Peace Treaty on Korean Peninsula
The lead section of this article may need to be rewritten. (March 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
The Peace Treaty on Korean Peninsula is a proposed settlement to formally end military hostilities on the Korean Peninsula as a follow-up to the 1953 Korean Armistice Agreement implemented by the United Nations after the Korean War. Before the 2018 Trump–Kim summit, US president Donald Trump announced that he would end the Korean War and establish a permanent peace on the Korean Peninsula. Trump and Kim Jong-un signed a Joint Statement during the summit which reaffirmed the Panmunjom Declaration. During the inter-Korean summit on April 27, 2018, Kim and Moon Jae-in signed the Panmunjom Declaration; the declaration involved an agreement about mutual efforts and action items for transforming the armistice agreement into a peace treaty with the cooperation of the U.S. and China.
|Also known as||Normalization of relations between the North Korean and US governments|
|Patron(s)||Kim Yo-jong, Mike Pompeo|
|Outcome||Formally ending the Korean War, restoring diplomatic relations between the two governments|
US president Donald Trump and North Korean Chairman of the State Affairs Commission Kim Jong-un agreed to speed up the denuclearization process on the Korean Peninsula by building a new relationship between the United States and North Korea, signing a Joint Statement on June 12, 2018. Kim asked the US to formally end the Korean War (1950–1953) to finalize the denuclearization schedule. In the past, with the advancement of North Korea's nuclear and missile program, the US had considered a military option or diplomatic negotiations with North Korea to secure its denuclearization.
There is ongoing mediation with the two Koreas, the US, and China about formally ending the Korean War. Although North and South Korea prefer declaring the end of the war first, China advocates a peace treaty which would be legally binding on all parties. The US favors a bilateral statement with North Korea in anticipation of Chinese concerns about the presence of United States Forces Korea (USFK). Russian president Vladimir Putin, who reconfirmed the peace treaty with Japan ending World War II, said that North Korea's nuclear issue should be resolved in "a political and diplomatic manner". Russia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs endorsed the Panmunjom Declaration. Putin suggested that Trump halt US-South Korean joint military exercises during a 2017 diplomatic gathering in Germany, and Trump agreed to suspend "war games" with South Korea during the Trump–Kim summit in 2018.
According to Robert Gallucci, the 1994 Agreed Framework set a precedent for resolving North Korea's nuclear and military issues. University of Southern California Korean Studies Institute director and professor of international relations David C. Kang has scrutinized previous efforts to resolve the nuclear issues, based on years of US–North Korean negotiations. The United States favors North Korean denuclearization before any security agreements, and North Korea refuses to give up its nuclear weapons before an agreement is reached.
The United States has attempted to secure the denuclearization of North Korea with a peace treaty for the peninsula because of North Korea's nuclear testing and the development of ICBM technology capable of reaching the United States. Before World War II, Korea was united for over a thousand years and known as Goryeo and Joseon. After colonisation by Japan from 1910 to 1945, Korea was divided into two countries along the 38th parallel (now the Korean Demilitarized Zone). North Korea was administered by the Soviet Union in the years immediately after the war, and South Korea was administered by the United States. North Korea invaded South Korea in 1950, beginning the Korean War. The war ended in a 1953 stalemate.
After the war, despite South Korean president Syngman Rhee's disagreement with the United States' pursuit of a ceasefire with China and the separation of North and South Korea under US-led United Nations intervention, the two Koreas were divided on July 27, 1953. After the 1954 Geneva Conference, Rhee hoped for reunification under the United Nations before his resignation in 1960.
On May 16, 1961, Park Chung-hee seized power in a South Korean military coup. During the decade, Korean reunification was advocated to revive the economies of both countries. During the 1970s, with the success of détente and Korean economic development, the countries resumed negotiations. The July 4th North–South Korea Joint Statement was drawn up, but not implemented. South Korea was governed by the Yushin Constitution, and the impetus for reunification on the peninsula ended.
On August 5, 2017, Chinese president Xi Jinping called for Donald Trump to resolve the North Korean nuclear issue through a peaceful resolution based on mutual respect between the nations in the face of heightened military tensions. At the 2017 G20 summit the previous month, Xi reaffirmed discussion of the peninsula's peace settlement.
On September 3, 2017, North Korea tested a thermonuclear weapon. The bomb was later estimated at 250 kilotons, based on a further study of seismic data. Relations between North and South Korea have warmed somewhat since then, beginning with North Korea's participation in the 2018 Winter Olympics in South Korea.
About the dismantling of a North Korean nuclear site, South Korean Foreign Minister Kang Kyung-wha said in October 2018 that he would like US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo to agree to a declaration ending the Korean War as part of security guarantees to increase North Korean confidence in a denuclearization agreement. Although Pompeo said that he was pleased to negotiate with Kim Jong-un about dismantling nuclear facilities at the Yongbyon Nuclear Scientific Research Center, he hesitated to express an opinion on the possility of an "end-of-Korean war declaration".
According to a Washington Post analysis, sufficient momentum exists for a declaration ending the Korean War as a useful tool for the Trump administration to speed up North Korea's denuclearization. The declaration would be a symbolic diplomatic measure, requiring fewer judicial obstacles than a peace treaty. Another factor making a declaration more timely is the warming relationship between the two Koreas as a result of several inter-Korean summits. CNN reported that the Trump administration is willing to end the Korean War to denuclearize North Korea.
The White House was petitioned about a peace treaty on the Korean Peninsula on March 15, 2018, and the petition received the required number of signatures within a month. Regarding a third inter-Korean summit and a permanent peace solution on the Korean peninsula, about 83 percent of the South Korean people support a diplomatic solution. According to South Korean president Moon Jae-in, the Korean War will end sooner rather than later. Moon is trying to persuade Kim Jong-un to give up his nuclear program and weapons by showing him a brighter economic future with South Korean cooperation. The president has a personal interest in the declaration, since his ancestors come from the north; Moon's 80-year-old mother has been separated from the rest of her family, who live in North Korea.
KCNA said in a commentary that there would be "such... steps as eternal dismantlement" of its DPRK nuclear complex "if the US takes a corresponding measure", however, KCNA did not elaborate the details, and stated the example about the declaration from US of an end to the Korean War 1950-53 or a peace treaty could not be a single bargaining chip to everlasting dismantlement of nuclear complex.
The UK Government advised circumspect travel to North Korea as of December 21, 2018. It summarized the current political situation on Korean peniunsula. For example, the increasing tension on the Korean peninsula became worse in 2017 due to a series of nuclear and ICBM missile tests. On 12 June, there was a meeting between US President Donald Trump and North Korea's leader Kim Jong Un. The Panmunjom Declaration signed during the inter-Korean summit on 27 April pledged to consent to a peace treaty to officially end the Korean War 1950-53 by the end of 2018. They requested the UK citizens who are living in North Korea or those who decided to travel there independently to notify the British embassy in Pyongyang about their travel plans before, or on arrival.
In March 2018, Kyodo News reported that Xi Jinping suggested a Korean peace treaty to Donald Trump in a phone conversation and emphasised that four countries (the US, South and North Korea, and China) should be included. Xi and Moon Jae-in agreed on mutual efforts to bring about a positive change to conditions surrounding the Korean Peninsula after the April 2018 inter-Korean summit.
On April 16, 2018, Trump met with Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe at Mar-a-Lago. Trump announced that Japan and the US had a shared objective in resolving the North Korea issue, saying that the Korean War had not yet ended but endorsing its end. He tweeted on 27 April, "KOREAN WAR TO END! The United States, and all of its GREAT people, should be very proud of what is now taking place in Korea!" The president promised to work with Moon to pressure North Korea into abandoning its ICBM and nuclear-weapons programs, which have caused anxiety in the Asia-Pacific region for years.
In a April 29 Fox News interview, US Senate Committee on Armed Services member Lindsey Graham said that North Korea could reach the US with nuclear weapons; given the threat of retaliation, however, they should negotiate their nuclear program and the Kim government's safety, stability and economic development. According to Graham, the nuclear deal with Iran was useless; Iran enriches their nuclear fuel without third-party inspection, and could quickly develop atomic weapons. An agreement with North Korea should include verification of their nuclear program.
In a June 1 CNBC interview about a meeting with North Korean aide Kim Yong Chol at the White House, Trump said that he did not like North Korea's meeting with Russia but it was time to end the war. Former Trump adviser Sebastian Gorka defended Trump's rhetoric in a June 12 Fox Business Network, after the Trump-Kim summit.
It was reported on July 24 that North Korea was dismantling a nuclear rocket-launching and test site near Tongchang-ri, as Kim had promised during the 2018 Trump–Kim summit. Moon called the move "a good sign for North Korea's denuclearization" and "Kim Jong-un's sincerity". Three days later, Korean Council for Reconciliation and Cooperation chairman Kim Hong-gul expressed Pyongyang's eagerness to sign a declaration ending the war and its willingness to speed up denuclearization based on mutual trust between the US and North Korea. Although North Korea had wanted a peace treaty, an "end-of-war declaration" would be the first step towards speedier denuclearization.
That day, the 65th anniversary of the Korean War armistice, North Korea returned the remains of 55 American military-service members who were killed during the Korean War to the United States. The Korean Central News Agency was silent on the return of the remains. According to Center for the National Interest director of defense studies, Trump should respond to the goodwill gesture with a bold move. Although a comprehensive denuclearization agreement was made during the Trump-Kim summit, a peace treaty would be a crucial condition for North Korea to give up their nuclear arsenal and ICBM program. The US would not lose face, since the Korean War ended 65 years ago and that declaration should have been finalized decades ago.
On August 4, during the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Regional Forum 2018, North Korea's nuclear program was the main agenda item. ASEAN foreign ministers issued a joint statement calling for "complete denuclearization", a change from 2017's call for "complete, verifiable and irreversible denuclearization". South Korean foreign minister Kang Kyung-wha said that she had "considerable" consultation about the declaration with her Chinese and US counterparts. According to Chinese foreign minister Wang Yi, "Everyone can announce a declaration ending the war if they do not want the war to happen again". North Korean foreign minister Ri Yong-ho said that he was "alarmed" by US insistence on maintaining sanctions until denuclearization and what he said was US reluctance to declare a formal end to the Korean War. USFK maintains several nuclear bomber fighters, and North Korea demanded a US safety guarantee in exchange for giving up their nuclear-weapons program. North Korea wants a second Trump–Kim summit to resolve the gridlocked security guarantee-denuclearization negotiations. A second summit was reportedly possible before the end of 2018.
On February 27–28, 2019, the North Korea–United States Summit in Hanoi was held. Kim Jong-un departed from Pyongyang on February 23, according to images released by the KCNA news agency. It was 4,500 kilometres (2,800 mi) one way trip took about 60 hours. The train arrived in Đồng Đăng railway station of the Vietnamese border city of Đồng Đăng on Tuesday February 26, and Kim traveled to Hanoi by vehicle. U.S president Donald Trump met with Kim Jong-un on February 27–28, 2019, in Hanoi, Vietnam, in the second summit meeting between the leaders of the United States and North Korea. On February 28, 2019, the White House published that the summit was cut short and that no deal was reached, with Trump later elaborating that it was because North Korea wanted an end to all sanctions. On the other hand, North Korean Foreign Minister Ri Yong-ho stated that the country only sought a partial lifting of five United Nations sanctions placed on North Korea during 2016–17.
About the end of March, which was one month after the summit ended, Reuters revealed that on the second day of the summit U.S. president passed DPRK Kim a note that bluntly called for North Korea to surrender all its nuclear weapons and fuel, in similar fashion to the “Libya model,” a proposal the North Koreans had repeatedly rejected. The scheduled ceremonial luncheon was then abruptly canceled and the summit ended. Dr. Chiew-Ping Hoo, a professor at the National University of Malaysia, said that the negotiations at the Hanoi summit changed the minute John Bolton was added at the eleventh-hour to the panel. He advised to change the goal-post from the YongByon Nuclear site, to add other sites that produced weapons of mass destruction. Trump had to agree with Bolton’s advice due to U.S. domestic issues, which resulted in a no-deal outcome for the summit. According to Jenny Town, Washington based, think-tank and North Korean expert, "it's Bolton's proposal in 2004, has been rejected more than once and, to bring it up again… would rather be insulting.” She also said that the US should have learned that this wasn’t effective diplomacy, and shows they haven’t learned how to properly negotiate.
Former special assistant to President Ronald Reagan, and a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, Doug Bandow, President Trump was demanding unrealistically for President Kim Jong Un to dismantle all his nuclear facilities, whereas President Kim was only agreeing to shutting down the YongByon Nuclear facility in exchange for a partial lifting of a few UN sanctions against his country. Asking continuously for an all nukes for sanctions deal is deemed as malicious in its intent and illogical. Douglas Dillon Professor of Government at the Harvard Kennedy School, and former director of Harvard’s Belfer Center, Graham T. Allison, believes that the Hanoi summit is not a whole failure, despite some public opinion, and even compared this to the Reagan-Gorbachev era. President Reagan also had to deal with negative public opinion regarding his dealings with the USSR, but he was able to remove all of the Soviet Union’s intermediate nuclear-armed missiles with an INF deal. Compared to the USSR, North Korea is also communist country, but President Trump was able to deal with the top leader of North Korea, President Kim, something neither Bush nor Obama were able to do in their combined 16- year term. According to Abby Bard, a research associate for Asia policy at the Center for American Progress, President Trump’s and President Kim’s teams need critical space between them to build trust and verify the intentions between the two parties. Working level meetings between both teams are needed to arrange the details that would result in bigger bargains without miscalculations and misunderstandings. In order for the two leaders to reach a deal, their diplomatic teams need to work together.
- 2018–19 Korean peace process
- April 2018 inter-Korean summit
- May 2018 inter-Korean summit
- September 2018 inter-Korean summit
- 2018 North Korea–United States Singapore Summit
- 2019 North Korea–United States Hanoi Summit
- DPRK– Russia Summit
- Korean conflict
- Korean reunification
- Kim–Xi meetings
- List of international trips made by Kim Jong-un
- Index of Korea-related articles
- NBC-News-Japan - 17 April 2018:President Donald Trump: North And South Korea 'Have My Blessing' To Discuss An End To War | NBC News
- cgtn.com- Where are we on a peace treaty 26 June 2018: Korean War: Where are we on a peace treaty?
- http://www.vox.com - 12 June 2018: Breaking: Trump and Kim sign agreement pledging to work toward "a lasting and stable peace"
- Japantimes.co.jp - Panmunjom Declaration 26 June 2018: Full text of Panmunjom Declaration
- "Pyongyang 'Frustrated' Over Delay in Peace Treaty Signing to End Korean War". sputniknews.com. Retrieved July 28, 2018.
- "President Trump's Top Defense and Diplomatic Chiefs Insist "There's A Military Option for North Korea"". time.com/. Retrieved August 23, 2017.
- "It's time for the U.S. to negotiate a peace treaty with North Korea". www.nknews.org. Retrieved August 13, 2017.
- English.chosun.com - 31 July 2018: Behind-the-Scenes Talks Underway to End Korean War
- japantimes.co.jp/- 27 May 2018: Abe and Putin reconfirm peace treaty, economic cooperation goals while taking united stance on denuclearizing North Korea
- http://www.newsweek.com/- 29 June 2018: Russia Wants a Piece of the North and South Korea Peace Action
- qz.com/- 14 June 2018: Did Putin give Trump the idea to stop "war games" with South Korea?
- ""Prevented war with North Korea in 1994 – here's what needs to be done". .inews.co.uk. Archived from the original on September 10, 2017. Retrieved September 10, 2017. Cite uses deprecated parameter
- "Agreed Framework of 21 October 1994 Between the United States of America and the Democratic People's Republic of Korea" (PDF). IAEA. November 2, 1994. INFCIRC/457. Archived from the original (PDF) on December 17, 2003.
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nKVNkh1KEhE |title= North Korea Beyond the Headlines Part 2: Dealing with North Korea's Military Challenge
- International Institute for Strategic Studies (February 10, 2004), North Korea's Weapons Programmes: A Net Assessment, Palgrave Macmillan, ISBN 978-1-4039-3324-9, archived from the original on March 11, 2009, retrieved March 5, 2009 Cite uses deprecated parameter
- "Conclusion of non-aggression treaty between DPRK and U.S. called for". KCNA. October 25, 2002. Archived from the original on September 8, 2009. Retrieved March 15, 2009. Cite uses deprecated parameter
- William J. Clinton (March 4, 1999), Presidential Determination No. 99-16, The White House, archived from the original on September 27, 2007, retrieved September 27, 2007
- "Statement from Former U.S. President Jimmy Carter on Current U.S.-North Korea Relations". cartercenter.org. Archived from the original on September 10, 2017. Retrieved September 10, 2017. Cite uses deprecated parameter
- Delk, Josh. "Rice: US has failed in denuclearization of North Korea". thehill.com. Retrieved August 21, 2017.
- "Biographies: Syngman Rhee". The Department of Defense 60th Anniversary of Korean War Commemoration Committee. Retrieved on September 28, 2017.
- Kim, B.-K. & Vogel, E. F. (eds.) (2011). The Park Chung Hee Era: The Transformation of South Korea. Harvard University Press. pp. 27–29.
However the Yushin Constitution may have merely formalised rather than directly established the "imperial presidencyCS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)
- "China's Xi Jinping urges calm in call with Donald Trump as US-North". www.abc.net.au. Retrieved August 20, 2017.
- Kim, Jack, and Soyoung Kim. "North Korea detonates its sixth and most powerful nuclear test yet". Reuters. Archived from the original on September 4, 2017. Cite uses deprecated parameter
- "North Korea's latest nuclear test was so powerful it reshaped the mountain above it". The Washington Post. September 14, 2017. Archived from the original on September 14, 2017. Retrieved September 14, 2017. Cite uses deprecated parameter
- Miller, J Berkshire. "Great aspirations: Inter-Korea relations going forward". www.aljazeera.com.
- Shin, Hyonhee. "Two Koreas discuss reducing military tension amid reports of North ..." U.S.
- Scmp - 5 October 2018: "An end to the Korean war in return for Pyongyang’s denuclearisation? That’s the suggestion from Seoul"| scmp.com
- washingtonexaminer.com - 3 October 2018: "South Korea pushes Pompeo to accept Kim's demand on status of Korean War"| washingtonexaminer.com
- aljazeera - 12 Oct 2018: "Moon Jae-in urges US to declare end of war with North Korea | cnn.com"
- washingtonpost.com - 20 September 2018: "The end of the Korean War? A new push to finish an old conflict"| washingtonpost.com/
- cnn.com - 2 Oct 2018: "After 65 years of 'armistice,' it's about time to end the Korean War"| cnn.com
- BBC.com - 12 Oct 2018: "South Korea's Moon optimistic about end to Korean War"|cnn.com
- We the People website, "A Peace Treaty on the Korean Peninsula". March 15, 2018.
- mediatoday.co.kr -25 Sept 2018: "Three major Broadcasting Poll shows, the inter-Korean Summit in Pyongyang 'Good' 80%" (in Korean).
- politico -25 September 2018: "How US and North Korea could stumble into World War III| politico"
- nationalinterest.org -21 Sept 2018: "How North Korea Could Start World War III: A War Between Russia and America"
- bbc.com - 12 Oct 2018: "South Korea's Moon optimistic about end to Korean War"
- bbc.com - 26 April 2018: "Moon Jae-in: South Korea's president with humble roots"
- telegraph.co.uk - 2 Oct 2018: "North Korea tells US it will not denuclearise in return for peace treaty"
- Gov.UK - 22 Dec 2018: "Foreign travel advice to North Korea "
- UPI - 1 April 2018: Report: Chinese President suggested Korean peace treaty to Donald Trump"
- Koreaherald - 17 April 2018: "Leaders of S. Korea, China vow close coordination in pushing for formal end to Korean War"
- Thehill.com - 27 April 2018: "Trump: Americans should be 'very proud' of denuclearization in Korean peninsula"
- twitter.com on Trump - 27 April 2018: "KOREAN WAR TO END! The United States, and all of its GREAT people, should be very proud of what is now taking place in Korea!"
- Fox News - 29 April 2018: "Graham: If the Korean War ends, Trump deserves Nobel Prize"
- CNBC - 1 June 2018: President Donald Trump On North Korea Meeting: We Talked About Ending The Korean War | CNBC
- "Former Advisor to President Trump Sebastian Gorka on President Trump's summit meeting with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un". June 12, 2018.
- "President Moon confirms shutdown of rockets site". July 26, 2018.
- "Pyongyang 'Frustrated' Over Delay in Peace Treaty Signing to End Korean War". July 27, 2018.
- BBC - 12 June 2018: "North Korea returns US war remains; bringing renewed hope to families who have waited decades for closure"
- newsinfo.inquirer.net - 30 July 2018: "North Korea silent on return of US remains"
- http://www.vox.com - 12 June 2018: "Let's offer North Korea a peace treaty officially ending the Korean War"
- asia.nikkei.com - 5 Aug 2018: "Let's offer North Korea a peace treaty officially ending the Korean War"
- yonhapnews.co.kr - 5 Aug 2018: "S. Korea, Chinese nuclear envoys to hold talks Monday"
- english.hani.co.kr - 5 Aug 2018: "Chinese foreign minister expresses public support of ending Korean War"
- https://www.cnbc.com - 5 Aug 2018: [ https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/06/us-secretary-of-state-pompeo-plays-down-north-korea-sparring.html "US Secretary of State Pompeo plays down sparring with North Korea"]
- RT AMERICA- 5 Aug 2018: [ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=howjM11YNJs "North Korea will only denuclearize if there is a peace treaty, says antiwar organizer"]
- CNN- 5 Aug 2018: [ https://edition.cnn.com/2018/08/06/asia/north-korea-nuclear-talks-intl/index.html "North Korea hopeful for 2nd Trump-Kim Summit: source"]
- japantimes.co.jp- 5 Aug 2018: "'Strong possibility' of second Trump-Kim summit before year’s end: report"
- Rosenfeld, Everett (February 28, 2019). "Trump-Kim summit was cut short after North Korea demanded an end to all sanctions". CNBC. Retrieved February 28, 2019.
- Talmadge, Eric. "Officials say Trump overstated Kim's demand on sanctions". Associated Press. Retrieved March 2, 2019.
- Shin, Hyonhee; Brice, Makini; Alexander, David. "North Korea offered proposal but U.S. asked for more at summit: foreign minister". Reuters. Retrieved March 2, 2019.
- Lee, Jihye; Lee, Youkyung; Wadhams, Nick. "North Korea's Kim Vows to Meet Trump Again After Summit Collapse". Bloomberg News. Retrieved March 2, 2019.
- "North Korea's foreign minister says country seeks only partial sanctions relief, contradicting Trump". Washington Post.
- NBC News (February 28, 2019), North Korea Disputes President Donald Trump's Assessment Of Hanoi Summit, retrieved March 1, 2019
- Wong, Edward (February 28, 2019). "Trump's Talks With Kim Jong-un Collapse, and Both Sides Point Fingers". The New York Times.
- "North Korea: Trump passed Kim a note demanding he give up his nukes". www.cnbc.com. March 30, 2019.
- Hoo, Chiew-Ping (March 12, 2019). "The Hanoi Summit – We Asked Chiew-Ping Hoo What Happens Next in U.S.-North Korea Relations". The National Interest.
- Bandow, Doug (March 12, 2019). "The Hanoi Summit – We Asked Doug Bandow What Happens Next in U.S.-North Korea Relations". The National Interest.
- Allison, Graham (March 12, 2019). "The Hanoi Summit —We Asked Graham Allison What Happens Next in U.S.-North Korea Relations". The National Interest.