Modernism in the Catholic Church
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages)(Learn how and when to remove this template message)
In a Catholic context, modernism refers to a loose gestalt of liberal theological opinions that developed in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Writing in the Catholic Encyclopedia, Arthur Vermeersch describes modernism thus: "In general we may say that modernism aims at that radical transformation of human thought in relation to God, man, the world, and life, here and hereafter, which was prepared by Humanism and eighteenth-century philosophy, and solemnly promulgated at the French Revolution." The term came to prominence in Pope Pius X's 1907 encyclical Pascendi dominici gregis, which synthesizes and condemns modernism as embracing every heresy.  The movement was influenced by Protestant theologians and clergy, starting with the Tübingen School in the mid-19th century. Pius charged that it was prominent in French and British intellectual circles and, to a lesser extent, in Italy. The term is generally used by critics of rather than adherents to positions associated with it.
Liberal Catholicism was a current of thought within the Catholic Church that was influential in the 19th century and the first half of the 20th, especially in France. It is largely identified with French political theorists such as Felicité Robert de Lamennais, Henri Lacordaire, and Charles Forbes René de Montalembert influenced, in part, by a similar contemporaneous movement in Belgium.Engelbert Sterckx, Archdiocese of Mechelen, a skilled negotiator with a natural inclination to conciliatory pragmatism, had managed to take advantage of the new freedoms to completely reorganized the Archdiocese, establishing schools, colleges, monasteries, charities and minor seminaries in Hoogstraten and Waver. Lamennais and his associates saw no conflict between Catholicism and liberal reform. They advocated for an enlarged suffrage, separation of church and state, and universal freedom of conscience, instruction, assembly, and the press.
In August 1832, Pope Gregory XVI issued the encyclical Mirari vos (On Liberalism and Religious Indifferentism). He attacked religious indifferentism, which was defined as the opinion that one religion is as good as another, which he saw as the basis for the argument for liberty of conscience. He also denounced secret societies that sought overturn the legitimate governments of the Italian states, and the freedom to publish or distribute any writings indiscriminately.
Lamennais, under attack from French conservatives, issued in 1834 the book, Paroles d'un croyant (Words of a Believer), in which he denounced all authority, civil as well as ecclesiastical. Paroles marked Lamennais' turn to a Christian socialism that inspired a whole generation. His radical ideas reflected an overlap of Catholic and socialist discourses that can be traced back to the 1820s.The experience of the popes during the recent revolutions, being expelled from Rome, widespread unrest in the Papal States and temporal power to anti-Catholic forces, and the erosion of even spiritual allegiance, predisposed the reaction of the Papacy. Gregory XVI's reaction was entirely predictable. He issued a second encyclical, Singulari Nos in June 1834, condemning the book and the ideas expressed therein.
In August 1863, Montalembert, gave a series of speeches in Mechelen, Belgium in which he held forth on his views concerning the future of modern society and the Church. His first speech aimed to show the necessity of Christianizing the democracy by accepting modern liberties. His second speech dealt with liberty of conscience, and the conclusion he drew was that the Church could be in perfect harmony with religious liberty and with the modern state. Being largely political in nature, Liberal Catholicism was distinct from, but contemporary with the theological movement of modernism.
Catholic studies in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries avoided the use of critical methodology because of its rationalist tendencies. Frequent political revolutions, bitter opposition of “liberalism” to the church, and the expulsion of religious orders from France and Germany, made the church understandably suspicious of the new intellectual currents of the period.
In 1863, Ernest Renan published Vie de Jésus (Life of Jesus). Renan had trained for the priesthood, before choosing instead a secular career as a philologist and historian. In Vie de Jésus he described Jesus as "Un homme incomparable", a man, no doubt extraordinary, but only a man. The book was very popular, but cost him his chair of Hebrew at the College de France. Among Renan’s most controversial ideas was that "a miracle does not count as a historical event; people believing in a miracle does. Renan’s Jesus is a man of simple piety and almost unimaginable charisma whose main historical significance was his legion of followers."
Gregory XVI was succeeded by Pope Pius IX, who, in December 1864, issued an encyclical, Quanta cura, decries what he considers significant errors afflicting the modern age. In it he condemned certain propositions such as: the people’s will, manifested by what is called public opinion ..., constitutes a supreme law, free from all divine and human control; "on civil law alone depend all rights of parents over their children, and especially that of providing for education; and that Religious orders have no legitimate reason for being permitted to exist. Some of these condemnations were aimed at anticlerical governments in various European countries, which had been recently and would in the next few years be secularizing education and taking over Catholic schools, suppressing religious orders, and confiscating their property. Attached to the encyclical was a "Syllabus of Errors". The Syllabus was a list of errors previously condemned in other documents, it therefore required recourse to the original statement to understand the context. The government of France briefly tried to suppress the circulation of the encyclical and the Syllabus within its borders; it forbade priests to explain the Syllabus from the pulpit, though newspapers were allowed to discuss it from a secular point of view. Among the condemned propositions listed were:
- "7. The prophecies and miracles set forth and recorded in the Sacred Scriptures are the fiction of poets, and the mysteries of the Christian faith the result of philosophical investigations. In the books of the Old and the New Testament there are contained mythical inventions, and Jesus Christ is Himself a myth."
- "13. The method and principles by which the old scholastic doctors cultivated theology are no longer suitable to the demands of our times and to the progress of the sciences."—"Letters to the Archbishop of Munich", "Tuas libenter," Dec. 21, 1863.
First Vatican CouncilEdit
The First Vatican Council was held from December 1869 to October 1870. It was convoked to deal with the issue of the rising influence of rationalism, liberalism, and materialism. The objects of the council were to be the correction of modern errors and a revision of the Church legislation. The council provoked a degree of controversy even before it met. In anticipation that the subject of papal infallibility would be discussed, a number of bishops expressed the opinion that the time was "inopportune". Ignaz von Döllinger, provost of St. Cajetan and professor of church history at Munich led a movement in Germany hostile to the council. Six years before, he had invited 100 theologians to meet at Mechelen and discuss the question which the liberals Lamennais and Lacordaire had raised in France, namely, the attitude that should be assumed by the Roman Catholic Church towards modern ideas. In his address, “On the Past and Future of Catholic Theology”, Döllinger advocated for greater academic freedom.
The dogmatic Constitution on the Catholic Faith defended the fundamental principles of Christianity against the errors of modern Rationalism, Materialism, and atheism. The other dogmatic Constitution addressed the primacy of the pope and rejected the idea that decrees issued by the pope for the guidance of the Church are not valid unless confirmed by the secular power. It also declared the infallibility of the pope when speaking "ex cathedra" on matters of faith. Other matters were deferred when the Piedmontese infantry entered Rome and the council was prorogued.
Louis Duchesne was a French priest, philologist, teacher, and amateur archaeologist. Trained at the École pratique des Hautes Études in Paris, he applied modern methods to Church history, drawing together archaeology and topography to supplement literature and setting ecclesiastical events within the contexts of social history. Duchesne held the chair of ecclesiastical history at the Institut Catholique de Paris, and was frequently in contact with like-minded historians among the Bollandists, with their long history of critical editions of hagiographies. Duchesne gained fame as a demythologizing critical historian of the popular, pious lives of saints produced by Second Empire publishers. However, his Histoire ancienne de l'Église, 1906‑11 (translated as Early History of the Christian Church) was considered too modernist by the Church at the time, and was placed on the Index of Forbidden Books in 1912.
Alfred Loisy was a French Roman Catholic priest, professor and theologian generally credited as a founder of Biblical Modernism in the Roman Catholic Church. He had studied at the École pratique des Hautes Études under Louis Duchesne. Harvey Hill says that the development of Loisy's theories originated not within an early modernist movement, but within the context of France's Church-State conflict, which contributed to Loisy's crisis of faith in the 1880's. In November 1893, Loisy published the last lecture of his course, in which he summed up his position on Biblical criticism in five propositions: the Pentateuch was not the work of Moses, the first five chapters of Genesis were not literal history, the New Testament and the Old Testament did not possess equal historical value, there was a development in scriptural doctrine, and Biblical writings were subject to the same limitations as those by other authors of the ancient world.Loisy came to regard the Christian religion more as a system of humanistic ethics than as divine revelation. Loisy was excommunicated in 1908.
Pope Leo XIIIEdit
In 1878, Pope Leo XIII had encouraged the study of history and archaeology. In 1887 he encouraged the study of the natural sciences, and in 1891 opened the Vatican Observatory. Leo's response to the modernist trend to undermine the authority of sacred scripture, was for the Church to have its own trained experts. In 1893, with Providentissimus Deus, Pope Leo gave the first formal authorization for the use of critical methods in biblical scholarship. "Hence it is most proper that Professors of Sacred Scripture and theologians should master those tongues in which the sacred Books were originally written, and have a knowledge of natural science.. He recommended that the student of scripture be first given a sound grounding in the interpretations of the Fathers such as Tertullian, Cyprian, Hilary, Ambrose, Leo the Great, Gregory the Great, Augustine and Jerome, and understand what they interpreted literally, and what allegorically; and note what they lay down as belonging to faith and what is opinion.
At the turn of the 20th century the official Catholic attitude to the study of holy Scripture was one of cautious advance, and at the same time of a growing appreciation of what had promise for the future. In 1902, Pope Leo XIII instituted the Pontifical Biblical Commission, which was to adapt Roman Catholic Biblical studies to modern scholarship and to protect Scripture against attacks.
In 1890 the École Biblique, the first Catholic school specifically dedicated to the critical study of the bible, was established in Jerusalem by Dominican Marie-Joseph Lagrange.In 1892 Leo gave his official approval. While many of LaGrange's contemporaries criticized the new scientific and critical approach to the Bible, he made use of it. LaGrange founded the Revue biblique, and his first articles drew sharp criticism, but Pope Leo was not inclined to discourage new ideas. As long as Pope Leo lived, LaGrange's work quietly progressed, but after Leo's death, an ultra-conservative reaction set in. The Historical-Critical Method was considered suspect by the Vatican. Père Lagrange, like other scholars involved in the 19th-century renaissance of biblical studies, was suspected of being a Modernist. In 1912 Lagrange was given an order for the Revue Biblique to cease publication and to return to France. The École itself was closed for a year, and then LaGrange was sent back to Jerusalem to continue his work.
Forms of modernismEdit
- A rationalistic approach to the Bible. The rationalism that was characteristic of the Enlightenment took a protomaterialistic view of miracles and of the historicity of biblical narratives. This approach sought to interpret the Bible by focusing on the text itself as a prelude to considering what the Church Fathers had traditionally taught about it.
- Secularism and other Enlightenment ideals. The ideal of secularism can be briefly stated as follows: the best course of action in politics and other civic fields is that which flows from a common understanding of the Good by various groups and religions.
- Modern philosophical systems. Philosophers such as Kant and Bergson inspired the mainstream of modernist thought. One of the latter’s main currents attempted to synthesize the vocabularies, epistemologies, metaphysics and other features of certain modern systems of philosophy with Catholicism in much the same way as the Scholastic order had earlier attempted to synthesize Platonic and Aristotelian philosophy with the Church's teaching.
- Theological rebellion in contradistinction or opposition to the Church's official policies.
As more naturalistic and scientific studies of history appeared, a way of thinking called historicism arose which suggested that ideas are conditioned by the age in which they are expressed; thus modernists generally believed that most dogma or teachings of the Church were novelties which arose because of specific circumstances obtaining at given points in its history. At the same time rationalism and literary criticism reduced the possible role of the miraculous, so that the philosophical systems in vogue at the time taught among other things that the existence of God could never be known (see Agnosticism). Theology, formerly “queen of the sciences”, was dethroned.[full citation needed]
Evolution of dogmaEdit
The final overall teaching of modernism is that dogmata (the teachings of the Church, which its members are required to believe) can evolve over time – not only in their expression but also in their substance – rather than remaining the same in substance for all time. This postulate was what made modernism unique in the history of heresies in the Church. Previously, a heretic (someone who believed and taught something different from what the rest of the church believed) would either claim that he was right and the rest of the Church was wrong because he had received a new revelation from God, or that he had understood the true teaching of God which had previously been understood but was later lost. Both of these scenarios almost inevitably led to an organisational separation from the Church (schism) or the offender’s being ejected from it (excommunication). Using the new idea that doctrines evolve, it was possible for the modernist to believe that both the old teachings of the Church and his new, seemingly contradictory teachings were correct — each group had its time and place. This system allows almost any type of new belief which the modernist in question might wish to introduce, and for this reason modernism was labelled by Pope Pius X as "the synthesis of all heresies".
The "evolution of dogma" theory (see Development of doctrine), much in the manner of Luther’s theory of salvation sola fide ('by faith alone') allows for a constant updating of standards of morality. The phrase sola fide derives from Pange Lingua Gloriosi Corporis Mysterium, a Eucharistic hymn by St. Thomas Aquinas: et si sensus deficit, | ad firmandum cor sincerum | sola fides sufficit. Since majority moral standards shifted heavily during the 20th century, Catholics not accepting the theory were placed in the position of having to abstain from receiving Communion if they wished to engage in some of the actions of some of their fellow-religionists.
Pope Pius X, who succeeded Leo, was the first to identify modernism as a movement. He frequently condemned both its aims and ideas, and was deeply concerned by the ability of modernism to allow its adherents to go on believing themselves strict Catholics while having an understanding markedly different from the traditional one as to what that meant (a consequence of the notion of evolution of dogma). In July 1907 the Holy Office published the document Lamentabili sane exitu, a sweeping condemnation which distinguished sixty-five propositions as modernist heresies. In September of the same year Pius X promulgated an encyclical Pascendi dominici gregis, followed in 1910 by the introduction of an anti-modernist oath to be taken by all Catholic bishops, priests and academic teachers of religion.
To ensure enforcement of these decisions, Monsignor Umberto Benigni organized, through his personal contacts with theologians, an unofficial group of censors who would report to him those thought to be teaching condemned doctrine. This group was called the Sodalitium Pianum, i.e. Fellowship of Pius (X), which in France was known as La Sapinière. Its frequently overzealous and clandestine methods often hindered rather than helped the Church in its combat with modernism.
In the period between World War II and the Cold War Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange O.P. was the "torchbearer of orthodox Thomism" against modernism. Garrigou-Lagrange, who was a professor of philosophy and theology at the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas, Angelicum, is commonly held to have influenced the decision in 1942 to place the privately circulated book Une école de théologie: le Saulchoir (Étiolles 1937) by Marie-Dominique Chenu O.P. on the Vatican's "Index of Forbidden Books" as the culmination of a polemic within the Dominican Order between the Angelicum supporters of a speculative scholasticism and the French revival Thomists who were more attentive to historical hermeneutics, such as Yves Congar O.P.. Congar's Chrétiens désunis was also suspected of modernism because its methodology derived more from religious experience than from syllogistic analysis.[page needed][page needed]
Since Pope Paul VI, most Church authorities have largely dropped the term "modernism", preferring instead in the interest of precision to call beliefs such as secularism, liberalism or relativism by their several names. The older term has however remained current in the usage of many Traditionalist Catholics and conservative critics within the Church.
- George Tyrrell (1861–1909), expelled from the Jesuits in 1906 for his views
- Maude Petre (1863–1942), English nun, close friend of Tyrrell, and a participant in the modernist movement as well as one of its first historians and critics
- Ernesto Buonaiuti (1881–1946), who as a scholar of the history of Christianity and of religious philosophy, was a leader in the Italian modernist movement
- Pierre Batiffol (1861–1929), historian of dogma
- Friedrich von Hügel
Less public modernistsEdit
This section does not cite any sources. (September 2016) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
- Vermeersch, Arthur (1911). "Modernism". The Catholic Encyclopedia. 10. New York: Robert Appleton Company. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Pope Pius X (8 September 1907). "Pascendi Dominici Gregis". The Holy See (in Latin). Retrieved 8 June 2016.Pascendi dominici gregis
- O'Connell, Marvin Richard (1994). Critics on Trial: An Introduction to the Catholic Modernist Crisis. Washington, D.C.: Catholic University of America Press. ISBN 9780813208008. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Bury, J.P.T., "Religion and Relations of Churches and States", The New Cambridge Modern History, Vol. 10, CUP Archive, 1960 ISBN 9780521045483
- Viaene, Vincent. Belgium and the Holy See from Gregory XVI to Pius IX (1831-1859), Universitaire Pers Leuven, 2001, p. 82ISBN 9789058671387
- "Englebert Sterckx", Das Portal zur katholischen Geisteswelt
- Chadwick, Owen. "Gregory XVI", A History of the Popes, 1830-1914, Oxford University Press, 2003 ISBN 9780199262861
- Strube, Julian (2016). Sozialismus, Katholizismus und Okkultismus im Frankreich des 19. Jahrhunderts. De Gruyter, Berlin/Boston ISBN 978-3-11-047810-5.
- Schultenover, S.J., David G., A View from Rome: On the Eve of the Modernist Crisis, New York: Fordham University Press, 1993
- Goyau, Georges. "Comte de Montalembert." The Catholic Encyclopedia Vol. 10. New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1911. 9 January 2019 This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
- "Modernism". New Catholic Encyclopedia. The Gale Group Inc. 2003. Retrieved 17 May 2019 – via Encyclopedia.com.
- Donahue, John R., "Biblical Scholarship 50 years After Divino Afflante Spiritu", America, September 18, 1993
- Theiss, Will. "The Pale Galilean: Ernest Renan, Jesus, and Modern History", Marginalia, Los Angeles Review of Books, March 16, 2018
- Pope Pius IX. Quanta Cura, §4, December 8, 1864
- Hales, E.E.Y. The Catholic Church in the Modern World, (Doubleday, 1958)
- Howard, Thomas Albert. "A Question of Conscience", Commonweal, September 29, 2014
- Kirch, Joseph. "Vatican Council." The Catholic Encyclopedia Vol. 15. New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1912. 15 May 2019 This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
- De Smedt, Charles. "The Bollandists." The Catholic Encyclopedia. Vol. 2. New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907. March 15, 2013 This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
- Strenski, Ivan. Theology and the First Theory of Sacrifice, BRILL, 2003, p. 220 ISBN 9789047402732
- Wolfgang Weiß (1993). "Loisy, Alfred Firmin". In Bautz, Traugott (ed.). Biographisch-Bibliographisches Kirchenlexikon (BBKL) (in German). 5. Herzberg: Bautz. cols. 190–196. ISBN 3-88309-043-3.
- Boynton, Richard Wilson. "The Catholic Career of Alfred Loisy", The Harvard Theological Review, Vol. 11, No. 1 (1918), pp. 36-73, Cambridge University Press
- Schultenover, David G."The Politics of Modernism: Alfred Loisy and the Scientific Study of Religion (review)", The Catholic Historical Review, vol. 89 no. 1, 2003, pp. 114-115
- Encyclopedia Americana (Volume 17: 1969), pgs 707-708. Article by Francis J. Hemelt of The Catholic University of America
- Murphy, Richard T. “The Teachings of the Encyclical ‘Providentissimus Deus’”, The Catholic Biblical Quarterly, vol. 5, no. 2, 1943, pp. 125–140. JSTOR
- Prior, Joseph G., The Historical Critical Method in Catholic Exegesis, Gregorian Biblical BookShop, 1999 ISBN 9788876528255
- Pope Leo XIII. "Providentissimus Deus", §17, November 18, 1893, Libreria Editrice Vaticana
- Providentissimus Deus, §18.
- Providentissimus Deus, §7.
- Providentissimus Deus, §19.
- "Regarding history of Biblical interpretation", Catholic Sentinel, Archdiocese of Portland., December 13, 2011
- "Biblical Commission." Cross, F. L., ed. The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church. New York: Oxford University Press. 2005
- Becker O.P., John Vianney. "Pere LaGrange", Dominicana
- "Our Founder",, École biblique et archéologique française de Jerusalem
- Wilkinson, 2002
- Akin, James (November 1994). "Modernism". This Rock.
- "Modernism (Roman Catholicism)". Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. 8 December 2006. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Thomas Marschler (2002). "Benigni, Umberto". In Bautz, Traugott (ed.). Biographisch-Bibliographisches Kirchenlexikon (BBKL) (in German). 20. Nordhausen: Bautz. cols. 113–116. ISBN 3-88309-091-3.
- Losito, Giacomo (2011). "Le eredità/2: i postumi della crisi modernista [1914-1958]" [Inheritances / 2: The Aftermath of the Modernist Crisis [1914-1958]]. Treccani (in Italian). l'Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Congar, Yves (1937). Chrétiens désunis: principes d'un "oecuménisme" catholique [Disunited Christians: Principles of a Catholic "Ecumenism"]. Unam sanctam (in French). 1. Paris: Éditions du Cerf. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- McBrien, Richard P., ed. (1995). "Modernism". The HarperCollins Encyclopedia of Catholicism (1st ed.). New York: Harper Collins. p. 304. ISBN 9780060653385. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- McInerny, Ralph (2006). Praeambula Fidei: Thomism and the God of the Philosophers. Washington, D.C.: Catholic University of America Press. ISBN 9780813214580. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Altholz, Josef L. (1962). The Liberal Catholic Movement in England: The 'Rambler' and its Contributors, 1848-1864. London: Burns & Oates.
- Arnold, Claus (2007). Kleine Geschichte des Modernimus. Freiburg i. B.: Herder.
- Arnold Claus; Vian, Giovanni, eds. (2017). The Reception and Application of the Encyclical Pascendi. The Reports of the Diocesan Bishops and the Superiors of the Religious Orders until 1914. Venezia: Edizioni Ca' Foscari.
- Amerio, Romano (1996). Iota Unum: A Study of Changes in the Catholic Church in the XXth Century. Kansas City, Missouri: Sarto House. ISBN 9780963903211. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Botti, Alfonso; Cerrato, Rocco, eds. (2000). Il Modernismo Tra Cristianitā e Secolarizzazione: Atti Del Convegno Internazionale Di Urbino, 1-4 Ottobre 1997 [Modernism between Christianity and Secularization: Proceedings of the International Conference of Urbino, 1–4 October 1997]. Studi e testi (in Italian). 6. QuattroVenti. ISBN 9788839205452. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Botti, Alfonso; Cerrato, Rocco; Biagioli, Ilaria, eds. (2004). Romolo Murri e i murrismi in Italia e in Europa cent'anni dopo: atti del Convegno internazionale di Urbino, 24-26 settembre 2001 [Romolo Murri and the Murrismi in Italy and in Europe One Hundred Years Later: Proceedings of the International Conference of Urbino, 24–26 September 2001]. Studi e testi (in Italian). 7. QuattroVenti. ISBN 9788839206817. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Bourmaud, Dominique (2006). One Hundred Years of Modernism: A History of Modernism, Aristotle to the Second Vatican Council. Kansas City, Missouri: Angelus Press. ISBN 9781892331434. OCLC 72871306. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Dalberg-Acton, John Emerich Edward (1907). Figgis, John Neville; Laurence, Reginald Vere (eds.). The History of Freedom and Other Essays. London: Macmillan and Co., Ltd. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Fawkes, Alfred (17 July 2015) . Studies in Modernism. London: Forgotten Books. OCLC 3307790. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Gauthier, Pierre (1988). Newman et Blondel: tradition et développement du dogme [Newman and Blondel: Tradition and the Development of Dogma]. Cogitatio fidei (in French). 147. Éditions du Cerf. ISBN 9782204028547. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Hales, Edward Elton Young (1960). The Catholic Church in the Modern World: A Survey from the French Revolution to the Present. Image Books. 95. Garden City, New York: Doubleday. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Hales, Edward Elton Young (1954). Pio Nono: A Study in European Politics and Religion in the Nineteenth Century (2nd ed.). London: Eyre and Spottiswoode. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Izquierdo, César (1990). Blondel y la crisis modernista: análysis de "Historia y dogma" [Blondel and the Modernist Crisis: Analysis of "History and Dogma"]. Colección teológica de la Universidad de Navarra. 71 (Illustrated ed.). Pamplona: Ediciones Universidad de Navarra. ISBN 9788431310998. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Jodock, Darrell, ed. (2000). Catholicism Contending with Modernity: Roman Catholic Modernism and Anti-Modernism in Historical Context. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521770712. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Loome, Thomas Michael (1979). Liberal Catholicism, Reform Catholicism, Modernism: A Contribution to a New Orientation in Modernist Research. Tübinger theologische Studien. 14. Mainz: Matthias-Grünewald-Verlag. ISBN 3786706603.
- Mettepenningen, Jürgen (2010). Nouvelle Théologie - New Theology: Inheritor of Modernism, Precursor of Vatican II. New York: Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 9780567299918. OCLC 676696271. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- O'Connell, Marvin Richard (1994). Critics on Trial: An Introduction to the Catholic Modernist Crisis. Washington, D.C.: Catholic University of America Press. ISBN 9780813208008. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Poulat, Émile (1979). Histoire, dogme et critique dans la crise moderniste [History, Dogma, and Critique in the Modernist Crisis]. Religion et Sociétés. 67. Tournai: Casterman. ISBN 9782203290563. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Providentissimus Deus. Leo XIII. 18 November 1893.
- Sinke Guimara̋es, Atila (1999). In the Murky Waters of Vatican II. Eli, Eli, Lamma sabacthani?. 1 (2nd ed.). Tan Books and Publishers. ISBN 9780895556363. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Vian, Giovanni (2012). Il modernismo. La Chiesa cattolica in conflitto con la modernità. Roma: Carocci.
- Virgoulay, René (1980). Blondel et le modernisme: la philosophie de l'action et les sciences religieuses, 1896-1913. Paris: Éditions du Cerf. ISBN 9782204015097. Retrieved 8 June 2016.
- Bourmaud, Fr. Dominique, One Hundred Years of Modernism: A Genealogy of the Principles of the Second Vatican Council
- Garrigou-Lagrange, Réginald (2013). The Essence & Topicality of Thomism. ISBN 9781304416186. — Fr. Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P., explains why Thomism is the solution to the present crisis of Modernism in the Church.
- Providentissimus Deus, Leo XIII, 18 November 1893
- Lamentabili sane, Pius X, 3 July 1907
- Pascendi dominici gregis, Pius X, 8 September 1907
- International Catholic University: James Hitchcock, Introduction to Modernism: Essays with bibliography arranged by subjects, headed “Note: Most of the works dealing with Modernism are sympathetic to the Modernists, and students should maintain a critical stance towards the assigned readings.”
- Fr. Michael Morton, “Catholic Modernism (1896-1914)”
- Herbermann, Charles, ed. (1913). . Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.