The Lie of the Land
"The Lie of the Land" is the eighth episode of the tenth series of the British science fiction television series Doctor Who. Written by Toby Whithouse, it was broadcast on 3 June 2017 on BBC One. "The Lie of the Land" received mixed reviews from television critics.
|272 – "The Lie of the Land"|
|Doctor Who episode|
Promotional image for the episode
|Directed by||Wayne Yip|
|Written by||Toby Whithouse|
|Produced by||Nikki Wilson|
|Executive producer(s)||Steven Moffat|
|Incidental music composer||Murray Gold|
|First broadcast||3 June 2017|
Continuing on after Bill (Pearl Mackie) gives her consent to the Monks, she and Nardole (Matt Lucas) have to find a way to rescue the Doctor (Peter Capaldi) after he is imprisoned, and end the Monk's invasion of Earth. It is the third and final of three loosely connected episodes called "The Monks Trilogy".
The Monks are rulers of the Earth, and appear to have been on Earth for millions of years, guiding human development. Bill and a few others are aware of the truth: the Monks have only been present on Earth for six months. Those who hold this view are imprisoned for "memory crimes". The Twelfth Doctor appears on television praising the Monks' guidance over humanity.
Bill keeps herself grounded in reality by imagining that she is talking with her long-dead mother, based on pictures the Doctor gave her. Nardole, also aware of the truth, locates Bill and helps her to find the prison hulk where the Doctor is thought to be a captive. Inside, after a team of commandos swarm inside, the Doctor tells Bill he is cooperating willingly with the Monks, believing that humanity was doomed without their guidance. Bill becomes distraught and shoots the Doctor, who appears to begin regenerating, but quickly stops. The entire scenario is revealed to have been a test by Nardole, the Doctor and the team, to make sure Bill was not under the influence of the Monks.
At the university where the Doctor and Bill work, they enter the Vault to talk to Missy, who says she has encountered the Monks before. She confirms the Monks maintain control by broadcasting a signal containing the false history to their subjugated victims via the numerous statues they have built across Earth, enabled by a psychic link established through the person who originally gave "consent"; Missy claims she defeated them during her own encounter by killing that individual. The implication is that Bill must die as the one who gave consent on Earth.
Believing there is another solution, the Doctor, Bill, Nardole, and the commandos infiltrate the Monks' pyramid in London so that the Doctor can hijack their broadcast with his own mind to break the psychic transmission. In the central chamber, the Doctor attempts to link his mind to the controlling Monk, who after a struggle overpowers the Doctor. Bill intends to sacrifice herself, linking her own mind to the Monks', despite the Doctor's protests. The Monks unintentionally replace their broadcast with images of Bill's mother, which the Doctor recognizes as a strong, loving memory in Bill's mind. Humanity recovers from the Monks' lies and rebels against them. The Doctor, Bill, and Nardole watch as the Monks abandon Earth. Sometime later, the Doctor and Bill find that most of humanity have no recollection of the Monks. In the Vault, Missy expresses remorse for those she has killed.
In images showing the Monks' aid to humanity, clips from the stories "Blink", "Nightmare in Silver" and "Into the Dalek" are shown. Later, a clip from "The Pilot" is shown, as well as several still images from past episodes of the new series. Magpie Electrical, which debuted in "The Idiot's Lantern" and recurs throughout the revival series, is shown as the shop where Bill watches one of the Doctor's broadcasts.
The read-through for "The Lie of the Land" took place on 11 January 2017. Filming took place, alongside the subsequent episode "Empress of Mars", from 16 January to 22 February 2017.
A scene was recorded featuring a family watching an episode of Casualty. This specialy filmed casualty scene included Casualty's Connie Beauchamp and Noel Garcia interacting with the Monks as part of the story line. Both characters were played by their regular actors Amanda Mealing and Tony Marshall. Despite being referred to in the Doctor Who Magazine preview of the episode, the scene was ultimately cut from the broadcast version.
Broadcast and receptionEdit
The episode was watched by 3.01 million overnight, the series' lowest overnight rating in its history at the time, after the rating of 3.10 million for Battlefield in 1989. This was due to the episode being placed directly against the Britain's Got Talent final. The episode received 4.82 million views overall, at the time the lowest official rating since the programme's return in 2005, and it received an Appreciation Index of 82.
|Rotten Tomatoes (Average Score)||7.28|
|Rotten Tomatoes (Tomatometer)||83%|
|The A.V. Club||B-|
|New York Magazine|||
"The Lie of the Land" received mixed reviews, with a number of reviewers finding it the weakest story in the season so far. The episode holds a score of 83% on Rotten Tomatoes, the site's consensus reading ""The Lie of the Land" closes a significant chapter for Doctor Who's tenth season—yet leaves some major characters' fates tantalizingly open."
Alasdair Wilkins of The A.V. Club gave the episode a score of B-, stating that he felt disappointed in the episode, and how script and its quality were "outpaced" by the skills of Capaldi's and Mackie's acting, stating that Capaldi was "great as ever but whose talents are sometimes misused in service of ideas the story won't commit to". He did, however, compliment Michelle Gomez for her role as Missy yet again.
Zoe Delahunty-Light of the SFX Magazine gave "The Lie of the Land" a perfect score of 5 stars out of 5, calling the episode "chilling", and complimenting the idea of the Monks taking over the human race and its development. She commented especially upon Pearl Mackie, complimenting her on her role in leading the episode, and her "uncanny ability to transition between emotions flawlessly", especially concerning her scenes with the Doctor and his apparent betrayal. Delahunty-Light also went on to praise how Missy finally got more screen time than she had received in previous episodes.
Ross Ruediger of the New York Magazine gave the episode 3 stars out of 5, stating that the episode starting out as "disturbingly effective", but goes on to certain questions that arose from the episode were "frustratingly unanswered". He also felt that the Monks had become far less of a danger than they had been in the previous episode, and how it made little sense that the Monks did not defend their leader when he became under attack by the thoughts of Bill and the Doctor. Overall, he stated that "The Lie of the Land" was a "disappointing conclusion to what was an otherwise killer story line".
Patrick Mulkern from Radio Times also gave the episode a lower rating, rewarding it a 2 stars out of 5. He felt that the worst part of the episode was the poor decision in getting a companion to fire a gun at the Doctor, how the viewers saw "nothing that would push her to such an extreme act", and stating the act as something that could not be "rationalised or condoned". He described the actors as being "blocked awkwardly" and how they appeared uncomfortable in the situation, though he complimented their acting overall throughout the episode.
- Hogan, Michael (20 May 2017). "Doctor Who: Extremis, series 10 episode 6: the Doctor meets the Pope". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 20 May 2017.
- "The Lie of the Land, Series 10, Doctor Who – The Lie of the Land: The Fact File – BBC One". BBC. Retrieved 5 June 2017.
- Dillon-Trenchard, Pete (3 June 2017). "Doctor Who: The Lie Of The Land geeky spots and Easter eggs". Den of Geek. Retrieved 5 June 2017.
- Fullerton, Huw (3 June 2017). "Did you spot a recurring Doctor Who Easter egg in The Lie of the Land?". Radio Times. Retrieved 5 June 2017.
- Pixley, Andrew (June 2018). "The Cutting-Room Floor". Doctor Who Magazine (525): 13.
- "The Lie of the Land – Overnight Viewing Figures". Doctor Who News. 4 June 2017. Retrieved 4 June 2017.
- Marcus (12 June 2017). "The Lie of the Land – Official Ratings". Doctor Who News. Retrieved 12 June 2017.
- Marcus (5 June 2017). "The Lie of the Land – Audience Appreciation:82". Doctor Who News. Retrieved 5 June 2017.
- "Doctor Who, Series 10, Episode 8, The Lie of the Land". Rotten Tomatoes. Retrieved 29 November 2018.
- Wilkins, Alasdair. "A frustrating Doctor Who lacks the courage of its convictions". The A.V. Club. Retrieved 5 June 2017.
- Serrao, Nivea (3 June 2017). "Doctor Who recap: 'The Lie of the Land'". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved 8 June 2017.
- Zoe Delahunty-Light (3 June 2017). "DOCTOR WHO S10.08 REVIEW: "A MASTERFUL ACT... THE DYSTOPIAN TONES ARE PALPABLE"". GamesRadar. Retrieved 8 June 2017.
- Nguyen, Hanh (3 June 2017). "'Doctor Who' Review: Bill and the Doctor Take On Fake News to Prove Resistance Matters". IndieWire. Retrieved 8 June 2017.
- Collura, Scott. "DOCTOR WHO: "THE LIE OF THE LAND" REVIEW". IGN. Scott Collura.
- Ruediger, Ross. "Doctor Who Recap: Alternative Facts". New York Magazine. Retrieved 8 June 2017.
- Patrick Mulkern (3 June 2017). "Doctor Who The Lie of the Land review: "showing Bill fire a gun at the Doctor is horribly misjudged"". Radio Times. Retrieved 8 June 2017.
- Jackson, Daniel (3 June 2017). "Doctor Who Series 10 Episode 8 The Lie Of The Land Review: Excellent performances wasted on a nonsensical trilogy". Daily Mirror. Retrieved 8 June 2017.
- "The Lie of the Land – Reaction". Doctor Who News. 5 June 2017. Retrieved 4 June 2017.