Ranjit Chandra

Ranjit Kumar Chandra (रंजीत कुमार चंद्रा; born February 2, 1938)[3] is an Indian-born Canadian researcher and self-proclaimed "father of nutritional immunology"[4][5] who committed scientific and health care fraud. Chandra's misconduct was the subject of a 2006 documentary by the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC). A libel trial in July 2015, concluded that the allegations of fraud against Chandra were truthful; he was ordered to pay $1.6 million to cover CBC's legal fees,[6] and later that year was stripped of his membership in the Order of Canada.[7] As of 2020, four of Chandra's research publications have been retracted, and one has been corrected.[8]

Ranjit Chandra
Born
Ranjit Kumar Chandra

(1938-02-02) February 2, 1938 (age 83)
NationalityCanadian
Education
Known forScientific and health care fraud
Medical career
FieldPediatrics
InstitutionsMemorial University
ResearchNutritional immunology
Awards

The Ontario Provincial Police have issued a warrant for Chandra's arrest, based upon a criminal charge of fraud exceeding $5,000 for having allegedly defrauded the Ontario Health Insurance Plan.[9][10]

Scientific fraudEdit

In the late 1980s, Chandra was hired by Ross Laboratories, US manufacturer of Isomil and Similac, to determine if their infant formulas could help babies avoid allergy problems; Nestlé (Good Start) and Mead Johnson had also contacted with Chandra for similar studies on their infant formulas. Chandra reported that the Nestlé and Mead Johnson formulas could protect infants from allergies, but the Ross formula could not, despite nearly identical ingredients in the three studied formulas. Marilyn Harvey, a nurse who recruited subjects for Chandra's studies and who disputed the accuracy of the number of infants reportedly enrolled in those studies, stated, "[Chandra] had all of the data analyzed and published even before we had [...] the data collected." In explaining his suspicious results to Mark Masor, then clinical research associate for Ross Pharmaceuticals, Chandra allegedly stated that "the study really wasn't designed right," although he had designed the studies himself, and he also claimed "you didn't really pay me enough money to do it correctly."[11]

In 1994, Memorial University, at which Chandra was a professor, investigated him for research fraud but its findings were kept private.[12]

In 2001, a study by Chandra and published in the journal Nutrition claimed that his own, patented multivitamin mineral supplement - the rights to which had been licensed to Javaan Corporation, a company founded by his daughter Amrita Chandra Gagnon - could reverse memory problems in people over the age of 65. The same study had earlier been submitted to, and rejected by, the British Medical Journal (BMJ), following a review by an expert who reported that the study had "all the hallmarks of being entirely invented."[13] In response to questions raised about the paper's validity, including questions of whether any of the reported work had actually been performed, Nutrition published an editorial that stated, "We regret that our peer review process failed to identify these problems before publication." Officials at Memorial University, where Chandra had been a faculty member and where the study was allegedly conducted, were requested to investigate but did not, stating that the combination of Chandra's retirement, his having left the country, and his claim that all the raw data had been lost during an office move prevented an investigation.[14] In 2005 the paper was retracted.[8]

In 2002, "Amrit L. Jain", allegedly a pseudonym of Chandra's, published a study in Nutrition Research that confirmed Chandra's earlier results on the effects of vitamin ingestion upon respiratory illness. Jain, who claimed affiliation with the non-existent Medical Clinic and Nursing Home, Jaipur, India, used as a mailing address a rented post office box in Canada. Attempts to verify Jain's identity or existence have been unsuccessful,[11] and in 2016 the Jain paper was retracted.[8]

Although Chandra retired from Memorial University of Newfoundland (MUN) under a cloud of suspicion, university officials did not charge him with research fraud. At least one university administrator admitted that Chandra's allegations of bias and threats of a lawsuit led to the termination of the university's investigation.[11] Marilyn Harvey would later enter into legal proceedings against Memorial University, claiming that the lack of action by MUN against Chandra caused people to erroneously believe that her allegations against Chandra were unfounded.[15] In response to the scandal, Memorial University later created the "Marilyn Harvey Award to Recognize the Importance of Research Ethics."[16]

In 2015, Chandra filed a lawsuit against the CBC seeking damages for libel in relation to a news segment entitled "The Secret Life of Dr. Chandra," which detailed many of the allegations of scientific and medical fraud (see below) against Chandra. The Ontario Superior Court ruled that the CBC's defence, based upon fair comment and responsible journalism, were allowed to go to the jury.[17] The jury found that the substance of the CBC broadcast was true, and dismissed Chandra's claim that in preparing the program the CBC had invaded his privacy. The court also ordered Chandra to pay $1.6 million to cover the CBC's legal fees.[18] The presiding judge, Justice Graeme Mew, wrote in the opinion of the court: "Tactically, Dr. Chandra played a high stakes game. The phrase, 'live by the sword, die by the sword' comes to mind. In the end, he failed abjectly."[19]

Chandra had been appointed in 1989 as an Officer in the Order of Canada. His membership in the Order of Canada was terminated on December 3, 2015.[20]

Investigation by College of Physicians and Surgeons of OntarioEdit

Chandra is listed in the official directory of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario (CPSO) with a revocation of registration effective 18 June 2018. The Discipline Committee of the CPSO investigated allegations of fraud against Chandra, and found that he engaged in a multi-year scheme to defraud the Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) of over $2 million. College prosecutor Elisabeth Widner said, "[Chandra] targeted OHIP in a calculated fraud in which he used and induced patients and staff members by furnishing them with money and cheques for improper use in a billing scheme ... There was little to no medical services provided for the $2 million-plus..." The Committee report stated that Chandra's actions could be "reasonably [...] regarded by members as disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional." Along with revocation of Chandra's certificate of registration, the Committee ordered Chandra to pay over $51,000 in fines and College costs.[21][22]

See alsoEdit

ReferencesEdit

  1. ^ General, Office of the Secretary to the Governor. "Dr. Ranjit Kumar Chandra, O.C., M.D., D.Sc., F.R.C.P." The Governor General of Canada.
  2. ^ General, Office of the Secretary to the Governor. "Ranjit Kumar Chandra, O.C." The Governor General of Canada.
  3. ^ Chandra, Dr Ranjit Kumar (October 22, 2008). "Dr. Ranjit Kumar Chandra". Journal of Nutritional Immunology. 2: 3–5. doi:10.1300/J053v02n01_02.
  4. ^ "Who is Ranjit Kumar Chandra? A Timeline of Notoriety". Retraction Watch. Center for Scientific Integrity. 2016-07-26. Retrieved 2019-06-26. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  5. ^ "Disgraced researcher Ranjit Chandra stripped of 1989 Order of Canada". The Globe and Mail Canada. 2016-01-08. Retrieved 2019-06-26. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  6. ^ "Ranjit Chandra ordered to pay $1.6M to cover CBC's legal fees in libel lawsuit". CBC News. Retrieved 17 November 2015. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  7. ^ "Ranjit Chandra, medical researcher, stripped of Order of Canada". CBC. CBC/Radio-Canada. 2016-01-08. Retrieved 2019-06-26. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  8. ^ a b c "Retraction Watch Database". Retraction Watch. Center for Scientific Integrity. Retrieved 2020-05-06. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  9. ^ "Toronto doctor, 78, charged in alleged OHIP fraud - CTV News Toronto". toronto.ctvnews.ca.
  10. ^ Gallant, Jacques; Ballingall, Alex (2016-08-24). "Etobicoke doctor charged with defrauding OHIP". The Star. Toronto Star Newspapers Ltd. Retrieved 2019-06-26. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  11. ^ a b c O'Neill-Yates, Chris; Burgess, Lynn. "The Secret Life of Ranjit Chandra". INFACT. INFACT Canada. Retrieved 2019-06-27. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  12. ^ White, Caroline. BMJ : British Medical Journal (Online); London351 (Nov 17, 2015). BMJ 2015;351:h6211
  13. ^ Payne, Doug. "Nutrition retracts 2001 paper". The Scientist. The Scientist. Retrieved 2019-06-27. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  14. ^ Brody, Jane (2004-05-06). "A Top Scientist's Research is Under Attack". The New York Times. Retrieved 2019-06-27. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  15. ^ "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2012-07-10. Retrieved 2012-04-11.CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
  16. ^ Newfoundland, Memorial University of. "Awards and Honours". Memorial University of Newfoundland.
  17. ^ [1][dead link]
  18. ^ "Ranjit Chandra ordered to pay $1.6M to cover CBC's legal fees in libel lawsuit". CBC. CBC/Radio-Canada. 2015-11-17. Retrieved 2019-06-27. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  19. ^ Chandra v CBC, 2015 ONSC 5303 (CanLII), <http://canlii.ca/t/gkx8r>, retrieved on 2017-06-23
  20. ^ Government of Canada, Public Works and Government Services Canada (9 January 2016). "Canada Gazette – GOVERNMENT HOUSE". gazette.gc.ca.
  21. ^ "Chandra, Ranjit Kumar - Previous Hearings". CPSO. The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. 2017-12-08. Retrieved 2019-06-26. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)
  22. ^ Pazzano, Sam (2017-12-14). "Doc found guilty of ripping off $2M from OHIP". Toronto Sun. Retrieved 2019-06-26. CS1 maint: discouraged parameter (link)

External linksEdit