Otto Kelsey

Otto Goodell Kelsey (November 11, 1852 – August 20, 1934) was an American lawyer and politician.

Otto Kelsey
Kelsey, 1902
New York State Comptroller
In office
Preceded byCharles H. Gaus
Succeeded byClark Williams
In office
Preceded byNathan Lewis Miller
Succeeded byWilliam C. Wilson
Superintendent of Insurance
In office
Preceded byFrancis Hendricks
Personal details
Born(1852-11-11)November 11, 1852
DiedRochester, New York, U.S.
August 20, 1934(1934-08-20) (aged 81)
ParentsPerry, New York, U.S.

Early lifeEdit

He was born on November 11, 1852, in Rochester, Monroe County, New York. He was the son of Wisconsin State Senator Charles S. Kelsey (born 1822) and Lucretia Parson (née Bacon) Kelsey (died 1868).

Congressman William H. Kelsey and Wisconsin State Senator Edwin B. Kelsey were his uncles.


He became a printer, then studied law, was admitted to the bar in 1875, and practiced law in Geneseo, Livingston County, New York.

Political careerEdit

He was a Republican member of the New York State Assembly (Livingston Co.) in 1894, 1895, 1896, 1897, 1898, 1899, 1900, 1901 and 1902. In November 1902, he ran for County Judge of Livingston County, but was unexpectedly defeated. Subsequently his party friends forced Theodore P. Gilman to resign the office of First Deputy Comptroller, and had Kelsey appointed to the post. When Comptroller Nathan Lewis Miller was appointed to the New York Supreme Court, Kelsey was appointed New York State Comptroller to fill the vacancy, and was elected at the New York state election, 1904, to succeed himself.

On May 2, 1906, Kelsey was appointed by Governor Frank W. Higgins to a three-year term as Superintendent of Insurance, and resigned the comptrollership. Early in 1907, Governor Charles Evans Hughes asked Kelsey to resign, but he refused. The governor then asked the New York State Senate to remove Kelsey on the ground that "while honest he utterly lacks in force and initiative", but after a lengthy hearing in the Judicial Committee, Kelsey was upheld by a vote of 27 to 24 on May 3, 1907. Then Governor Hughes appointed Matthew C. Fleming a Special Commissioner to examine the Insurance Department, and on February 2, 1908, Fleming declared Kelsey "unfit for the office" in his report to the State Senate, but Kelsey was maintained in office by an even larger majority.

Eventually, Kelsey resigned from the Insurance Department to be re-appointed First Deputy Comptroller by Charles H. Gaus on January 1, 1909, and acted as Comptroller after Gaus's death until the appointment, on November 11, of Clark Williams to fill the vacancy. A week later, Kelsey was forced to resign as First Deputy Comptroller.

Personal lifeEdit

He died on August 20, 1934, in Perry, Wyoming County, New York, after complications from a fall, and was buried in Geneseo.


  • [1] The Rapid Transit Bill, mentioning Chairman Kelsey with wrong middle initial "C.", in NYT on April 12, 1901
  • [2] Speculation about Gilman's imminent resignation, in NYT on December 29, 1902
  • [3] Denial of Gilman's resignation in NYT on December 30, 1902
  • [4] The speculation about Gilman's resignation continues, in NYT on January 13, 1903
  • [5] Gilman resigned, in NYT on January 16, 1903
  • [6] Appointed Supt. of Insurance, in NYT on May 3, 1906
  • [7] Kelsey at work, denying resignation, in NYT on January 20, 1907 (giving wrong middle initial "T.")
  • [8] His fight to stay in office, in NYT on February 13, 1907 (giving wrong middle initial "T.")
  • [9] Vote in the state senate 27 to 24 for Kelsey, in NYT on May 3, 1907
  • [10] The report on Kelsey's receivership at the Republic Savings and Loan Association, in NYT on January 3, 1908 (giving wrong middle initial "C.")
  • [11] The Fleming Report, in NYT on February 3, 1908
  • [12] His re-appointment, in NYT on December 15, 1908
  • [13] Kelsey with middle initial H., in NYT on December 25, 1908
  • [14] Acting Comptroller between death of Gaus and appointment of successor, in NYT on November 11, 1909
  • [15] His resignation, in NYT on November 20, 1909
  • [16] Obit in NYT on August 21, 1934 (subscription required)
  • "Gossip About People of Note" in Old newspaper, of 1906 with short bio of Kelsey
  • [17] His mother's burial record, from West Perry Cemetery, at RootsWeb
  • [18] Members of the Wisconsin Legislature

External linksEdit

New York Assembly
Preceded by
Jesse Roberts
New York State Assembly
Livingston County

Succeeded by
William Y. Robinson
Political offices
Preceded by
Nathan Lewis Miller
New York State Comptroller
Succeeded by
William C. Wilson
Preceded by
Francis Hendricks
Superintendent of Insurance
Succeeded by
Henry D. Appleton
Preceded by
Charles H. Gaus
New York State Comptroller

Succeeded by
Clark Williams