Tomb of Kha and Merit

(Redirected from TT8)

The tomb of Kha and Merit, also known by its tomb number TT8, is the funerary chapel and burial place of the ancient Egyptian foreman Kha and his wife Merit, in the northern cemetery of the workmen's village of Deir el-Medina. Active during the mid-Eighteenth Dynasty, Kha supervised the workforce who constructed royal tombs in the reigns of pharaohs Amenhotep II, Thutmose IV and Amenhotep III (r. 1425 – 1353 BC). Of unknown background, he probably rose to this position through skill and was rewarded by at least one king. He and his wife Merit had three known children. Kha died in his 50s or 60s, while Merit died before him, seemingly unexpectedly, in her 30s.

Theban tomb TT8
Burial site of Kha and Merit
Plain-walled room densely packed with neatly arranged furniture and offerings
The burial chamber of Kha and Merit as discovered in 1906
TT8 is located in Egypt
TT8
TT8
Coordinates25°43′44″N 32°36′03″E / 25.7289°N 32.6009°E / 25.7289; 32.6009
LocationDeir el-Medina, Theban Necropolis
DiscoveredBefore 1818 (chapel)
15 February 1906 (tomb)
Excavated byErnesto Schiaparelli (1906)
Bernard Bruyère (1924)
DecorationOffering and feasting scenes (chapel)
Undecorated (tomb)
← Previous
TT7
Next →
TT9

The couple's pyramid-chapel was known since at least 1818 when one of their funerary stele was purchased by antiquarian Bernardino Drovetti. Scenes from the chapel were first copied in the 19th century by early Egyptologists including John Gardiner Wilkinson and Karl Lepsius. The paintings show Kha and Merit receiving offerings from their children and appearing before Osiris, god of the dead. The texts of the chapel were defaced during the reign of Akhenaten and later restored, indicating it was one of the oldest chapels in the village cemetery.

Kha and Merit's tomb was cut into the base of the cliffs opposite their chapel. This position allowed the entrance to be quickly buried by debris deposited by landslides and later tomb construction, hiding its location from ancient robbers. The undisturbed tomb was discovered in February 1906 in excavations led by the Egyptologist Ernesto Schiaparelli on behalf of the Italian Archaeological Mission. The burial chamber contained over 400 items including carefully arranged stools and beds, neatly stacked storage chests of personal belongings, clothing and tools, tables piled with foods such as bread, meats and fruit, and the couple's two large wooden sarcophagi housing their coffined mummies. Merit's body was fitted with a funerary mask; Kha was provided with one of the earliest known copies of Book of the Dead. Their mummies were never unwrapped. The use of X-rays, CT scanning and chemical analysis has revealed neither were embalmed in the typical fashion but are well preserved. Both wear metal jewellery beneath their bandages, although only Kha has funerary amulets.

Almost the entire contents of the tomb was awarded to the excavators and was shipped to Italy soon after the discovery. It has been on display in the Museo Egizio in Turin since its arrival and the exhibition has been reworked several times, most recently in 2015, where an entire gallery is dedicated to the exhibition of TT8.

Kha and Merit edit

N28
a
Y1
and
mriitB1
[1]
Kha and Merit
in hieroglyphs
Era: New Kingdom
(1550–1069 BC)

Kha (also rendered KhaꜤ[1] or Khai[2]) was a foreman for the village of Deir el-Medina during the mid-Eighteenth Dynasty.[3] Often referred to as an architect in modern publications, he supervised the workmen responsible for cutting and decorating royal tombs in the Valley of the Kings (known as "the Great Place"[4]) in the reigns of Amenhotep II, Thutmose IV, and Amenhotep III (r. 1425 – 1353 BC).[5][6] His origins are unknown. His only attested parent is his father, Iuy, who bears no titles and about whom nothing is known.[7][8] Given his lack of hereditary titles, Kha is assumed to have attained his position through skill.[5] The Egyptologist Barbara Russo suggests that his mentor or tutor was a man named Neferhebef, who has similar titles to Kha and whose name appears on items in Kha's tomb. Additionally, he is depicted alongside his wife Taiunes in Kha's funerary chapel.[9] Evidently the two had a close relationship but there is no evidence they were related.[7]

Kha likely began his career in the reign of Amenhotep II.[10] Ernesto Schiaparelli considered him to have been active in the reign of the preceding king, Thutmose III, based on the presence of seals bearing his name within the tomb[11] but this probably reflects the use of this king's name long after his reign.[12] Kha is generally thought to have been responsible for the design and cutting of the tombs of Amenhotep II, Thutmose IV, and Amenhotep III.[10] Russo proposes that Kha began his career under the supervision of Neferhebef, who oversaw the construction of the tomb of Amenhotep II.[13] He attained the role of "chief of the Great Place" (ḥry m st Ꜥꜣ(t)) during the reign of Thutmose IV and reached the peak of his career during the reign of Amenhotep III, when he was given the title of "overseer of (construction) works in the Great Place" (imy-r kꜣ(w)t m st Ꜥꜣ(t)). Russo suggests Kha entered the bureaucracy at the end of his career, based on his titles of "overseer of the works of the central administration" (imy-r kꜣ(w)t pr-Ꜥꜣ) and "royal scribe" (sš nswt).[14] His position as "royal scribe" is debated as it only appears on two staffs. Eleni Vassilika suggests "royal scribe" was an early position he held,[15] while Russo considers it was late in his career based on the style and intricacy of the staffs the title appears on.[16] Dimitri Laboury [fr] doubts the title referred to Kha at all, pointing to the many grammatical errors in texts in both the chapel and tomb, and posits the sticks were gifts from a colleague who bore the title.[17]

Kha enjoyed a successful career and received several royal gifts for his service. The first was a gilded cubit rod, given by Amenhotep II, and he later obtained a bronze pan from Amenhotep III. His most significant award was a "gold of honour", although which ruler it was given by is debated. Thutmose IV or Amenhotep III are considered the most likely candidates based on the style of the jewellery.[18][19] His mummy wears some of the jewellery he obtained, such as signet rings and a collar made of gold disc beads around his neck beneath his mummy wrappings.[20][21] Preparations for his tomb likely began in the reign of Thutmose IV, as his name occurs most frequently as a seal on vessels.[12] Based on the style of his coffins and the juvenilising art style seen on the painted funerary chests, Kha died in the reign of Amenhotep III, likely in his third decade of rule.[5][22] The period of his death can be further narrowed down to the last few years of Amenhotep's reign if, as Russo suggests, he is identical to the "royal scribe Kha" attested on jars from the palace complex of Malkata dating to the Sed (jubilee) festival in year 35.[23]

 
Kha and Merit receive offerings from two of their children on a painted chest.

Merit (also transcribed as Meryt[1]) was Kha's wife. She is titled "lady of the house" (nbt pr), a common title given to married women.[24][25] She likely died before Kha and unexpectedly as she is buried in a coffin intended for her husband. They had three known children: two sons named Amenemopet and Nakhteftaneb, and a daughter also named Merit (Merit II).[5] A third son named Userhat is sometimes attributed to them but his father is identified as Sau, a scribe of grain-keeping. Amenemopet also worked in Deir el-Medina and is titled "servant in the royal necropolis".[26] No title is given for Nakhteftaneb;[26] he seems to have been in charge of the funerary cult of his parents.[27] Merit II became a priestess of Amun.[28] All the children outlived their mother[5] but Amenemopet may have died before his father.[27]

Chapel edit

Location and description edit

 
Plan of the interior of the chapel of TT8

The funerary chapel of Kha and Merit is situated on a terrace at the northern end of the Deir el-Medina necropolis.[29][30][Note 1] The chapel sits at the back of a rectangular walled enclosure, the rear of which is cut back into the rocky hillside.[34][35] The square courtyard in front of the chapel measures approximately 8 by 8 metres (26 ft × 26 ft) and was likely entered through a small pylon-shaped gateway.[30]

The chapel is a small pyramid measuring 4.66 by 4.72 metres (15.3 ft × 15.5 ft) with an incline of 75 degrees, giving the structure a projected total height of 9.32 metres (30.6 ft). Constructed of mudbrick, the exterior was plastered and whitewashed.[34][36] It is one of few surviving Eighteenth Dynasty chapels from Deir el-Medina and is an early example of the pyramid form,[37] derived from the tombs of contemporary nobility.[38][30] This shape became typical for chapels in the workmen's village in later dynasties.[37][38] The chapel was in a ruined state by the time of European interest in it, during 19th and 20th centuries;[39] the exterior was partially restored by the Institut Français d'Archéologie Orientale (IFAO).[40] It is not open to tourists.[39]

The chapel faces the northeast and is entered through a single doorway with large doorposts. Nothing remains of the lintel and cornice they supported. Like other pyramid-chapels in the necropolis, there was probably a niche cut into the face of the pyramid, above the door, into which a small stele was set. The interior of the chapel is a single room measuring 3 by 1.6 metres (9.8 ft × 5.2 ft) with a vaulted ceiling 2.15 metres (7.1 ft) high. A niche in the back wall housed the stele now in the Museo Egizio, Turin, Italy. This wall is badly damaged, probably as a result of the removal of the stele.[41]

The chapel was topped by a pyramidion of whitewashed sandstone decorated on all sides with sunk bas-reliefs of Kha worshipping the sun god Ra and inscribed with hymns to the god at the stages of his journey: the east and damaged north faces adore Ra at sunrise, the south face praises him as he crosses the sky, and the west face worships Ra as he sets. The pyramidion was reused in antiquity for a small, anonymous pyramid-chapel near the courtyard of TT290, a few metres south-east of TT8 and was rediscovered by Bernard Bruyère on 8 February 1923.[40][42] It is now housed in the Louvre in Paris, France.[43]

Unusually, the tomb is not directly associated with the chapel itself, instead being cut into the base of the cliffs opposite.[43] In 1924, Bernard Bruyère excavated the courtyard to see if the presence of a burial shaft close to the area was the reason for the separation. On the right side of the courtyard, 3 metres (9.8 ft) from the entrance of the chapel, in the expected location of a shaft, he found a pit 0.75 metres (2.5 ft) deep and 1 metre (3.3 ft) wide lined with mudbrick. Schiaparelli suggested that this pit was where Kha's additional copy of the Book of the Dead and other funerary items, known before the discovery of the tomb, were originally deposited. Bruyère suggests the separation of chapel and tomb is instead due to the very poor quality rock beneath the courtyard.[44]

Decoration edit

 
Painted motifs found on the upper walls and ceilings of TT8's chapel, Metropolitan Museum of Art

The interior of the chapel was plastered and fully decorated. On stylistic grounds, it was completed in the reigns of either Thutmose IV or Amenhotep III.[45] As with the exterior, the decorative scheme mimics the types of scenes and layouts seen in the chapels of the elite. Kha likely employed his own skilled workmen to execute the decoration. Unlike the tombs of nobles, the texts have errors such as unconventional hieroglyph groupings and omitted signs indicating the artists had "limited hieroglyphic literacy".[46]

The brightly coloured paintings have drawn attention, being copied by several Egyptologists in the 19th century including John Gardiner Wilkinson and Karl Lepsius.[43] Ernesto Schiaparelli briefly described the chapel in his 1927 publication of the burial chamber; a full study of the decoration was made in the 1930s by Jeanne Marie Thérèse Vandier d'Abbadie during the IFAO's excavations of the village.[47]

The ceiling is covered with two different geometric and floral patterns separated by a central inscription. The vault is bordered on each side by another band of text and an upper frieze of alternating lotus flowers, buds, and grapes separates the inscriptions from the wall scenes proper.[41]

The back wall, now badly damaged, is divided into three registers around the central stele niche. A pair of Anubis-jackals face each other across a large bouquet in the uppermost, semi-circular register.[48] Unlike the rest of the decoration, this is executed on a light grey background.[49] In the second register, two men, one on the left and one on the right, kneel and offer bouquets. The left side of the lowest register shows Neferhebef and Taiunes seated with offerings before them and receiving ministrations from a man, on the right side of the register, dressed in the leopard skin of a sem-priest. He may be their son but his identity is unknown as the inscription is badly damaged.[1][49]

On the left wall Kha and Merit are depicted seated before an offering table in a banquet scene. Their daughter, also named Merit, bends to adjust her father's collar and one of their sons presents them with offerings. Below this scene, a narrow register depicts an additional offering of four amphorae, garlanded with flowers and fruit attended by a servant. The rest of the wall depicts guests and musicians. In a lower register, offering bearers advance in the opposite direction, towards a seated couple who are now mostly obliterated by damage.[50][51]

The right wall has the same layout as the left. The large scene depicts the god Osiris seated in a raised kiosk; he receives offerings from Kha and Merit, who are accompanied by their children. In the two smaller registers, servants approach with offerings of a goat or gazelle and a white ox wearing a floral garland.[52][53][54]

The decoration has received damage over the millennia since its execution. The first damage occurred only a decade or so after the chapel went into use during the reign of Amenhotep III's successor Akhenaten. The name of the god Amun was erased wherever it occurred as part of Akhenaten's iconoclasm against the deity.[55] It was later restored but in a way that does not match the original text. Later, all the faces of the figures were hammered out, possibly by Copts.[56] The decoration near to the door deteriorated further after the partial collapse of the ceiling in this area.[53] The chapel was also targeted by robbers. The back wall was damaged in the 19th century during the removal of the stele, and a hieratic graffito, mentioned by Lepsius in the 1840s, was destroyed sometime after his publication.[1][57]

Steles edit

 
Funerary stele of Kha, now in the Museo Egizio, Turin

A painted stone stele dedicated to Kha and Merit once stood in the niche in the back wall of the chapel. Around 1818 it was removed from the chapel and purchased by agents of Italian antiquarian Bernardino Drovetti.[58] In 1824 it was donated to the Museo Egizio as part of the Drovetti collection.[59] The first register depicts Kha adoring Osiris and Anubis, who sit back to back. In the second register, Kha and Merit, accompanied by a young child, sit before a table of offerings; their son Amenemopet stands on the far side officiating. The two lines of text at the bottom of the stele give offerings to the gods Amun, Ra, Ra-Horakhty, and Osiris, and ask for funerary offerings to be given.[53]

A second stele is housed in the British Museum. The large upper register depicts Thutmose IV offering floral bouquets and incense to an enthroned Amun and the deified Ahmose-Nefertari, who stands behind him; Kha kneels in adoration below them in the second register. This stele was likely originally made for the Kha of TT8 and was later restored and adapted by another Deir el-Medina foreman, Inherkau (whose name can be abbreviated to Kha), owner of TT299. The image of Amun, hacked out during the Amarna Period, was restored, and the name and titles of Inherkau's wife Henutdjuu were added in ink instead of being cut into the stone.[60]

Tomb edit

Given his role in the construction of royal tombs, Kha probably participated in the construction of his own tomb (and chapel) along with his sons or workmen.[61] Atypically for non-royal tombs, the burial chamber was not associated with the chapel but dug into the cliffs nearby. This separation contributed to the tomb escaping the attention of robbers,[62] as did its position at the base of the cliffs, which allowed the entrance to be covered by debris from landslides and later tombs cut above.[3][63]

Discovery and clearance edit

 
The entrance to TT8 at the time of its discovery

The tomb was discovered on 15 February 1906 during excavations conducted by the Italian Archaeological Mission headed by the Egyptologist Ernesto Schiaparelli.[3] The Mission began investigating the village of Deir el-Medina in 1905 and their 1906 excavation season focused on the village necropolis.[64] Knowing that Kha and Merit's chapel in the northern cemetery was older than the visible Twentieth Dynasty tombs in the area, Schiaparelli reasoned that Eighteenth Dynasty tombs were likely present at the base of the nearby cliffs, buried by debris from their own and later tomb construction. His excavations began at the mouth of the valley and proceeded towards the end. More than 250 workers, divided into several gangs, excavated for four weeks, uncovering only opened and robbed tombs; the discoloured limestone fill was mixed with bone, pottery, and cloth. In February 1906, after clearing two thirds of the valley, and 25 metres (82 ft) north of Kha and Merit's chapel, an area of clean white limestone chip was encountered. A further two days of digging uncovered an irregular opening with a set of roughly-cut descending stairs. The doorway at the base of the staircase was sealed by a plastered wall of stacked stones; a hole was made to admit the foreman Khalifa who confirmed the tomb beyond was unviolated. Two members of Schiaparelli's team, the supervisor Benvenuto Savina and Alessandro Casati, guarded the entrance overnight.[65][66]

 
Plan of the tomb of Kha and Merit

The following morning,[67] with the Inspector of Antiquities of Upper Egypt, Arthur Weigall, in attendance, the first wall was demolished, revealing a horizontal corridor. Less than 10 metres (33 ft) ahead was another intact blocking wall which opened into a taller, carefully cut passage. This section of corridor contained overflow from the burial chamber, including Kha's bed with bundles of persea branches underneath, a large lamp stand, baskets, jars, baskets of fruit, a wooden stool, and a whip with Kha's name written on it.[63][68] At the end of passage was a wooden door which Weigall said "looked for all the world as though it had been set up yesterday"[69] and locked with a wooden lock; the spring for the bolt was carefully sealed with clay.[69] A thin saw was inserted between the two planks of wood and used to cut the crossbars on the back of the door, allowing entry into the burial chamber and preserving the lock.[63]

Weigall was the first to enter the burial chamber, followed by Schiaparelli and members of his team.[63] The room was rectangular, measuring 5.6 by 3.4 metres (18 ft × 11 ft) with a 2.9 metres (9.5 ft) high barrel vaulted ceiling.[54] The walls were smoothed, plastered, and painted yellow but otherwise undecorated. The chamber was packed with objects, carefully ordered and arranged by members of the funeral party over 3000 years earlier. Kha and Merit's black wooden sarcophagi were placed against the back and right walls respectively, covered with linen palls. Against the left wall was Merit's bed, ready for use with sheets, blankets, and a pair of headrests. At its foot was her toilet box, and near it was her large wig box. Opposite, garlanded and standing on a chair, was a wooden statuette of Kha. The rest of the space was filled with stools piled with linen, tables laden with bread, sycamore and persea branches, pottery, alabaster, and bronze jars on stands and tables, stacked boxes, nets of doum palm fruit, and another lamp stand, similar to the one found outside the room. The excavators were struck by how fresh and undecayed the contents looked after three millennia; Weigall in particular commented that, from the state of the objects, the tomb seemed only to have been closed months beforehand.[70][63]

 
Egyptian excavators transporting the contents of TT8 to the Valley of the Queens

The tomb and its contents were recorded, photographed, and cleared in only three days, likely due to fear of theft. A single plan drawing was made which noted the locations of eighteen key objects, and few photos of the interior were taken. On 18 February 1906 the contents were transferred to the tomb of Amun-her-khepeshef (QV55) in the Valley of the Queens before being shipped to Cairo and ultimately to Italy.[30][71]

Schiaparelli published the discovery over 20 years later, in 1927, a year before his death. The large volume makes some omissions and mistakes in recalling the specifics of the discovery, such as neglecting to mention the date of the discovery,[72] stating that many of Kha's possessions were in a box too small for them, and saying that Merit's toilet box was unsealed.[73] The publication used a blank floor plan and only three photos of the burial chamber, leading to confusion regarding the positioning of objects such as the slatted table and senet board which are not included in the unpublished plan or seen in photographs.[74]

Contents edit

Discovered entirely intact and containing over 440 items, TT8 is considered the "most abundant and complete non-royal burial assemblage ever found in Egypt".[3] The majority of the objects were used by Kha and Merit in life, such as clothing and furniture. Clothing was laundered and neatly folded in baskets or chests, and some furniture was given a fresh coat of paint. Other pieces were made to be placed in the tomb, having painted decoration in imitation of expensive inlay work and hieroglyphic texts that are often full of grammatical errors. The various boxes and chests were labelled for the use of either Kha or Merit with brief inscriptions in ink.[75] Different kinds of breads, meats, vegetables, fruits and wine were also provided for the deceased to eat in the afterlife. Despite the large number of items within the tomb, they were carefully laid out in an orderly way that "suggested a tidying-up done that very morning".[76] The quality and quantity of objects is assumed to be typical of an upper-middle class burial.[21] Although less richly outfitted than noble or royal burials, it provides a more complete picture of the variety of food, clothing, and personal objects expected in burials during the mid-Eighteenth Dynasty.[21] Since 2017, the tomb's contents have been the subject of the "TT8 Project", a multidisciplinary and non-invasive study of all the objects, the full publication of which is planned for 2024.[3]

Personal possessions edit

 
Tunics and a clothing chest of Kha

The personal items belonging to the couple were found neatly stored in various boxes, chests, and baskets.[77] Kha's personal possessions make up the bulk of the objects, with some 196 items inscribed for him.[78] These included work tools such as a rare folding wooden cubit rod (in its own leather pouch),[79] scribal palettes, a drill, chisel, an adze, and a possible level. Among his cosmetics were bronze razors in a leather bag, a comb, and tubes of kohl. Also present were items for preparing and serving drinks, including a funnel, two metal strainers, a silver jar, and faience bowls.[77] His clothing, marked with his monogram, was stored in several boxes and a bag. All were made of linen and consisted of 59 loincloths and 19 tunics, and further rectangular pieces of fabric, identified by Schiaparelli as four shawls and 26 sashes or kilts; seven of these were knotted together with loincloths to form sets of clothing.[80][77] Other objects belonging to Kha were distributed around the tomb, such as four sticks (two with decorative bark inlay), and a traveling mat, folded on a net of doum palm nuts.[77]

 
Royal cubit rod of Kha, bearing the names of Amenhotep II, wood covered in gold leaf

Several items within the tomb were gifts to Kha from others. A cubit rod covered entirely in gold leaf and bearing the cartouches of Amenhotep II was likely an award from that king, although Kha's name does not appear on it.[81] Another royal gift was a large dish with the throne name of Amenhotep III inscribed on the handle. It was likely produced in the royal workshops and presumably given to Kha as part of a royal award.[82] A large metal situla bears the name and titles of Userhat, a priest of the funerary cults of Mutnofret, wife of Thutmose I, and Sitamun, daughter of Ahmose I. He likely worked in the west of Thebes, presumably the Deir el-Medina area, and the gift was in recognition of Kha's high status at the height of his career.[83] One of Kha's two scribal palettes dates to the reign of Thutmose IV and belonged to a high official named Amenmes, who was buried in TT118.[84] Among his titles was "overseer of all of the construction works of the king", meaning he oversaw all of the royal construction projects and in this role likely worked directly with Kha.[85] One stick was a gift from Neferhebef, with a dedicatory inscription recording that it was made by him, presumably for Kha, but the space where Kha's name would be inserted was left blank.[86] Another stick belonged to Khaemwaset, who likely worked alongside Kha as he also bears the title "chief of the Great Place". Kha's senet board had previously belonged to a man named Benermeret who was associated with the cult of Amun at Karnak temple, and who had it inscribed and decorated for his parents Neferhebef and Taiunes.[87]

 
Toilet box and vessels of Merit, containing various cosmetics such as kohl

Merit's personal possessions were much fewer than Kha's, and were placed beside her bed, near the door.[88] Egyptologist Lynn Meskell considers this difference in the quantity of items to be a reflection of the inequality between the sexes at the elite level of ancient Egyptian society.[89] A large wooden cabinet, 1.10 metres (3.6 ft) tall, contained her wig which Schiaparelli said "still shines with the perfumed oils that were applied to it".[88] It is one of the best surviving examples from ancient Egypt and represents the "enveloping" style of wig common during the Eighteenth and early Nineteenth Dynasties. It is made of locks of human hair styled into tight waves ending in tiny ringlets. At the back, the wig forms three thick plaits. It would not have been thick enough to entirely cover Merit's own hair when worn and would have been an addition to her own styled hair. Investigation using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry indicated the presence of plant oils and "balsam". As no fixative such as resin is present on the wig, it is suggested that it was styled by braiding when wet, and that the oils mentioned by Schiaparelli were meant to keep the hair soft.[90][91] Two smaller baskets contained personal effects such as needles, a razor, bone hairpins, combs, spare braids of hair, a tool possibly used to curl hair or wigs, and dried raisins. A large sheet, stained with oil but carefully stored, was considered by Schiaparelli to be Merit's dressing gown.[92][93] Merit's cosmetics were stored inside a box likely made especially for the funeral, with funerary inscriptions and painted in imitation of inlay. They consisted of a wooden comb and vessels of alabaster and faience holding ointments and oils; two objects were of multi-coloured glass – a small jar for oils and a kohl tube.[92][94]

Furniture and furnishings edit

 
View of the burial chamber showing the carefully arranged contents, including the chair, stools, and lampstand in front of the sarcophagi

The tomb contained many items of everyday furniture including stools, footrests, tables, and beds, sourced from the couple's house in Deir el-Medina.[Note 2] The most obvious funerary piece was a single high-backed chair, on which was placed a statuette of Kha. Like the other pieces, it has a funerary inscription but uses paint instead of costly inlay, and lacks wear on the strung seat. Fourteen stools of various forms were placed in the tomb; these were all items used by Kha and Merit in life. The most unusual example is a folding stool with a leather seat and legs ending in duck heads inlaid with ivory. The tables found in the tomb were simple, either of wood, or constructed of papyrus stems. A single small table had more elaborate construction, being made of wooden slats; it held Kha's senet box when found, which may have been its usual purpose. The largest pieces of furniture belonging to Kha and Merit were their beds, each with a strung cord mattress. Kha's bed was placed in the corridor outside the burial chamber due to lack of space within the room. Merit's was made up with sheets, blankets, and two headrests, one of which was entirely wrapped in fabric. Thirteen chests of varying sizes and styles made up the rest of the furniture placed within the tomb. All were of wood, plain or white-washed but five were painted in imitation of inlay and of these, three bore scenes of Kha and Merit receiving offerings from their sons.[97][98]

The two wooden lamp stands are the only examples of their kind from ancient Egypt. They are made in the shape of papyrus stalks with open umbels and approximately 1.5 metres (4.9 ft) tall. Only the example found inside the burial chamber had a bronze lamp, variously identified as having the shape of a leaf,[99] bird,[100] or bulti-fish;[101] it had been left half-full of fat with the wick burning when the tomb was closed.[102][103]

Food and drink edit

 
Baskets of herbs such as cumin were found alongside doum palm fruit and loaves of flatbread

The tomb was stocked with numerous foodstuffs which were piled on tables and in bowls, packed in amphorae, and stored in baskets. The most numerous category was bread which Schiaparelli said was of "a more varied and plentiful assortment than has been discovered in any other tomb or exists in any museum".[104] The bulk of the loaves were arranged on the low tables or packed within a large ceramic vessel. Most were of the standard round flat form but others were made into various shapes such as triangles, jars or trussed animals, or have grooves or holes that may suggest fertility. Wine was also well represented, the containers for which were labelled with their year and place of origin. Most were sealed but those that were open had evaporated over the millennia, leaving only a residue. Chunks of meat and roasted birds were stored salted in amphorae while salted fish were placed in bowls among the bread. Vegetable dishes consisted of minced and seasoned greens in bowls and jars accompanied by bundles of garlic and onions, and baskets of cumin seeds. Fruits included grapes, dates, figs, and nets of doum palm nuts.[105][106] Imported species were represented by a box of almonds (mixed with domestically-grown tiger nuts) and a basket of juniper berries.[107] Thirteen sealed alabaster vessels contained oils, seven of which Schiaparelli identified as the "seven sacred oils" used in funerary ritual. Also included was oil and salt for cooking and the fuel needed for the kitchen fire, in the form of dried cow dung.[105][106] Few of the sealed vessels were opened by Schiaparelli so the contents of sealed (and unsealed) containers have been investigated using non-invasive techniques such as X-ray fluorescence (XRF), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS), and types of mass spectrometry (MS), which has identified the presence of oils, fats, beeswax, and other organic compounds.[108][109]

Sarcophagi and coffins edit

 
The large sarcophagus or outer coffin of Kha

The largest items within the tomb were the two outer coffins (sarcophagi) containing the mummiform coffins and mummies of Kha and Merit.[110] Kha's was placed against the far wall, with Merit's positioned at a right angle to it against the long wall.[111] Both were covered by large linen sheets, the fabric covering Kha's being approximately 15 metres (49 ft) long and 2 metres (6.6 ft) wide.[112] The two sarcophagi are similar in style and construction, although they differ in size (Kha's is larger), and base (Kha's with sledge runners and Merit's without). Both are made of black-painted sycamore wood without any additional decoration.[113] Referred to as "bitumen" in Schiaparelli's publication, the black coating is made mainly of Pistacia resin and small amounts of other plant-derived products.[114] Similar sarcophagi with additional gilded or painted text and figures were found in the tombs of the contemporary nobles Yuya, his wife Thuya, and Maiherpri, but Schiaparelli remarks that sarcophagi of this type must "have been common to all high-ranking dignitaries, princes, and princesses" having found fragments of such boxes during his excavations in the Valley of the Queens.[112][115] Given their large size, they were brought into the tomb in sections and reassembled; marks made on the edges of each piece assisted in this task.[112]

 
Portrait of the gilded inner coffin of Kha

Kha's sarcophagus contained a further set of two nested coffins in human shape. Egyptologist Arielle Kozloff considers them "superb examples" of the wealth and craftsmanship seen during the reign of Amenhotep III.[116] They are of identical style and workmanship to those of the nobility, if of smaller size.[117] The outer coffin has a black-based design ornamented with gilding on the face, hands, wig, texts and figures.[116] When revealed, it was covered almost entirely by Kha's copy of the Book of the Dead.[118][5] Underneath, the neck of the coffin was draped with a garland made of melilot leaves, cornflowers, and lotus petals. The innermost coffin was entirely gilded.[118] The eyes and eyebrows are inlaid with quartz or rock crystal and black glass or obsidian, with blue glass for the eyebrows and cosmetic lines, all set into bronze or copper sockets. Across his chest is a broad collar with falcon-head terminals and below, his arms are crossed in the manner of Osiris, god of the dead. Below is the goddess Nut as a vulture with outstretched wings grasping two shen-signs in her talons.[119] Across the chest of this was placed a similar floral garland. The red-dyed flax ropes used to lower the inner coffin into the outer were still in place around the ankle and neck. Additionally, the inner coffin sat on a layer of natron inside the outer coffin. The lids of the coffins were closed with small wooden dowels.[118]

 
Side view of the coffin of Merit showing the gilded lid and black-based trough

Merit's sarcophagus contained only a single coffin wrapped in a linen shroud. The coffin was not made for her; it is much too large for her mummy and the inscriptions only name Kha.[120] Merit's coffin combines features of Kha's outer and inner coffins, with the lid being entirely gilded and the trough having a black-based design.[121] The discrepancy in design represents a merging of the typical two-coffin set into one.[122][123] Her coffin is of lesser quality than Kha's and is less costly;[124] the sculpting of the face is rougher, the figures of deities are roughly rendered, and the text is incised instead of being modeled in plaster.[122] The difference in quality is likely due to this coffin being commissioned by Kha earlier in his career, before he could afford a more expensive two-coffin set.[125] A large figure of the goddess Nut is painted on the interior of the coffin trough.[126] Merit likely died unexpectedly, resulting in a coffin made for her husband being used for her burial.[127]

Mummies edit

The wrapped mummies of Kha and Merit were found undisturbed within their coffins. Schiaparelli decided against unwrapping them, so the pair have been investigated with non-invasive methods. They were X-rayed in 1966 and 2014,[128] and CT scanned in 2002 at the Institute of Radiology in Turin[24] and again in 2016.[129] Neither had undergone a mummification procedure typical for the Eighteenth Dynasty; their internal organs were not removed, explaining the absence of canopic jars.[130] The lack of organ removal has led to suggestions that the bodies were treated using a shorter procedure, with little care,[131] or that they were not embalmed at all[124] despite their status. However, their organs, including their eyes and optic nerves, are excellently preserved. Chemical analysis of textile samples from their mummies indicate that they were both treated with an embalming recipe. Kha's consists of a mix of animal fat or plant oil and plant-derived extracts, gums, and conifer resin. Merit's is different, consisting of an unusual oil (fish) mixed with plant extracts, gums, resin, and beeswax; similar results, with the addition of Pistacia resin, were obtained from a sample of the red shroud that covered her mummy within the coffin. Both of these embalming recipes were made of costly ingredients that were hard to obtain, some of which were imported into Egypt, and would have had effective anti-bacterial and insecticidal properties. Natron, the main desiccating agent used in mummification, was also utilised within Kha's coffin and appears as white spots on the surface of Merit's wrappings. This study indicates that, contrary to previous opinions, their bodies were indeed embalmed, at significant effort and cost. That the methods used for them differ from the royal mummification method is not surprising, given the difference in status and the economics of Deir el-Medina; Bianucci and co-authors suggest that few in Deir el-Medina would have been mummified in the typical (royal) fashion.[132]

Kha edit

 
The wrapped mummy of Kha

The mummy of Kha is wrapped in many layers of linen and covered with a linen shroud. The shroud is secured by a double layer of linen bandages running down the centre of the body. This is crossed by four narrow bands at the shoulders, hips, knees, and ankles. Restoration work carried out in the 2000s used a nylon net to consolidate the outer layers of linen, weakened by a previous fungal attack.[133] Kha's mummy is not fitted with a funerary mask. It is generally thought that he donated his mask for his wife's burial[134] but the reason that he did not have another made for his own burial is unknown.[21][135] His body is 1.68 metres (5.5 ft) tall and he lies on his back with his arms extended; his hands are placed over the pubic area.[136]

Kha was 50 to 60 years old at the time of his death, with an estimated height of 1.71 metres (5.6 ft).[137] He was in reasonably good health at the time of his death. His teeth were in poor condition, having lost all the premolars and molars in the upper jaw and several molars in the bottom jaw. He had osteoarthritis in his knees and lower back[138] and many arteries show signs of calcification.[137] His gallbladder contained fourteen gallstones, judged to most likely be pigment stones.[139] His right elbow had an inflammation (enthesopathy) at the insertion point of the triceps brachii.[140] CT examination identified that Kha had fractured his first lumbar vertebra, an injury which left it flattened.[137] Later X-ray analysis considers this injury to have occurred after his death.[140] No attempt was made to remove his organs, which are still in place and are well preserved. There is a large air-filled gap between Kha's torso and the bandage layers, suggesting his body was not fully dried before wrapping.[131] His cause of death is unknown.[140] Despite his sarcophagus being placed in the furthest corner of the tomb, Kha is thought to have died after his wife, as some of his objects were placed in the corridor due to lack of space.[141]

 
Relief of Ay and his wife Tey receiving the "gold of honour" from Akhenaten. Multiple double-stranded shebyu collars are draped around their necks.

Kha's body is equipped with metal jewellery, likely of gold. Around his neck is a necklace of large gold discs beads known as a shebyu collar. This item of jewellery was given by the king as part of the "gold of honour", a reward for service. These necklaces are well known from ancient Egypt, being depicted in many statues and tombs of nobility including those of Sennefer, Ay and Horemheb.[142][143] Kha's collar has only a single strand of beads instead of the usual minimum of two, leading to the suggestion that this may be the longest, outermost strand of a multi-stranded shebyu collar.[144] He wears a pair of large earrings, one of the earliest known ancient Egyptian men to do so.[142] These may also have been part of his royal reward, as similar earrings are depicted, albeit more rarely, in "gold of honour" reward scenes.[145] Kha wears six finger rings; three have fixed oval bezels, one has a fixed rectangular bezel, and two have swiveling bezels of either faience or stone.[146] Further jewellery is purely funerary in nature. These consist of a stone heart scarab on a gold wire or chain, a stone or faience tyet amulet, and a gold foil bracelet around each upper arm.[137] On his forehead is a stone snake head amulet, likely in carnelian or jasper. The usual location of this amulet is around the neck, where it assists in the deceased's ability to breathe in the afterlife. Its placement on his forehead is possibly in imitation of the royal uraeus worn by kings.[146][147]

Merit edit

 
The collapsed and damaged mask of Merit soon after discovery

After raising the lid, Merit's mummy appeared like a vision, her head and part of the chest covered by a fine gilded mask and the head and body leaning slightly to the left, in the arms of the goddess Nut, painted on the inside of the box, in the languid and weary pose of a person resting and dreaming. The large frozen eyes of the mask, filled with an anguished expression, seemed to be staring at all of us standing around her, as if imploring us to leave her in peace.[127]

Merit's coffin, intended for Kha, is much too large for her and the space around her body was packed with fabric bearing her husband's monogram. A sheet of linen was folded into a pad placed under the mummy and the space under her feet and around her body was filled with eight rolls of bandages.[148] No padding was placed at the head end as the closed coffin would have been placed upright to receive funerary rites so there was no danger of the mummy sliding towards that end. When found, her body lay slanted to her left within the coffin, likely having moved during transport to the tomb.[149] The mummy was wrapped in a further sheet of linen over the top of the shroud, the end of which was tucked under her gilded mummy mask. Her white shroud is stitched up the back with a whip stitch using a thick cord.[148] In 2002 her mummy was sewed into a custom-dyed nylon net to consolidate the fabric.[147]

 
The restored mummy mask of Merit

Unlike Kha, Merit's mummy is fitted with a cartonnage mask. The mask is constructed from eight layers of linen covered in layers of white stucco primer. It has inlaid eyes, of which only one original remains, made of alabaster and obsidian with cosmetic lines and eyebrows of blue paste. The surface is covered in gold leaf now tarnished to a reddish colour, and the striped wig is coloured with Egyptian blue. The broad collar is composed of alternating bands of carnelian, dark blue paste imitating lapis lazuli, and turquoise. The pectoral below the collar is decorated with a blue and red painted vulture on a yellow ground. The mask was probably intended for Kha and was donated by him for his wife's burial. By the time of discovery the mask had sustained some damage, particularly to the back and sides, and one of the inlaid eyes was missing. This may be a result of the mask being much too big for Merit's head, leading to collapse once placed in the coffin.[147] Alternatively, the damage and the missing eye have been attributed to rough handling by Schiaparelli's workmen.[150][151] The mask was restored in 1967 but degraded quickly and further restoration was carried out in 2002, before being placed on a new padded mount in 2004. The back of the mask could not be restored as it was found detached underneath the mummy and had soaked up the oils and resins and flattened by the weight; it is now stored separately.[147]

Merit lies with her arms extended and hands nearly crossed over the pubis. Her age at death is estimated to be between 25 and 35.[131][152] Her body is 1.47 metres (4.8 ft) tall and estimates for her height in life vary between 1.48 metres (4.9 ft)[131] and 1.60 metres (5.2 ft).[152] She wears a long, crimped wig on her head,[129] which is turned slightly to the right. This twist is suggested to be the result of the method of wrapping her head, in which a right handed embalmer pulled on the left side of the bandages to tighten them as he wrapped.[147] Her teeth have little wear but some molars, premolars and a canine have been lost and others have cavities. She is less well-preserved than her husband, with many of her ribs and vertebrae broken and displaced due to postmortem damage to the torso. No attempt was made to remove her brain or other internal organs. Given that she was buried in a coffin intended for Kha, her death was likely unexpected but her cause of death is unknown.[153][131]

 
A gold ring in the Walters Art Museum with a similar design to the ring found behind Merit's mask

Like Kha, her body wears metal jewellery. Around her neck is a triple-strand necklace of fine gold beads; the strings have broken and the beads have scattered, with some being seen by her ankles. Across her chest and shoulders is a gold and stone broad collar similar in design to one from the burial of three foreign wives of Thutmose III[154] and the collars seen on the coffins and mask of Thuya.[155] Her ears are double pierced and she wears two pairs of ribbed hoop earrings. She wears four gold rings on her left hand; a further ring is seen behind her shoulder on X-ray and CT images. This ring has either been displaced from her finger by postmortem damage[154] or was intended for her right hand and forgotten during the wrapping process, being slipped into the shroud before burial.[134] A second gold ring was found during conservation work, stuck to the back of her mask in the embalming resins. The bezel is incised with an image of a Hathor-cow wearing a menat necklace and standing on a boat under a palm tree. This design is similar to a ring found on the body of Nefertity in tomb DM1159a.[134] Around her waist is a beaded girdle of metal cowrie shell-shaped beads interspersed with strings of small non-metal beads. Cowries are associated with fertility[134] and similar girdles are known from the burials of Sithathoriunet and three of Thutmose III's foreign wives. On each wrist are ten-stranded bracelets of metal and non-metal beads with a sliding catch. They appear to have the same design as the necklace and girdle and probably formed part of a set.[154][134] Merit was not equipped with any funerary amulets, possibly due to her unexpected death.[154]

Other funerary equipment edit

 
Kha and Merit before Osiris in a vignette from Kha's Book of the Dead

Kha's copy of the Book of the Dead, some 13 metres (43 ft) long, was found laid out atop his outer mummiform coffin. At the time of its discovery it was "perfectly conserved and as supple as if recently made".[118] It is one of the earliest copies known,[156] and the only one found in Deir el-Medina dating to the Eighteenth Dynasty.[157] It features colourful vignettes in which Kha is depicted generically, showing less customization than in the copies of Yuya and Maiherpri. It is written in cursive hieroglyphs which are closer in style to Maiherpri's[156] but the composition is more similar to Yuya's. A second copy of the Book of the Dead belonging to Kha is now in the Bibliothèque Nationale in Paris but its provenance is unknown.[157] It may originally have come from the pit Bruyère found in front of their chapel. This copy was likely intended for Merit as her name appears more often than Kha's, a unique instance in the Eighteenth Dynasty of a woman being provided with her own copy. Alternatively, it could be a separate copy which ultimately went unused and was put aside for reuse.[158]

 
Wooden statuette of Kha displayed as found in the tomb

A wooden funerary statuette was placed in the tomb, standing on a chair. The 43 cm (17 in) tall figure depicts a youthful Kha wearing a kilt, striding forward. Around the shoulders was a garland of melilot leaves; another was folded at its feet. The eyes and wig are painted and the column of text down the front of his kilt is filled with yellow pigment but the surface is otherwise plain. The inscription asks that his ka (soul) may receive "all that appears on the table of offerings to Amun, king of the gods".[159] The rectangular base is also inscribed with an offering formula ensuring Kha received the standard bread, beer, ox and fowl with the additional alabaster, linen, wine, and milk.[160] This item is not without parallel as there are occasional examples from other contemporary non-noble Theban tombs. However, given the number of similar wooden statuettes known, this practice was likely much more common. Such figures are generally absent from contemporary elite (robbed) burials, possibly indicating they were made of valuable metal and looted by ancient robbers.[161]

Kha was provided with two ushabti for his use in the afterlife. One is made of stone and the other is wooden and was provided with its own miniature sarcophagus and agricultural tools. These were placed immediately behind and in front of the statuette.[159][162] Merit was not given any ushabti. This inequality between the spouses is not unusual as a similar imbalance is seen in the burial of Yuya and Thuya.[149]

Location and display of objects edit

 
Display case in Museo Egizio, as seen in 2005

Following the discovery, Gaston Maspero, director of the Antiquities Service, awarded the majority of the contents of TT8 to the excavators. They are housed today in the Museo Egizio in Turin, Italy. The Egyptian Museum in Cairo retained few objects from the tomb, keeping one of the two lamp stands, loaves of bread, three blocks of salt, and nineteen pottery vases.[30] This may be because Maspero considered the contents of TT8 to be duplicates or not unlike anything already in the museum's collection.[163][164]

The contents of the tomb have been displayed since their arrival in Italy. Within months of arriving, the change in humidity affected the leather seats of the stools and the Book of the Dead, rendering them both fragile and cracked.[151] The objects were displayed within a single small room, refurbished in the 1960s, which gave visitors "a good idea of the place at the moment of discovery".[126][165] They were moved to a larger gallery in the 2000s, and redisplayed again in 2015 in an even more spacious gallery after the Museo Egizio underwent extensive renovations.[165]

Notes edit

  1. ^ The chapel has the number TT8. The standard numbering system for private tombs in the Theban necropolis was implemented by the Antiquities Service in the early 1900s and published by the Egyptologists Alan Gardiner and Arthur Weigall in 1913. Tombs and chapels discovered later were added in sequence.[31][32] Kha and Merit's burial chamber, located separately from their chapel, was initially given the tomb number 269 before being connected with the existing chapel number.[33]
  2. ^ Kha and Merit are presumed to have lived in Deir el-Medina.[95] No house can be definitely assigned to the couple. Vassilika and Russo consider the possibility that they lived temporarily in the village during work periods and had a separate residence elsewhere, based on the large quantity of furniture and the small house sizes in the workmen's village.[61][96]

References edit

Citations edit

  1. ^ a b c d e Porter & Moss 1960, pp. 16–18.
  2. ^ Eaton-Krauss 1999, p. 128.
  3. ^ a b c d e La Nasa et al. 2022, p. 1.
  4. ^ Reeves & Wilkinson 1996, p. 18.
  5. ^ a b c d e f Bianucci et al. 2015, p. 4.
  6. ^ Ferraris 2018, p. 12.
  7. ^ a b Russo 2012, p. 67.
  8. ^ Töpfer 2019, p. 12.
  9. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 22, 77.
  10. ^ a b Forbes 1998, p. 112.
  11. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, p. 60.
  12. ^ a b Trapani 2012, p. 167.
  13. ^ Russo 2012, p. 73.
  14. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 67–69.
  15. ^ Vassilika 2010, p. 7.
  16. ^ Russo 2012, p. 70.
  17. ^ Laboury 2023, p. 127.
  18. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 23, 31.
  19. ^ Binder 2008, p. 240.
  20. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 24, 31.
  21. ^ a b c d Forbes 1998, p. 113.
  22. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 102.
  23. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 63, 78.
  24. ^ a b Martina et al. 2005, p. 42.
  25. ^ Koltsida 2007, p. 125.
  26. ^ a b Trapani 2015, pp. 2221–2222.
  27. ^ a b Russo 2012, p. 66.
  28. ^ Vassilika 2010, p. 9.
  29. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 132.
  30. ^ a b c d e Sousa 2019, p. 63.
  31. ^ Porter & Moss 1960, p. vii.
  32. ^ Gardiner & Weigall 1913, p. 10.
  33. ^ Bruyère 1925, p. 53.
  34. ^ a b Vandier d'Abbadie 1939, p. 2.
  35. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, p. 56.
  36. ^ Bruyère 1924, p. 53.
  37. ^ a b Meskell 1998, p. 371.
  38. ^ a b Russo 2012, p. 64.
  39. ^ a b Forbes 1998, p. 135.
  40. ^ a b Ferraris 2022, p. 610.
  41. ^ a b Vandier d'Abbadie 1939, p. 4.
  42. ^ Bruyère 1924, pp. 51–54.
  43. ^ a b c Hobson 1987, pp. 118–119.
  44. ^ Bruyère 1925, pp. 53–55.
  45. ^ Russo 2012, p. 22.
  46. ^ Laboury 2023, pp. 126–127.
  47. ^ Vandier d'Abbadie 1939, p. 1.
  48. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, p. 58.
  49. ^ a b Vandier d'Abbadie 1939, p. 5.
  50. ^ Porter & Moss 1960, p. 1618.
  51. ^ Vandier d'Abbadie 1939, pp. 5–7.
  52. ^ Vandier d'Abbadie 1939, p. 7.
  53. ^ a b c Schiaparelli 2008, p. 57.
  54. ^ a b Sousa 2019, p. 64.
  55. ^ Wilkinson 2003, p. 97.
  56. ^ Vandier d'Abbadie 1939, p. 8.
  57. ^ Vandier d'Abbadie 1939, pp. 5, 8.
  58. ^ Del Vesco & Poole 2018, pp. 98–99.
  59. ^ Bianucci et al. 2015, p. 2.
  60. ^ Eaton-Krauss 1999, pp. 127–128.
  61. ^ a b Vassilika 2010, p. 10.
  62. ^ Russo 2012, p. 4.
  63. ^ a b c d e Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 15–17.
  64. ^ Del Vesco & Poole 2018, p. 107.
  65. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 15–16.
  66. ^ Vassilika 2010, p. 8.
  67. ^ Vassilika 2010, p. 22.
  68. ^ Weigall 1911, pp. 178–179.
  69. ^ a b Weigall 1911, p. 178.
  70. ^ Weigall 1911, pp. 180–182.
  71. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 61.
  72. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 114.
  73. ^ Vassilika 2010, pp. 25–26.
  74. ^ Vassilika 2010, pp. 22–23.
  75. ^ Vassilika 2010, pp. 13–16.
  76. ^ Weigall 1911.
  77. ^ a b c d Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 28–33.
  78. ^ Meskell 1998, p. 372.
  79. ^ Nishimoto 2017, p. 450.
  80. ^ Sousa 2019, p. 73.
  81. ^ Russo 2012, p. 11.
  82. ^ Russo 2012, p. 45.
  83. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 46–47.
  84. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 22–23.
  85. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 36, 77.
  86. ^ Russo 2012, pp. 19–20.
  87. ^ Russo 2012, p. 18.
  88. ^ a b Schiaparelli 2008, p. 33.
  89. ^ Meskell 1998, p. 376.
  90. ^ a b Buckley & Fletcher 2016.
  91. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 85.
  92. ^ a b Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 33–34.
  93. ^ Forbes 1998, pp. 84–85.
  94. ^ Forbes 1998, pp. 86–87.
  95. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 88.
  96. ^ Russo 2012, p. 65.
  97. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 37–40.
  98. ^ Forbes 1998, pp. 87–92.
  99. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 93.
  100. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, p. 44.
  101. ^ Wilkinson 1992, p. 111.
  102. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 43–44.
  103. ^ Forbes 1998, pp. 92–93.
  104. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 46–47.
  105. ^ a b Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 46–50.
  106. ^ a b Forbes 1998, pp. 105–108.
  107. ^ Shahat 2019, p. 69-70.
  108. ^ Festa et al. 2021.
  109. ^ La Nasa et al. 2022.
  110. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 63.
  111. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 144.
  112. ^ a b c Schiaparelli 2008, p. 19.
  113. ^ Forbes 1998, pp. 63–64.
  114. ^ Bianucci et al. 2015, p. 15.
  115. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 64.
  116. ^ a b Kozloff 1998, p. 118.
  117. ^ Forbes 1998, pp. 65–68.
  118. ^ a b c d Schiaparelli 2008, p. 20.
  119. ^ Kozloff 1998, pp. 118–119.
  120. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, pp. 21–22.
  121. ^ Schiaparelli 2008, p. 21.
  122. ^ a b Sousa 2019, p. 80.
  123. ^ Bettum 2018, p. 285.
  124. ^ a b Meskell 1998, p. 373.
  125. ^ Sousa 2019, p. 89.
  126. ^ a b Curto & Mancini 1968, p. 77.
  127. ^ a b Schiaparelli 2008, p. 22.
  128. ^ Bianucci et al. 2015, pp. 4–6.
  129. ^ a b Gordan-Rastelli 2019, p. 51.
  130. ^ Bianucci et al. 2015, p. 3.
  131. ^ a b c d e Martina et al. 2005, p. 44.
  132. ^ Bianucci et al. 2015, pp. 16–18.
  133. ^ Marochetti et al. 2005, p. 243.
  134. ^ a b c d e Marochetti et al. 2005, p. 246.
  135. ^ Casini 2017, p. 66.
  136. ^ Bianucci et al. 2015, p. 6.
  137. ^ a b c d Martina et al. 2005, p. 43.
  138. ^ Bianucci et al. 2015, pp. 6–7.
  139. ^ Cesarani et al. 2009, p. 1194.
  140. ^ a b c Bianucci et al. 2015, p. 7.
  141. ^ Forbes 1998, p. 113, 144.
  142. ^ a b Bianucci et al. 2015, pp. 12–13.
  143. ^ Brand 2006, pp. 17–18.
  144. ^ Binder 2008, p. 43.
  145. ^ Trapani 2015, pp. 2222–2223.
  146. ^ a b Bianucci et al. 2015, p. 13.
  147. ^ a b c d e Marochetti et al. 2005, p. 245.
  148. ^ a b Marochetti et al. 2005, p. 244.
  149. ^ a b Forbes 1998, p. 75.
  150. ^ Curto & Mancini 1968, pp. 77–78.
  151. ^ a b Vassilika 2010, p. 27.
  152. ^ a b Bianucci et al. 2015, p. 9.
  153. ^ Bianucci et al. 2015, pp. 9–11.
  154. ^ a b c d Bianucci et al. 2015, pp. 14–15.
  155. ^ Russo 2012, p. 31.
  156. ^ a b Forbes 1998, p. 121.
  157. ^ a b Trapani 2012, p. 166.
  158. ^ Vassilika 2010, p. 77.
  159. ^ a b Schiaparelli 2008, p. 26.
  160. ^ Sousa 2019, p. 66.
  161. ^ Smith 1992, p. 200.
  162. ^ Sousa 2019, pp. 74–75.
  163. ^ Forbes 1998, pp. 61–63.
  164. ^ Vassilika 2010, p. 24.
  165. ^ a b Forbes 1998, pp. 114–115.

Works cited edit

External links edit