Shinagawa no Tsuki, Yoshiwara no Hana, and Fukagawa no Yuki
Beginning in the late 18th the Japanese ukiyo-e artist Kitagawa Utamaro (c. 1753 – 1806) produced three hanging-scroll paintings for the prominent merchant Zenno Ihē. The themes of the paintings are "moon", "flowers", and "snow", and are named Shinagawa no Tsuki (品川の月, "Moon in Shinagawa"), Yoshiwara no Hana (吉原の花, "Flowers in Yoshiwara"), and Fukagawa no Yuki (深川の雪, "Snow in Fukagawa")
The paintings have a reputation as Utamaro's most ambitious works. They are unusually large and were executed in high-quality coloured pigments on imported Chinese Xuan paper. Utamaro made the paintings from about 1788 to about 1801–04; it is not known why they took so long to complete. In the 1880s they came into European collections and were soon split up; two are now in American collections, and the other is back in Japan. After their first known public display together in 1879 they were not exhibited together again until 2016.
Ukiyo-e art flourished in Japan during the Edo period from the 17th to 19th centuries, and took as its primary subjects courtesans, kabuki actors, and others associated with the "floating world" lifestyle of the pleasure districts. Alongside paintings, mass-produced woodblock prints were a major form of the genre. In the mid-18th century full-colour nishiki-e prints became common, printed using a large number of woodblocks, one for each colour. A prominent genre was bijin-ga ("pictures of beauties"), which depicted most often courtesans and geisha at leisure, and promoted the entertainments of the pleasure districts.
Kitagawa Utamaro (c. 1753–1806) made his name in the 1790s with his bijin ōkubi-e ("large-headed pictures of beautiful women") portraits, focusing on the head and upper torso, a style others had previously employed in portraits of kabuki actors. Utamaro experimented with line, colour, and printing techniques to bring out subtle differences in the features, expressions, and backdrops of subjects from a wide variety of class and background. Utamaro's individuated beauties were in sharp contrast to the stereotyped, idealized images that had been the norm.
Utamaro is less known for his paintings (nikuhitsu-ga) than for the large number of wooblock prints he produced, of which about 2000 are known. 53 of his paintings are known, many of which have been discovered only in the 21st century. Utamaro's paintings have received relatively little critical attention.
Execution and historyEdit
The earliest of the paintings was made c. 1788 and the last c. 1801–04. They are dated based on comparison to the styles Utamaro used in his other works. It is unknown why the paintings took so long to execute, or whether Utamaro executed them alone or with the help of those in his workshop. The paintings are unsigned, and are the only known paintings Utamaro did not sign.
The paintings were commissioned by the prominent merchant Zenno Ihē[a] of Shimotsuke Province (roughly modern Tochigi Prefecture). The city of Tochigi prospered as a trading centre connected by waterways to Edo (modern Tokyo); the arts also thrived there, and Utamaro had connections with those in Tochigi's kyōka poetry circles. Ihē was the uncle of Zenno Kihē IV,[b] a poet who had his work published in kyōka anthologies that included poems by Utamaro.[c] A find of seven Utamaro paintings in Tochigi in 1936 indicates a relationship with the city and has brought speculation that he travelled there. He is said to have visited Tochigi at least three times, though certain evidence of this has not been found, and the shop the Zennos owned had an Edo branch where Utamaro could have had contact with Ihē.
The first record[d] of the paintings' public display together was in 1879, when a member of the Zenno merchant family had them at the temple Jōgan-ji[e] in the city of Tochigi on 23 November 1879. It is not know what happened to the paintings after this, but at the height of the popularity of Japonism in the Western world, Yoshiwara no Hana and Fukagawa no Yuki somehow came into the possession of the Parisian art dealer Siegfried Bing, who photographed them in 1887. He bought Shinagawa no Tsuki some years later, and a Japanese collector later purchased it and brought it back to Japan in 1939. Its whereabouts became unknown after an exhibition in 1948, until its rediscovery in 2012. The other two were purchased by American art galleries. The three were not displayed together again until 2016, when they were brought together for display at the Wadsworth Atheneum.
The paintings have a reputation as Utamaro's most ambitious works. According to the art historian Shūgō Asano, "The snow—moon—flowers paintings are extraordinary even amongst Utamaro's nikuhitsu-ga paintings."[f] To the art historian Tadashi Kobayashi, the paintings' "compositional power and dynamic postures are magnificent".[g]
Description and analysisEdit
The paintings are on the themes of "moon" (Shinagawa no Tsuki), "flowers" (Yoshiwara no Hana), and "snow" (Fukagawa no Yuki); "Moon", "flowers", and "snow" was a popular traditional artistic theme in Japan. Utamaro depicts one of the three most representative officially-approved yūkaku pleasure districts in each of the paintings: Yoshiwara, Shinagawa, and Fukagawa. There are no male figures in any of the three paintings, though as yūkakus existed for male pleasure, the exclusion was almost certainly deliberate.
The three paintings are Utamaro's largest known works. They depict extravagantly-dressed women such as courtesans and geishas of the pleasure districts; these women would have been surrounded by men demanding their services in real life, but no men appear in the paintings. On the kimonos of the women in each of Shinagawa no Tsuki and Fukagawa no Yuki appears the kumaizasa[h]—the nine-leafed sasa mon crest of the Zenno family.
It was rare for paintings to be of such a large size. They are on Xuan paper, a type of paper made in China. Edo-period Japan had not developed the skill to make it, and as the Japanese government maintained a policy of isolation with severely restricted foreign trade, Zenno may have obtained the paper for Utamaro in secret. The inks are believed to be of a particularly high quality, from evidence such that when cleaned with water they do not smudge. Executing the paintings would have required a large working space with carefully controlled humidity. These conditions suggests a great expense went into the paintings, and point to an extremely high regard for Utamaro as an artist.
Shinagawa no TsukiEdit
Shinagawa no Tsuki (品川の月, "Moon in Shinagawa", late 18th century) is also known as Tsukimi no Zashiki Zu (月見の座敷図, "Picture of parlour moon-viewing") or Moonlight Revelry at Dozō Sagami. The horizontal painting is a hanging scroll in ink on two joined sheets of Xuan paper together measuring 147.4 by 321 centimetres (58 in × 126 in). It was made c. 1788 and is believed to be the first of the series. It resides in the collection of the Freer Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C.
The scene takes place at an evening party under a full moon in a two-story yūkaku pleasure house called the Sagamiya (相模屋, also called the Dozō Sagami 土蔵相模) in Shinagawa, near the administrative capital of Edo. It was owned by Sagamiya Chūbei[i] and was the most prosperous pleasure house in Shinagawa.
Utamaro places sixteen figures throughout the painting, all of whom are women with the exception of a young boy playing at the mid-left, and the shadow of a man smoking behind a shōji door further behind the boy. The point of view looks out on the sea, and the moon appears over it in the distance to the right. Utamaro uses an elevated point of view traditional to Japanese art while employing European-style geometric perspective principles to give the architecture a sense of depth. Such techniques began to have an influence on Japanese art in the 18th century. Utamaro was yet to develop a distinct style of his own at this point, and the influence of Torii Kiyonaga on his depiction of the figures is strong.
|Japanese text||Romanized Japanese||English translation|
Kamaya Ihē commissioned the paintings in the late 18th century. Shinagawa no Tsuki was in the collection of the Paris-based Japanese art dealer Tadamasa Hayashi (1853–1906). In 1903 Charles Lang Freer obtained it from Hayashi and later donated it to the Freer Gallery of Art, where it now resides.
Yoshiwara no HanaEdit
Yoshiwara no Hana (吉原の花, "Flowers in Yoshiwara", c. 1791–92) is believed to have been the second executed in the series. The horizontal painting is a hanging scroll of eight joined sheets of Xuan paper, together measuring 186.7 by 256.9 centimetres (73.5 in × 101.1 in), and executed in ink in c. 1791–92. Since 1957 it has resided in the collection of the Wadsworth Atheneum in Hartford, Connecticut.
The painting shows a hanami cherry blossom–viewing party in the Yoshiwara pleasure district in Edo. 45 figures appear in it. The scene is a teahouse, though one of a more exaggerated grandeur than a real one. A sign of spring, sakura cherry-blossom petals fall all around, and azaleas bloom in the bottom right.
The women are of different ranks and status, signified by their manner of dress and haristyles—the more complex, the higher the rank. In the bottom left is a group of women led by high-ranking oiran courtesans in bright reds and blues. They are identifiable as oiran from having their obi sashes tied at the front of them. In the centre sits another oiran on a deep red carpet wearing an uchikake bridal robe.
On the second floor sit a number of women wearing katahazushi hairstyles and dressed in the manner the women-in-waiting of the households of high-ranking samurais or daimyōs (feudal lords). They are spectators to a dance performance—what appears to be a zashiki kyōgen, which is a style of kabuki theatre adapted to performance in private samurai homes. The women to the left play music on shamisen plucked-string instruments and tsuzumi hand-drums for the dancers.
Fukagawa no YukiEdit
Fukagawa no Yuki (深川の雪, "Snow in Fukagawa") depicts a temporary brothel in Fukagawa with the theme snow. The horizontal painting is a hanging scroll in coloured pigments on eight joined sheets of Xuan paper, together measuring 198.8 by 341.1 centimetres (78.3 in × 134.3 in). The painting resides in the collection of the Okada Museum of Art in the town of Hakone in Japan.
Utamaro achieves a strong compositional balance despite the painting's complexity. He distributes 27 figures throughout it amongst several buildings, such as a teahouse duplexes and a second-storey restaurant-teahouse at the left. The main building appears to be a two-story restaurant-teahouse; the picture focuses on an atrium with a garden court in the middle surrounded by railings, revealing the snowy outdoors. With the exception of the young boy who reaches out at a cat in the lower left, all the figures are women, though in real life the guests of a pleasure house would be men. Several of the figures pose in a manner similar to those in the book Seirō Ehon Nenjū Gyōji[j] (1804) that Utamaro illustrated around the time he completed this painting, such as the woman looking behind her in the hallway in the centre, the woman with her arm wrapped around a pillar in the centre, and the woman crouched down near her with her hand on the railing, looking to the right behind her.
Several women lean over the rails to check the snow. A woman in the bottom left stops and looks down behind her at a cat tugging at her kimono; the kimono bears the Zenno family's kumaizasa crest on the shoulder. In the middle a woman carries a tray of food along the hallway. A group of guests sits around a hibachi heating device in a room at the right. In the upper right a woman carries a large furoshiki bundle full of the courtesans' and geishas' bedclothes.[k] Several women in a back room sit playing hand games. The women's kimonos tend to be of subdued colours such as indigo or brown, in contrast with the bright, flashy colours of the other two paintings.
It is believed Utamaro made the painting in c. 1801–04. The ukiyo-e collector Takeo Nagase[l] purchased Fukagawa no Yuki in Paris from an ukiyo-e art dealer from Japan and brought it back to Japan in 1939. It was displayed in an exhibition[m] at the Matsuzakaya department store in the Ginza district of Tokyo in 1948. Thereafter the painting's whereabouts became unknown, and researchers made do with only black-and-white photography. The art dealer Seiichirō Teramoto rediscovered it in January 2012, and had its authenticity confirmed by Shūgō Asano. It was purchased by the Okada Museum of Art, which has declined to name who had it or where it was found. It has since had touch-up work done by a Chinese restorer.
- 善野 伊兵衛 Zenno Ihē
- ４代目善野喜兵衛 Yon-daime Zenno Kihē, who published poetry under the name Tsūyōtei Tokunari 通用亭 徳成
- Utamaro published poetry under the name Fude no Ayamaru 筆綾丸.
- The catalogue for the event lists the paintings as: 「雪月花図紙本大物 三幅対 善野氏蔵」 Setsugekka-zu shihon mono, sanpukuzui, Zenno-shi Zō, "Pictures of snow, moon, flowers; set of three; owned by Zenno"
- 定願寺 Jōgan-ji
- 「歌麿の肉筆画の中でも『雪月花』は別格」"Utamaro no nikuhitsu-ga no naka de mo Setsugekka wa bekkaku."
- 構成力・群像表現はすばらしい "Kōsei-ryoku, gunzō-hyōgen ha subarashii."
- 九枚笹 kumaizasa, "nine sasa leaves"; mai is a Japanese counter word for flat things.
- 相良屋 忠兵衛 Sagamiya Chūbei
- 青楼絵本年中行事 Seirō Ehon Nenjū Gyōji
- This was a custom of the Fukagawa pleasure district.
- 長瀬 武郎 Nagase Takeo
- 第２回浮世絵名作展覧会 Dai-nikai Ukiyo-e Meisaku Tenrankai, "Second Famous Works of Ukiyo-e Exhibition"
- Fitzhugh 1979, p. 27.
- Kobayashi 1997, pp. 80–83.
- Harris 2011, p. 60.
- Kobayashi 1997, pp. 87–88.
- Kobayashi 1997, p. 88.
- Asano 2016, p. 110.
- Yomiuri Shimbun staff 2014.
- Shimomura 1991, p. 123.
- Dunne 2017.
- Higuchi 2014, p. 238.
- Asano 2016, pp. 123–124, 126.
- Asano 2016, p. 111.
- Kobayashi 2006, p. 26.
- Higuchi 2014, p. 237.
- Narazaki 1981, p. 49.
- Middletown Press staff 2016.
- Yomiuri Shimbun staff 2014a.
- Takahashi 2016.
- Shimomura 1991, p. 124.
- Asano 2016, p. 126.
- Smithsonian staff 2017.
- Freer Gallery of Art staff.
- Narazaki 1981, p. 48.
- Asano 2016, p. 123.
- International Association of Theoretical and Applied Limnology 1981, p. 1767.
- Kyodo staff 2014.
- Buruma 2017.
- Asano, Shūgō (2016). "婦人相学十躰・婦女人相十品". In Asano, Shūgō (ed.). Utamaro Ketteiban 歌麿決定版. Bessatsu Taiyō (in Japanese). 245. Heibonsha. pp. 18–21. ISBN 978-4-582-92245-5.
- Buruma, Ian (2017-06-29). "Myth-Maker of the Brothel". The New York Review of Books. Archived from the original on 2017-06-29. Retrieved 2018-01-30.
- Dunne, Susan (2017-01-19). "'Utamaro' First Exclusive Japanese Exhibit At Wadsworth Atheneum Since 1951". Hartford Courant. Archived from the original on 2017-02-12. Retrieved 2017-02-12.
- Fitzhugh, Elisabeth West (1979). "A Pigment Census of Ukiyo-e Paintings in the Freer Gallery of Art". Ars Orientalis. Freer Gallery of Art, The Smithsonian Institution, and Department of the History of Art, University of Michigan. 11: 27–38. JSTOR 4629295.
- Freer Gallery of Art staff. "Moonlight Revelry at Dozo Sagami". Freer Gallery of Art. Archived from the original on 2016-03-30. Retrieved 2017-02-06.
- Harris, Frederick (2011). Ukiyo-e: The Art of the Japanese Print. Tuttle Publishing. ISBN 978-4-8053-1098-4.
- Higuchi, Kazutaka (2014). "Fukagawa no Yuki" 深川の雪. In Ōkubo, Jun'ichi (ed.). Nihon bijutsu zenshū 日本美術全集 [Japanese Art Complete Series]. 15. Shōgakukan. pp. 237–238. ISBN 978-4-09-601115-7.
- International Association of Theoretical and Applied Limnology (1981). Proceedings of the International Association of Theoretical and Applied Limnology. 21 Parts 2–3. E. Schweizerbart'sche Verlagsbuchhandlung.
- Kobayashi, Tadashi (1997). Ukiyo-e: An Introduction to Japanese Woodblock Prints. Kodansha International. ISBN 978-4-7700-2182-3.
- Kobayashi, Tadashi (2006). Utamaro no Bijin 歌麿の美人 [Utamaro's Beauties] (in Japanese). Shogakukan. ISBN 978-4-09-652105-2.
- Kyodo staff (2014-03-03). "Long-lost painting by ukiyo-e artist Utamaro found". The Japan Times. Archived from the original on 2014-03-06. Retrieved 2017-02-12.
- Middletown Press staff (2016-12-21). "Wadsworth Atheneum presents rare Japanese art exhibit opening Jan. 7". The Middletown Press. Archived from the original on 2017-02-19. Retrieved 2017-02-19.
- Narazaki, Muneshige (1981). Utamaro 歌麿. Nikuhitsu Ukiyo-e (ja: 肉筆浮世絵) (in Japanese). 6. Shūeisha. OCLC 14040019.
- Shimomura, Ryōnosuke; et al. (1991). Utamaro 歌麿 (in Japanese). Shinchōsha. ISBN 978-4-10-601996-8.
- Smithsonian staff (2017). "Inventing Utamaro: A Japanese Masterpiece Rediscovered". Archived from the original on 2018-01-30.
- Takahashi, Sakiko (2016-12-20). 米で喜多川歌麿展 「雪月花」１３８年ぶり同時展示 「深川の雪」「品川の月」「吉原の花」の３作. Mainichi Shimbun (in Japanese). Retrieved 2017-02-12.
- Yomiuri Shimbun staff (2014-06-22). "Fukagawa no Yuki" 深川の雪・上. Yomiuri Shimbun (in Japanese). Retrieved 2017-02-20.
- Yomiuri Shimbun staff (2014-06-24). "Fukagawa no Yuki" 深川の雪・下. Yomiuri Shimbun (in Japanese). Retrieved 2017-02-20.