any special orders. Special orders were unusual for play-by-mail games, which were often moderated by a computer. As reviewer Jeff Neufeld noted, "Properly utilized, this is the best part of the game... What can be done here is virtually unlimited. For instance, you can push development of a better crossbow, or breed faster horses. The big advantage of having a [human] gamesmaster is that he can decide on the feasibility of new ideas."
Knowledge of the world and other tribes was gained through moving from place to place, meeting other tribes and trading knowledge, or asking questions of the game master.
When The Tribes of Crane began, the cost was $1 to join a game, and $1.50 for each monthly turn, with unlimited special orders. After several years, the number of turns increased to two per month, and the cost rose to $2.50 per turn. A charge of $1 per turn for special orders was also initiated, increasing the possible monthly cost for two turns to $7.
In the June 1979 edition of Dragon (Issue 26), Jeff Neufeld lauded the human gamemaster, the addition of special orders, and the gamemasters' habit of sending a self-addressed stamped envelope when replying to a player's turn. His one disappointment was the lack of interaction with other players, but overall, he believed that "Tribes of Crane is an excellent game and worth every penny it costs to play.
However, in the July 1980 issue of The Space Gamer (Issue 29), Forrest Johnson disagreed that a human gamemaster was necessarily a good thing, noting, "[It] is the largest open-ended correspondence game around. But how open is it when an inexperienced GM appraises your turn, so that a sophisticated special action comes back marked simple 'noted,' or ignored altogether? How open is it when a different GM handles every turn, so the elaborate preparations of a previous turn are forgotten? The more involved a player is in Crane, the more frustrated he becomes."
In the July 1983 edition of White Dwarf (Issue #43), Trevor Graver liked the enjoyment that came from "discovering things. The amount of information one can acquire about Crane is staggering, information on anything from city life, through to details on an obscure religion all come together to paint a brilliant fantasy." However, Graver did warn about the high cost of play: "Many prospective [Play-by-Mailers] flinch when they compare the cost of playing the game for a year, with say, the cost of the AD&D works." However, Graver concluded that "Tribes of Crane is well worth playing, and could very easily become an obsession."
In The Space Gamer 1979 Game Survey, readers rated Tribes of Crane 6.4 out of 9.
- Townsend, Jim. "The PBM Corner". White Wolf. No. 11. p. 20.
- Johnson, Forrest (July 1980). "Featured Review: Farewell to Crane". The Space Gamer. No. 29. Steve Jackson Games. p. 17. ISSN 0194-9977.
- "The Tribes of Crane (1978)". Board Game Geek. Retrieved 2019-06-17.
- Neufeld, Jeff (June 1979). "The Dragon's Augury". Dragon. TSR, Inc. (26): 40.
- Cummings, Mark (August 1980). "The fatal flaws of Crane". Dragon. TSR, Inc. (40): 24–25.
- Shannon Appelcline (2011). Designers & Dragons. Mongoose Publishing. ISBN 978-1-907702-58-7.
- Gray, Michael (April 1983). "The PBM scene: Facts you can use when YOU choose what game to play". Dragon. TSR, Inc. (72): 32.
- Graver, Trevor (July 1983). "Open Box...". White Dwarf. No. 43. p. 13.
- Creese, Brian (May 1984). "Chain Mail". Imagine (review). TSR Hobbies (UK), Ltd. (14): 39.
- Jackson, Steve (May–June 1980). "1979 Game Survey Results". The Space Gamer. No. 28. Steve Jackson Games. pp. 6–7. ISSN 0194-9977 – via Internet Archive.
- Johnson, Forrest (July 1980). "Featured Review: Farewell to Crane". The Space Gamer. No. 29. Steve Jackson Games. p. 17.
- McCarthy, William (Winter 1983). "The Singers of Crane". Flagship magazine. No. 1. p. 21.
- Steadman, Chris (Spring 1984). "Directions for New Crane Operators". Flagship magazine. No. 2. p. 14–15.
- Townsend, Jim. "The PBM Corner". White Wolf Magazine. No. 11. p. 20.