The manifesto was published in two versions (October 11, 1849, and December 1849) by the Annexation Association, an alliance of 325 Montreal businessmen.[Note 1] Most of these were English-speaking Tories, who were opposed to Britain's abolition of the Corn Laws, which ended preferential colonial trade, and by its consent to the Rebellion Losses Bill, and French Canadian nationalists (including Louis-Joseph Papineau) who supported the republican system of government in the United States. These businessmen believed that so long as Canada was under British rule, it would be subjected to the interests of elements of Britain's aristocracy and businessmen. Papineau too had believed a similar subjection occurred, perpetrated by France.
The signatories believed that, given the tiny population and limited transportation routes in Canada compared to that of the United States, the abolition of customs duties at such an early point in Canada's economic development would be disastrous for Canadian business. They predicted a lack of foreign capital investment leading to economic downturn and massive job losses.
News of the annexation movement and its manifesto was widely reported in New York. The New-York Daily Tribune sent a correspondent to Montreal. The New York Herald and New York Times newspapers both responded with editorials proposing that the British colony should first negotiate independence from the UK's rule, as an intermediate step before joining with the United States.
The manifesto was strongly opposed by members of the British American League and by leading politicians such as Robert Baldwin plus the followers of Louis-Hippolyte Lafontaine. After the signing of the Canadian–American Reciprocity Treaty in 1854, the annexation movement died out.
- William Tetley lists the signatories in his article "Cornelius Krieghoff, the Shakspeare Club and the Annexation Manifesto".
- Tetley, William (September 14, 2006), "Cornelius Krieghoff, the Shakspeare Club and the Annexation Manifesto" (PDF), Tetley's maritime & admiralty law website, Montreal, QC, Canada: McGill University, retrieved November 7, 2009,
Equally important and disturbing is the fact that on October 11, 1849 a manifesto (dated September 14, 1849) was presented favouring the annexation of Lower Canada to the United States.
- Ontario History. Vol. 62. Ontario Historical Society. 1970. p. 41.
- Patrick Richard Carstens and Timothy L (2013). The Republic of Canada Almost. Xlibris Corporation. p. 352. ISBN 978-1-4797-4915-7.
- Monet, Jacques, "Annexation Association", The Canadian Encyclopedia, Toronto, ON, Canada: The Historica Dominion Institute, OCLC 439558183, archived from the original on August 16, 2007, retrieved November 7, 2009,
Annexation Association, founded 1849 to promote Canada-US political union. In October and December it published 2 versions of the "Annexation Manifesto."
- Publications of the Hudson's Bay Record Society. 1959. p. 795.
- W.P. Morrell (28 October 2013). British Colonial Policy in the Age of Peel and Russell. Taylor & Francis. p. 162. ISBN 978-1-136-24353-0.
- Reginald C. Stuart (1988). United States Expansionism and British North America, 1775-1871. University of North Carolina Press. p. 94. ISBN 978-0-8078-1767-4.
- Gordon Martel; Wayne Lavender (16 June 1986). Studies in British Imperial History: Essays in Honour of A.P. Thornton. Palgrave Macmillan UK. pp. 71–72. ISBN 978-1-349-18244-2.
- Works related to Montreal Annexation Manifesto at Wikisource