The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll
"The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll" is a topical song written by the American musician Bob Dylan. Recorded on October 23, 1963, the song was released on Dylan's 1964 album, The Times They Are a-Changin' and gives a generally factual account of the killing of a 51-year-old African-American barmaid, Hattie Carroll, by the 24-year-old William Devereux "Billy" Zantzinger (February 7, 1939 – January 3, 2009), a young man from a wealthy white tobacco farming family in Charles County, Maryland, and of his subsequent sentence to six months in a county jail, after being convicted of assault.
|"The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll"|
|Song by Bob Dylan|
|from the album The Times They Are a-Changin'|
|Released||January 13, 1964|
|Recorded||October 23, 1963|
|The Times They Are a-Changin' track listing|
The lyrics are a commentary on 1960s racism. When Carroll was killed in 1963, Charles County was still strictly segregated by race in public facilities such as restaurants, churches, theaters, doctor's offices, buses, and the county fair. The schools of Charles County were not integrated until 1967.
The main incident described in the song took place in the early hours of February 9, 1963, at the white tie Spinsters' Ball at the Emerson Hotel in Baltimore. Using a toy cane, Zantzinger drunkenly assaulted at least three of the Emerson Hotel workers: a bellboy, a waitress, and — at about 1:30 in the morning of the 9th — Carroll, a 51-year-old barmaid. Carroll "had borne 10 children" (at least according to the song) and was president of a black social club.[not in citation given] According to a 1991 story in The Washington Post, Carroll was the mother of nine children.
Already drunk before he got to the Emerson Hotel that night, the 6'2" Zantzinger had assaulted employees at Eager House, a prestigious Baltimore restaurant, with the same cane. The cane was a 25-cent toy. At the Spinsters' Ball, he called a 30-year-old waitress a "nigger" and hit her with the cane; she fled the room in tears. Moments later, after ordering a bourbon that Carroll did not bring immediately, Zantzinger cursed her, called her a "nigger", then "you black son of a bitch", and struck her on the shoulder and across the head with the cane. In the words of the court notes: "He asked for a drink and called her 'a black bitch', and 'black s.o.b'. She replied, 'Just a moment' and started to prepare his drink. After a delay of perhaps a minute, he complained about her being slow and struck her a hard blow on her shoulder about half-way between the point of her shoulder and her neck." She handed him his drink. After striking Carroll, he attacked his own wife, knocking her to the ground and hitting her with his shoe.
Within five minutes from the time of the blow, Carroll leaned heavily against the barmaid next to her and complained of feeling ill. Carroll told co-workers, "I feel deathly ill, that man has upset me so." The barmaid and another employee helped Carroll to the kitchen. Her arm became numb, her speech thick. She collapsed and was hospitalized. Carroll died eight hours after the assault. Her autopsy showed hardened arteries, an enlarged heart and high blood pressure. A spinal tap confirmed brain hemorrhage as the cause of death. She died in Mercy Hospital at 9 a.m. on February 9, 1963.
Zantzinger was initially charged with murder. His defense was that he had been extremely drunk, and he claimed to have no memory of the attack. His charge was reduced to manslaughter and assault, based on the likelihood that it was her stress reaction to his verbal and physical abuse that led to the intracranial bleeding, rather than blunt-force trauma from the blow that left no lasting mark. On August 28, Zantzinger was convicted of both charges and sentenced to six months' imprisonment. Time magazine covered the sentencing:
In June, after Zantzinger's phalanx of five topflight attorneys won a change of venue to a court in Hagerstown, a three-judge panel reduced the murder charge to manslaughter. Following a three-day trial, Zantzinger was found guilty. For the assault on the hotel employees: a fine of $125. For the death of Hattie Carroll: six months in jail and a fine of $500. The judges considerately deferred the start of the jail sentence until September 15, to give Zantzinger time to harvest his tobacco crop.— Time, "Deferred Sentence", September 6, 1963.
After the sentence was announced, the New York Herald Tribune conjectured he was given a sentence that short to keep him out of the largely black state prison, reasoning his notoriety would make him a target for abuse there. Zantzinger served his time in the comparative safety of the Washington County county jail, some 70 miles (110 km) from the scene of the crime. In September, the Herald Tribune quoted Zantzinger on his sentence: "I'll just miss a lot of snow." His then-wife, Jane, was quoted saying, "Nobody treats his niggers as well as Billy does around here."
Zantzinger was convicted of manslaughter on August 28, 1963, and was not tried by a jury of peers but by a panel of three judges. The sentence was handed down on the same day that Martin Luther King, Jr. delivered his "I Have a Dream" speech in Washington. Bob Dylan, aged 22 at that time, was one of the celebrities at the march and on the journey home to New York City he read about the conviction of Zantzinger and decided to write a protest song about the case. According to a 1991 Washington Post report, Dylan wrote the song in Manhattan, sitting in an all-night cafe. A recent radio documentary on the song said rather that he wrote it both in New York and at the home of his then-lover, Joan Baez, in Carmel. According to Nancy Carlin, a friend of Baez who visited: "He would stand in this cubbyhole, beautiful view across the hills, and peck type on an old typewriter... there was an old piano up at Joan's... and peck piano playing... up until noon he would drink black coffee then switch over to red wine, quit about five or six." He recorded it on October 23, 1963, when the trial was still relatively fresh news, and incorporated it into his live repertoire immediately, before releasing the studio version on January 13, 1964.
The song juxtaposes Zantzinger's wealth and connections with the brevity of that sentence. Despite the song's topical nature, Dylan has continued to perform it in concert as of May 2009. His live-audience renditions of it appear on the albums The Bootleg Series Vol. 5: Bob Dylan Live 1975, The Rolling Thunder Revue (2002; recorded November 21, 1975), The Bootleg Series Vol. 6: Bob Dylan Live 1964, Concert at Philharmonic Hall (2004; recorded October 31, 1964), and Live 1962-1966: Rare Performances From The Copyright Collections (2018; recorded October 26, 1963).
In Chronicles: Volume One, Dylan includes "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll" in a list of his early songs which he feels were influenced by his introduction to the work of Bertolt Brecht and Kurt Weill. He describes writing out the words of "Pirate Jenny" (or "The Black Freighter") in order to understand how the Brecht–Weill song achieved its effect. Dylan writes: "Woody had never written a song like that. It wasn't a protest or a topical song and there was no love for people in it. I took the song apart and unzipped it—it was the free verse association, the structure and disregard for the known certainty of melodic pattern to make it seriously matter, give it its cutting edge. It also had the ideal chorus for the lyrics."
Literary critic Christopher Ricks considers the song to be "one of Dylan's greatest" and the recording on The Times They Are A-Changin' to be "perfect". He devotes an entire chapter to it, analyzing both the meaning as well as the prosody in his book on Dylan's songs as poetry. "But here is a song that could not be written better."
Dylan's song ("The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll") contains at least two inaccuracies. Zantzinger was not booked for first degree murder, but for second degree murder. Dylan also misspells and mispronounces Zantzinger's surname as "Zanzinger".
Impact on ZantzingerEdit
After serving his sentence for manslaughter, Zantzinger returned to running the farm in Charles County and began selling real estate. He moved to more urban Waldorf, Maryland, still within Charles County. Eventually he moved to a 2-acre (8,100 m2) home in Port Tobacco, where he lived throughout the 1990s until moving to a new home in St. Mary's County around 2001 in Chaptico, Maryland, called Bachelor's Hope.
In addition to federal tax delinquencies, Zantzinger fell more than $18,000 behind on county taxes on properties he owned in two Charles County communities called Patuxent Woods and Indian Head, shanties he leased to poor blacks. In 1986, the same year the IRS ruled against him, Charles County confiscated those properties. Nonetheless, Zantzinger continued to collect rents, raise rents, and even successfully prosecute his putative tenants for back rent. In June 1991, Zantzinger was initially charged with a single count of "deceptive trade practices." After some delay, Zantzinger pleaded guilty to 50 misdemeanor counts of unfair and deceptive trade practices. He was sentenced to 19 months in prison and a $50,000 fine. Some of his prison sentence was served in a work release program.
In 2001, Zantzinger discussed the song with Howard Sounes for Down the Highway, the Life of Bob Dylan. He dismissed the song as a "total lie" and claimed "It's actually had no effect upon my life", but expressed scorn for Dylan, saying, "He's a no-account son of a bitch, he's just like a scum of a scum bag of the earth, I should have sued him and put him in jail."
- Billy Bragg used the melody of Dylan's song for his own "The Lonesome Death of Rachel Corrie" in 2006, commemorating an activist who was killed in the Gaza Strip by an Israeli bulldozer in 2003.
- Phranc covered "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll" on her 1985 debut album, Folksinger, (Rhino), and released the cover as a single in 1986, on Stiff Records.
- Mason Jennings performed a cover of the song as part of the soundtrack to the 2007 film I'm Not There.
- Cage The Elephant covered "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll" on the album, Chimes of Freedom: The Songs of Bob Dylan Honoring 50 Years of Amnesty International in 2012.
- Paula Cole included the song on her 2017 Ballads.
- Judy Collins performed the song on her 1964 album The Judy Collins Concert.
- Carlson, Peter (August 4, 1991). "'A Regular Old Southern Maryland Boy'". The Washington Post. Washington DC: Nash Holdings LLC. Retrieved December 1, 2018.
- Ian Frazier (November–December 2004). "Legacy of a Lonesome Death". Mother Jones. Retrieved December 14, 2014.
- Douglas Martin, "W.D. Zantzinger, Subject of Dylan Song, Dies at 69", The New York Times, January 9, 2009.
- The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll, BBC Radio Four, May 17, 2010, presented by Dylan biographer Howard Sounes — in this programme a neighbour of Carroll from northwest Baltimore says she was the mother of eight children, not ten, although it is possible that only eight were alive at the time of their mother's death.
- "The Spinsters' Ball". Time. New York City: Time, Inc. February 22, 1963. Retrieved December 1, 2013. (Subscription required (help)). Cite uses deprecated parameter
- The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll, presented by Howard Sounes, BBC Radio 4, May 2010.
- BBC Radio 4 documentary, The Lonesome death of Hattie Carroll, presented by Howard Sounes, May 17, 2010.
- Gilliland, John (1969). "Show 31 - Ballad in Plain D: An introduction to the Bob Dylan era. [Part 1]" (audio). Pop Chronicles. University of North Texas Libraries. Track 5.
- Bob Dylan Glasgow concert (May 2, 2009), boblinks.com; accessed December 14, 2014.
- Dylan, Bob (2004). Chronicles, Vol. 1. New York City: Simon and Schuster. pp. 273–276. ISBN 978-0743272582.
- Ricks, Christopher (2003). Dylan's Visions of Sin. New York City: Ecco Books. pp. 15, 233. ISBN 978-0060599249.
- Ancestry Database: U.S. Phone and Address Directories, 1993–2002
- Frazier, Ian (24 February 2005). "Life after a lonesome death". The Guardian. London, England: Guardian Media Group. Retrieved 1 December 2018.
- Buckley, Stephen (June 7, 1991). "'Md. Man Charged in Rental Scam". Washington Post. Washington DC: Nash Holdings LLC. Retrieved December 1, 2018.
- "'Landlord' Indicted in Rent Theft", Washington Post, September 7, 1991.
- "Former Landlord Guilty on 50 Counts", Washington Post, November 19, 1991.
- "Landlord Sentenced", Washington Post, January 4, 1992.
- Meyer, Eugene L. (August 17, 1992). "A Neighborhood Lost – And Finally Found". The Washington Post. Washington DC: Nash Holdings LLC. Retrieved December 1, 2018.
- Cornwell, Rupert (January 12, 2009). "William Zantzinger: Subject of Bob Dylan ballad". The Independent. London, UK. Archived from the original on January 31, 2010. Retrieved May 25, 2010.
- Bragg, Billy (March 28, 2006). "The lonesome death of Rachel Corrie". The Guardian. London, UK. Retrieved January 28, 2017.
- Betts, Stephen L. (July 7, 2017). "Hear Paula Cole's Swampy Cover of Bobbie Gentry's 'Ode to Billie Joe'". Rolling Stone. Retrieved August 18, 2017.
- Frazier, Ian, "Legacy of a Lonely Death". Mother Jones, November/December 2004, 42–47; partial version on line. Reprinted by The Guardian February 25, 2005, as "Life after a lonesome death" (full version with the full song lyrics).
- "Farmer Convicted in Barmaid's Death", New York Times June 28, 1963. p. 11
- "Farmer Sentenced in Barmaid's Death", New York Times August 29, 1963. p. 15
- Dylan, Bob (2004). Chronicles: Volume One. Simon and Schuster. ISBN 0-7432-2815-4.
- Maryland Court Records
- "Legacy of a Lonesome Death", Mother Jones (November/December 2004)
- "Bob Dylan – The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll", SongMeanings.net; accessed August 24, 2015.
- "The Art of Bob Dylan's 'Hattie Carroll'", web.cecs.pdx.edu (1964 critique by Phil Ochs in Broadside Magazine)
- "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll", bobdylan.com; accessed August 24, 2015.
- "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll", bbc.co.uk (BBC Radio 4 programme); accessed August 24, 2015.