Open main menu

Organ theft was at one time only a belief and a popular urban legend topic that an organized scheme exists to steal human organs for the purpose of transplantation and being sold to the highest bidder on the dark web.[1] However, there are cases where the accusations of organ theft have been found true.

The urban legendEdit

As an urban legend the story has been around since at least the early 1990s and mostly involves the theft of one or both of the victims kidneys.[2] According to Jan Harold Brunvand it's possible that the story originated due to a news story wherein a Turkish man, Ahmet Koc, claimed to have had his kidney stolen at a hospital but had in fact sold his kidney and was unhappy at the amount of money he'd been paid.[3][4]

There is certainly a worldwide organ trafficking issue but actual organ theft is highly unlikely. Benjamin Radford notes that organ transplantation is extremely complicated, requires specific matches coupled with fairly tight time frames, and highly specialized medical training.[4] As such, the common variations on the legend where either a lone traveler is drugged or otherwise subdued or where a child is kidnapped and harvested against their will are simply not possible scenarios for such theft to occur.[5]

Credible occurrencesEdit

There are some cases that have been proven or are at least strongly suspected to be real occurrences. As you can read below these are generally institutional settings with the systems and expertise available for the transplantation of the organ to occur.

ChinaEdit

According to reports there are more organ donations than there are official donors and it's suspected that prisoners of conscience are making up the difference against their will.[6] The U.S. House of Representatives and the European Parliament have passed resolutions condemning the practice.[7]

The allegations are strongly supported by a 2017 report.[8] The report itself is an update to two separate works of investigative journalism:

  • The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvesting, and China’s Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem, written by Ethan Gutmann[9]
  • Bloody Harvest: The Killing of Falun Gong for Their Organs, written by David Matas and David Kilgour[10]

On June 17, 2019 the China Tribunal, an independent tribunal looking into the accusations of forced organ harvesting in China, released their final report and judgement.[11] The tribunal in part determined that:

"The Tribunal’s members are certain – unanimously, and sure beyond reasonable doubt – that in China forced organ harvesting from prisoners of conscience has been practiced for a substantial period of time involving a very substantial number of victims."[11]

As a result of the tribunal's report and China previously admitting to harvesting organs (although they claimed to have ceased the practice in 2015[12]) several prominent journals are instituting stronger controls to ensure that papers produced on organ transplantation only use voluntarily obtained organs.[13]

IndiaEdit

The multi-billion rupee Gurgaon kidney scandal came to light in January 2008 when police arrested several people for running a kidney transplant racket in Gurgaon,[14] an industrial township near New Delhi, India. Kidneys from most of the victims, who were the poor hailing from the nearby western Uttar Pradesh,[14] were transplanted into clients from the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Saudi Arabia and Greece. The police raid was prompted by complaints by the locals from Moradabad about illegal kidney sales.[15] The man accused of the scandal, Amit Kumar, was arrested in Nepal on 7 February 2008 and has denied any hand in criminal activity.[16] According to the Gurgaon police, the scandal at a local clinic was going on for six to seven years. The donors were lured with offerings of about Rs. 30,000 for kidney removal.[17] First, they were lured to the clinic on the pretext of job opportunities. They were instead asked for donating their kidneys for the fee and all those who resisted this were drugged against their will and subsequently operated upon.[18]

KosovoEdit

Organ theft in Kosovo has been widely reported.[19][20][21]

  • During and after the 1999 war, accusations were made of people being killed in order to remove their organs to sell them on the black market. Various sources estimated that the number of victims ranged from a "handful",[22] up to 50,[23] between 24 to 100[24] to over 300.[25] The victims were believed to be of Serbian nationality, killed by perpetrators with strong links to the Kosovo Liberation Army (UÇK) in 1999. Claims were investigated first by the ICTY who found medical equipment and traces of blood in and around the house.[19] They were then investigated by the UN, who received witness reports from many ex-UK fighters who stated that several of the prisoners had their organs removed.[26]
  • In 2010, a report by Swiss prosecutor Dick Marty to the Council of Europe (CoE) uncovered "credible, convergent indications"[27] of an illegal trade in human organs going back over a decade,[28] including the deaths of a "handful" of Serb captives killed for this purpose.[28] On 25 January 2011, the report was endorsed by the CoE, which called for a full and serious investigation. Since the issuance of the report, however, senior sources in the European Union Rule of Law Mission in Kosovo (EULEX) and many members of the European Parliament have expressed serious doubts regarding the report and its foundations, believing Marty failed to provide "any evidence" concerning the allegations.[29] A EULEX special investigation was launched in August 2011.
  • Responding to this allegation, the head of the war crimes unit of Eulex (the European Law and Justice Mission in Kosovo), Matti Raatikainen, claimed "The fact is that there is no evidence whatsoever in this case, no bodies. No witnesses. All the reports and media attention to this issue have not been helpful to us. In fact they have not been helpful to anyone."[30] He described these allegations as a "distraction" that prevented the war crimes unit from finding the remains of close to 2,000 individuals of Serb, Albanian, and Roma ethnicity still missing in the conflict.

See alsoEdit

  • Coma, 1977 novel by Robin Cook
  • Coma, 1978 film, based on the aforementioned novel
  • Death Warrant, 1990 film, where a murder mystery involves organ theft where healthy prison inmates are murdered for healthy organs
  • Charlie the Unicorn, a 2005 short viral video
  • Turistas, a 2006 American Horror film, in which the main characters who are tourists are abducted in the Brazilian countryside for purposes of organ theft
  • Snakehead, a 2007 Alex Rider novel in which the title character is kidnapped and sent to a facility for organ theft in the South East Asian jungle
  • Pound of Flesh, a 2015 film in which a former commando falls prey to organ thieves.

ReferencesEdit

  1. ^ "Kidney Theft". Snopes.com. 2001-09-06. Retrieved 2019-07-08.
  2. ^ Brunvand, J.H. (1994). The Baby Train and Other Lusty Urban Legends. W. W. Norton. p. 149. ISBN 978-0-393-34672-5. Retrieved 2019-07-08.
  3. ^ Beelman, Maud (1989-07-16). "Body Parts Needed for Transplants : Trade in Human Organs Stirs Global Attention". latimes.com. Retrieved 2019-07-08.
  4. ^ a b Radford, Benjamin; Contributor, Live Science (2008-02-19). "The Truth About Sensational Kidney Thefts". Live Science. Retrieved 2019-07-08.
  5. ^ Radford, Benjamin (June 1999). "Bitter Harvest: The Organ-Snatching Urban Legends". Skeptical Inquirer. 23 (3): 34–48. Retrieved 8 July 2019.
  6. ^ Rogers, Benedict (2019-02-05). "Opinion - The Nightmare of Human Organ Harvesting in China". WSJ. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
  7. ^ Ochab, Ewelina U. (2018-10-16). "Organ Harvesting In China And The Many Questions To Be Answered". Forbes. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
  8. ^ "An Update". The International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
  9. ^ Gutmann, E. (2014). The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvesting, and China's Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem. Prometheus Books. ISBN 978-1-61614-940-6. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
  10. ^ Matas, D.; Kilgour, D. (2009). Bloody Harvest: The Killing of Falun Gong for Their Organs. Seraphim Editions. ISBN 978-0-9808879-7-6. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
  11. ^ a b "Final Judgement Report". China Tribunal. 2018-10-14. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
  12. ^ "China stopped harvesting organs from executed prisoners in 2015. Prove it at London inquiry, say unconvinced UK lawmakers". South China Morning Post. 2019-03-27. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
  13. ^ "Startling China organ claims raise alarm about transplant research". Nature. 2019-06-25. Retrieved 2019-07-02.
  14. ^ a b "Kidney racket busted in Gurgaon". The Times of India. 2008-01-25. Retrieved 2008-02-06.
  15. ^ "Doctor held for kidney racket". NDTV. 2008-01-25. Retrieved 2008-02-06.
  16. ^ "I have done nothing wrong: Kingpin". Retrieved 2008-02-08.
  17. ^ Hafeez, Mateen. "Kidney racket: Women did con job for Amit Kumar". The Times Of India. Retrieved 2008-01-08.
  18. ^ Ramesh, Randeep (2008-01-25). "Indian police arrest suspected kidney snatching gang". London: The Guardian. Retrieved 2008-02-06.
  19. ^ a b Chuck Sudetic, Carla Del Ponte, La caccia: Io e i criminali di guerra, Feltrinelli, Milano, (2008), ISBN 88-07-17144-9
  20. ^ http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/new-details-emerge-in-kosovo-organ-trafficking-case |newspaper=Balkan Insight |date=14 December 2010
  21. ^ "United Nations Document" (PDF). France24.com.
  22. ^ Lewis, Paul (14 December 2010). "Kosovo physicians accused of illegal organs removal racket". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 22 January 2011.
  23. ^ Flottau, Renate (22 September 2008). "Albania's House at the End of the World: Family Denies Organ Harvesting Allegations". Der Spiegel. Retrieved 4 August 2012.
  24. ^ "United Nations Document" (PDF). France24.com. Retrieved 29 September 2012.
  25. ^ Chuck Sudetic, Carla Del Ponte, La caccia: Io e i criminali di guerra, Feltrinelli, Milano, (2008), ISBN 88-07-17144-9
  26. ^ UN knew about Kosovo organ trafficking, report says – EXCLUSIVE. FRANCE 24. Retrieved on 2011-04-30.
  27. ^ "New Details Emerge in Kosovo Organ Trafficking Case". Balkan Insight. 14 December 2010. Retrieved 22 January 2011.
  28. ^ a b Lewis, Paul (14 December 2010). "Kosovo physicians accused of illegal organs removal racket". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 22 January 2011.
  29. ^ Politician angers MEPs over Kosovo organ harvesting claim (The Irish Times)
  30. ^ "End of the road for Kosovo Organ Claims?". BBC. 27 May 2010. Retrieved 1 February 2013.