Talk:Decimus Junius Brutus Callaicus

Latest comment: 4 years ago by Chris.let in topic Image

2 Brutus edit

I'm confussed at how this Brutus could be in the times that are suggested here... This is linked from the Brutus that assasinated Caesar... if this is the case than this information must be wrong...?

Yes, the Decimus Junius Brutus who detained Mark Antony outside the Senate during Caesar's assassination was Decimus Junius Brutus Albinus; links leading here (and a quick glance indicates there are many of them) are incorrect. This article should probably be moved to Decimus Junius Brutus Callaicus, and Decimus Junius Brutus can be turned into a disambiguation page for Albinus and Callaicus. I can take care of that now. Correcting the incorrect links, however, is a more in depth project.
Incidentally, you can sign your talkpage posts either by just typing your name or by typing four tildes (~) in a row. Binabik80 21:46, 12 October 2005 (UTC)Reply


Irrelevant and misguiding references edit

The references from Strabo, Pomponius Mela and Pliny the Elder bear no relation with the content of this article. These three authors were geographers, not historians. Therefore, in none of them there is even a mention of the name Brutus, let alone of him crossing any rivers. Pliny the Elder 4.22 does not even deal with Hispania, it is about Cilicia (in Turkey); book 4 covers the geography of the Eastern Mediterranean, the Black Sea, continental and northern Europe, not Hispania.

Strabo in III.4 describes Hispania only south of the River Tagus. There is not even any mention of the Douro, the Limia or the Minho, let alone of Brutus.

Pomponius Mela 3.1 is a description of the coast of the Mediterranean which includes brief descriptions or mentions of the rivers of Lusitania and Galaecia. Again, there is no mention of Butus

Brutus could not have been proconsul of Lusitania with Gaius Marius. edit

  • In 113 BC there was not such a thing as the province of Lusitania and therefore there were no governors of Lusitinia. The province of Lusitania was established later by Augustus.Conflicts with Lusitanians were dealt with by the governor of Hispania Ulterior (Further Spain)
  • There was only one governor per province.
  • Neither Brutus nor Marius could have been proconsuls in 113 BC. In order to be a proconsuls, they would have had to have been consuls the previous year. Neither of them was.
  • In 113 BC Brutus was 67. He was too old to be given a governorship, which involved military command.

Image edit

There is an image described: "Decimus Junius Brutus crossing the "Lethes" (Limia River today). Photo taken 150 BC." how can a photo be taken 150BC? — Preceding unsigned comment added by Kakko1 (talkcontribs) 19:55, 20 October 2019 (UTC)Reply

Looks like vandalism to me - I just updated the caption. Chris.let (talk) 12:53, 24 October 2019 (UTC)Reply