Musicophilia

In 2007 neurologist Oliver Sacks released his book Musicophilia: Tales of Music and the Brain in which he explores a range of psychological and physiological ailments and their intriguing connections to music. It is broken down into four parts, each with a distinctive theme; part one titled Haunted by Music examines mysterious onsets of musicality and musicophilia (and musicophobia). Part two A Range of Musicality looks at musical oddities musical synesthesia. Parts three and four are titled Memory, Movement, and Music and Emotions, Identity, and Music respectively. Each part has between six and eight chapters, each of which is in turn dedicated to a particular case study (or several related case studies) that fit the overarching theme of the section. Presenting the book in this fashion makes the reading a little disjointed if one is doing so cover to cover, however, it also means one may pick up the book and flip to any chapter for a quick read without losing any context. Four case studies from the book are featured in the NOVA program Musical Minds aired on June 30, 2009.

Musicophilia: Tales of Music and the Brain
Musicophilia front cover.jpg
AuthorOliver Sacks
Cover artistChip Kidd
LanguageEnglish
PublisherKnopf
Publication date
2007-10-16
ISBN978-1-4000-4081-0
OCLC85692744
781/.11 22
LC ClassML3830 .S13 2007
Preceded byOaxaca Journal (2002) 
Followed byThe Mind's Eye (2010) 

PurposeEdit

According to Sacks, Musicophilia was written in an attempt to widen the general populace's understanding of music and its effects on the brain. As Sacks states at the outset of the book's preface, music is omnipresent, influencing human's everyday lives in how we think and act. However, unlike other animal species (such as birds) whose musical prowess is easier to understand in relation on a biological/evolutionary level, humanity's draw towards music and song is less clear-cut. There is no "music center" of the brain, yet the vast majority of humans have an innate ability to distinguish, "music, perceive tones, timbre, pitch intervals, melodic contours, harmony, and (perhaps most elementally) rhythm." With that in mind, Sacks examines human's musical inclination through the lens of musical therapy and treatment, as a fair number of neurological injuries and diseases have been documented to be successfully treated with music. This understanding (along with a medical case Sacks witnessed in 1966 wherein a Parkinson's patient was able to be successfully treated via music therapy) is what galvanized Sacks to create an episodic compilation of patient cases that all experienced and were treated by music to some capacity. In doing so, Sacks concertizes each example by explaining the neurological factors that play into each patient's healing and treatment in ways that relate to a lay yet curious audience.

ReviewsEdit

In a review for The Washington Post, Peter D. Kramer wrote, "In Musicophilia, Sacks turns to the intersection of music and neurology -- music as affliction and music as treatment." Kramer wrote, "Lacking the dynamic that propels Sacks's other work, Musicophilia threatens to disintegrate into a catalogue of disparate phenomena." Kramer went on to say, "What makes Musicophilia cohere is Sacks himself. He is the book's moral argument. Curious, cultured, caring, in his person Sacks justifies the medical profession and, one is tempted to say, the human race." Kramer concluded his review by writing, "Sacks is, in short, the ideal exponent of the view that responsiveness to music is intrinsic to our makeup. He is also the ideal guide to the territory he covers. Musicophilia allows readers to join Sacks where he is most alive, amid melodies and with his patients."[1]

Musicophilia was listed as one of the best books of 2007 by The Washington Post.[2]

Music and the brainEdit

Sacks includes discussions of several different conditions associated with music as well as conditions that are helped by music. These include musical conditions such as musical hallucinations, absolute pitch, and synesthesia, and non-musical conditions such as blindness, amnesia, and Alzheimer’s disease.

Musical conditionsEdit

Sacks first discusses musical seizures, and he mainly writes about someone who had a tumor in his left temporal lobe which caused him to have seizures, during which he heard music. Sacks then writes about musical hallucinations that often accompany deafness, partial hearing loss, or conditions like tinnitus. Sacks also focuses a lot on absolute pitch, where a person is able to immediately identify the pitch of a musical note. Another condition Sacks spends a lot of time on is synesthesia. Sacks discusses several different types of synesthesia: key synesthesia, non-musical synesthesia centered on numbers, letters, and days, synesthesia centered on sounds in general, synesthesia centered on rhythm and tempo, and synesthesia in which the person sees lights and shapes instead of colors. Sacks also describes cases where synesthesia has accompanied blindness.

Conditions affectedEdit

Sacks discusses how blindness can affect the perception of music and musical notes, and he also writes that absolute pitch is much more common in blind musicians than it is in sighted musicians. Sacks writes about Clive Wearing, who suffers from severe amnesia. Sacks writes about how, even though Clive suffers from such severe amnesia, he still remembers how to read piano music and play the piano. However, Clive can only remember how to do so in the moment. Sacks also writes about Tourette syndrome and the effects that music can have on tics, for example, slowing tics down to match the tempo of a song. Sacks writes about Parkinson’s disease, and how, similar to with people who suffer from Tourette’s, music with a strong rhythmic beat can help with movement and coordination. Sacks briefly discusses Williams syndrome and how children with Williams syndrome were found to be very responsive to music. Sacks finishes his book with a discussion of Alzheimer’s disease and dementia. He discusses how music therapy can help people with these conditions regain memory.

Behavioral effectsEdit

Certain portions of the brain are associated with how we use the brain to interact with music. For example, the cerebellum, a portion that coordinates movement and stores muscle memory, responds well to the introduction of music. For example, an Alzheimer's patient would not be able to recognise his wife, but would still remember how to play the piano because he dedicated this knowledge to muscle memory when he was young. Those memories never fade. Another example is the Putamen. This portion of the brain processes rhythm and regulates body movement and coordination. When introduced to music, if the amount of dopamine in the area is increased, it increases our response to rhythm. By doing this, music has the ability to temporarily stop the symptoms of such diseases as Parkinson’s Disease. The music serves as a cane to these patients, and when the music is taken away, the symptoms return. When it comes to which music people respond best to, it is a matter of individual background. In patients with dementia, it is found that most patients respond to music from their youth, rather than relying on a certain rhythm or element. Neuroscientist Kiminobu Sugaya explains “That means memories associated with music are emotional memories, which never fade out-even in Alzheimer’s patients”.[3]

Studies on the effects of music therapyEdit

Since the 1970s, there have been multiple studies on the benefits of music therapy for clients with medical conditions, trauma, learning disabilities, and handicaps. Most of the documented studies for children have shown a positive effect in promoting self-actualization and developing receptive, cognitive, and expressive capabilities.[4][5] While the studies conducted with adults 18+ had overall positive effects, the conclusions were limited because of overt bias and small sample sizes.

Since music is a fundamental aspect of every culture, it embodies every human emotion and even can transport us to an earlier time, an earlier memory. Oliver Sacks, author of Musicophilia, acknowledges the unconscious effects of music as our body tends to join in the rhythmic motions involuntarily.[6] Working with clients with a variety of neurological conditions, Sacks observed the therapeutic potential and susceptibility to music. Even with the loss of language, music becomes the vehicle for expression, feeling, and interaction.

Well-known music therapists Paul Nordoff and Clive Robbins documented their work with audio recordings and videos of the transformative results of music with children who had emotional or behavioral problems, traumatic experiences, or handicaps. Robbins classifies the “Music Child” as the inner self in every child that evokes a healthy musical response.[4] It is music that becomes the catalyst for discovering the child’s potential. In essence, musical play creates an atmosphere that emboldens a child to free expression and reproductive skills. Sometimes family members observe immediate effects because selfhood is encouraged and nurtured and thus a child’s personality develops in response to music.  

First, the music therapist assesses each client to determine impairments, preferences, and skill level. Notably, every person appreciates different musical genres. Next, treatment is determined based on individualized goals and selection as well as frequency and length of sessions. Finally, the progress of the client is evaluated and updated based on effectiveness. Although sessions are typically structured, therapist also remain flexible and try to meet clients where they are at emotionally and physically.

When music therapy was first introduced in tandem with other medical fields, it was mostly receptive and patients listened to live solo performances or pre-recorded songs. Today, music therapist allow for more creative interactions by having clients improvise, reproduce music or imitate melodies vocally or with an instrument, compose their own songs, and/or listen during artistic expression or with movement.  

Recently, studies have been conducted on the effects of music with chemo patients, stroke patients,[7][8] patients with Alzheimer,[9] spinal or brain injury,[10][11] and hospice patients.[12] According to a 2017 report from Magee, Clark, Tamplin, and Bradt,[13] a common theme of all their studies was the positive effect music had on mood, mental and physical state, increase in motivation and social engagement, and a connection with the client’s musical identity. From 2008-2012, the Department of Oncology/ Hematology of the University Medical Center in Hamburg-Eppendorf orchestrated a randomized pilot study to determine if music therapy helped patients cope with pain and reduce chemotherapy side effects.[14] The sessions were given twice a week for twenty minutes and patients could choose either receptive or active methods. Each week, the quality of life, functioning ability and level of depression/anxiety were assessed. Although emotional functioning scores increased and perception of pain improved significantly, they determined the outcome was inconclusive because patients have differing levels of manageable side effects and a hope to survive may influence expectations of treatment. However, patients rated the program helpful and potentially beneficial. Moreover, the feasibility of these studies allows for music therapists to practice in educational, psychiatric, medical, and private settings. Although there haven’t been any statistical significance based on few empirical adult studies, the trend shows improvements on most measures.

ReferencesEdit

  1. ^ Peter D. Kramer (2007-10-28). "Melodies and Maladies". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2007-12-26.
  2. ^ "Book World's Holiday Issue". The Washington Post. 2007-12-02. Retrieved 2007-12-26.
  3. ^ “Music and the Brain: What Happens When You're Listening to Music.” Pegasus Magazine, University of Central Florida, www.ucf.edu/pegasus/your-brain-on-music/.
  4. ^ a b Guerrero, Nina; Turry, Alan; Geller, Daniel; Raghavan, Preeti (2014). "From Historic to Contemporary: Nordoff-Robbins Music Therapy in Collaborative Interdisciplinary Rehabilitation". Music Therapy Perspectives. 32 (1): 38–46. doi:10.1093/mtp/miu014. ISSN 0734-6875.
  5. ^ Bruscia, Kenneth. (2014). Case Studies in Music Therapy. Barcelona Publishers. ISBN 978-1-891278-60-0. OCLC 956277739.
  6. ^ Sacks, Oliver, 1933-2015, author., Musicophilia, OCLC 1107668220CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  7. ^ Kim, Dong Soo; Park, Yoon Ghil; Choi, Jung Hwa; Im, Sang-Hee; Jung, Kang Jae; Cha, Young A; Jung, Chul Oh; Yoon, Yeo Hoon (2011). "Effects of Music Therapy on Mood in Stroke Patients". Yonsei Medical Journal. 52 (6): 977–81. doi:10.3349/ymj.2011.52.6.977. ISSN 0513-5796. PMC 3220261. PMID 22028163.
  8. ^ Poćwierz-Marciniak, Ilona; Bidzan, Mariola (2017). "The influence of music therapy on quality of life after a stroke". Health Psychology Report. 2: 173–185. doi:10.5114/hpr.2017.63936. ISSN 2353-4184.
  9. ^ Hsiung, Ging-Yuek; Kirkland, Kevin; Hswen, Yulin; Slack, Penelope J.; Summers, Susan; Boyd, Lara; Jacova, Claudia (July 2013). "A pilot, randomized study of music therapy for people with Alzheimer's disease". Alzheimer's & Dementia. 9 (4): P477. doi:10.1016/j.jalz.2013.05.972.
  10. ^ Mondanaro, John; Loewy, Joanne (2015-07-09). "Music Therapy with Adolescents in Medical Settings". Oxford Handbooks Online. doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199639755.013.43.
  11. ^ Rebecca, West; Michael, J. Silverman (February 2020). "A music therapy feasibility study with adults on a hospital neuroscience unit: Investigating service user technique choices and immediate effects on mood and pain". The Arts in Psychotherapy. 67: 101585. doi:10.1016/j.aip.2019.101585.
  12. ^ Porter, Sam; McConnell, Tracey; Graham-Wisener, Lisa; Regan, Joan; McKeown, Miriam; Kirkwood, Jenny; Clarke, Mike; Gardner, Evie; Dorman, Saskie; McGrillen, Kerry; Reid, Joanne (December 2018). "A randomised controlled pilot and feasibility study of music therapy for improving the quality of life of hospice inpatients". BMC Palliative Care. 17 (1): 125. doi:10.1186/s12904-018-0378-1. ISSN 1472-684X. PMC 6260709. PMID 30482192.
  13. ^ Magee, Wendy L; Clark, Imogen; Tamplin, Jeanette; Bradt, Joke (2017-01-20). Cochrane Stroke Group (ed.). "Music interventions for acquired brain injury". Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 1: CD006787. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD006787.pub3. PMC 6464962. PMID 28103638.
  14. ^ Kordovan, Sarah; Preissler, Pia; Kamphausen, Anne; Bokemeyer, Carsten; Oechsle, Karin (April 2016). "Prospective Study on Music Therapy in Terminally Ill Cancer Patients during Specialized Inpatient Palliative Care". Journal of Palliative Medicine. 19 (4): 394–399. doi:10.1089/jpm.2015.0384. ISSN 1096-6218. PMID 26894922.

External linksEdit