Minors and the legality of cannabis
Minors and the legality of cannabis is one of the issues around the legalisation of cannabis, with most jurisdictions placing strict age limits in a similar way as is done with the drinking age for alcohol.
The details differ greatly: in Uruguay consumption is legal for those that are at least 18 years old; in the U.S. eight states have legalized cannabis for recreational use for individuals that are at least 21 years old - while in the Netherlands, all drugs are technically illegal, but those 18 years old and older can smoke cannabis within a “coffeeshop".
Health and cannabis among minorsEdit
Countries tend to regulate cannabis differently depending on the way in which they view cannabis and its potential effects on individuals, including minors. One reason that individuals are concerned about the use among minors is because of the higher chance of dependency that studies have shown. Epidemiologists have found that 9% of people who begin smoking marijuana at 19 years or older satisfy the criteria of dependency and this number triples at ages under 18 years old. The reason for this is that a minor's brain is under rapid development when they are young. Studies have also shown that anxiety and depressive disorders have been the product of cannabis use and exposure among minors.
Medical cannabis is used for children with severe illnesses such as cancer and epilepsy. The use of cannabis relieves the pain and is seen as a “healthier” alternative because it is less addictive than drugs such as morphine and Oxycontin. Other pain-relieving medicines that are opioids tend to cause nausea and vomiting, while cannabis reduces these side effects. Because of this, many advocates argue that if opioids are acceptable to treat a minor’s pain, then cannabis should be as well. As cannabis consumption among minors has increased, the rate at which they consume alcohol and smoke cigarettes has decreased dramatically.
In the United StatesEdit
In the United States, marijuana is illegal under the federal Controlled Substances Act, but most states have legalized some form of medical marijuana, and a smaller but growing number of states have legalized marijuana for recreational use by adults. However, "it is currently illegal in all 50 states for minors to use marijuana recreationally." In some states (such as Illinois, Pennsylvania, and Connecticut) minors may use certain forms of marijuana for medical use if certain specific conditions are met.
Uruguay legalized cannabis in 2014. Uruguay is the first nation in the world to regulate all aspects of the cannabis market (production, sales, and consumption) for those that are at least 18 years old. The reason for its proposed legalization was to get rid of the organized crime and violence that came along with the illegal drug industry. Their efforts to legalize the drug were not done because of social pressure, but more so out of the efforts to protect society from the dangers that are produced from an illegal market. Uruguay’s government wanted to seize the market from criminals, not encourage individuals to smoke cannabis. The law that was put into place states that an individual can have up to six plants at their home, cannabis will be sold over the counter, buyers must sign up for a registry that permits the purchase of cannabis, and there is a 40-gram cap per month.
Despite cannabis being legalized in Uruguay, over 60 percent of people in the country believe legalization should be repealed. Many individuals are doubtful that the legalization of cannabis will get rid of criminal organizations, such as the drug cartel. While criminal groups will not be able to compete with the legalized cannabis costs, they will be able to fall back on other activities such as trafficking and selling harder drugs, which can lead to larger crime. Because the purpose of legalization is for public health and safety reasons, publicity or advertising is against the law. Any kind of publicity of cannabis is prohibited, meaning there cannot be any billboards or advertisements for the drug. Because of the strong opposition of legalization within Uruguay, there is no movement towards legalization of cannabis for minors.
Effects on minorsEdit
Despite the skepticism within society, data has shown that among regular consumers, young individuals are most likely to be the ones consuming cannabis. The age in which one can possess and consume cannabis is 18. In comparison to the United States, this is three years younger. The cannabis consumption age in Uruguay is a reflection of the drinking age, because the legal drinking age in Uruguay is 18 years old as well. Like the United States, Uruguay applied the same kind of restrictions to cannabis as they did to alcohol.
After the legalization had passed within Uruguay, there was an increase in secondary school students’ prevalence with the drug. In 2003, 8.4% of students had consumed marijuana during the previous twelve months, and in 2014, 17% had. The typical user at this age was much more likely to be male than female. There are many concerns about this increase in cannabis use, which is why new prevention strategies are being suggested, such as drug education courses.
All drugs, including cannabis, are technically illegal in the Netherlands. This means it is illegal to produce, possess, and sell the drugs. Dutch police conduct about 5,000 marijuana raids annually throughout the country. But the government designed a drug policy that tolerates cannabis use under strict conditions for those that are at least 18 years old.
The only places individuals can really smoke cannabis is within "coffeeshops". In these coffeeshops, they sell cannabis, which is considered to be soft drugs in comparison to hard drugs; drugs such as heroin. The purpose of these coffee shops are to help people who use soft drugs such as cannabis, to avoid contact with hard drugs, such as heroin. The legal age to get into these coffeeshops is 18 years old. While cannabis can be sold legally through coffeeshops, trafficking the drug is illegal under Dutch law, which means that the coffeeshops have to obtain their cannabis secretly and illegally.
Criteria for coffee shops:
- must not cause any nuisance;
- are not permitted to sell hard drugs;
- are not permitted to sell cannabis to minors;
- are not permitted to advertise drugs;
- are not permitted to sell large quantities (over 5 grams of cannabis) in a single transaction.
Effects on minorsEdit
Many children as young as twelve years old are feeling pressured to try cannabis in the Netherlands. The reason for this is because of the tolerance principle that is in place, meaning that authorities cannot prosecute someone for possessing cannabis if it is under five grams. Because of the lack of enforcement in this, it is giving children the opportunity to possess marijuana in small amounts. Dutch youth have reported higher than average availability of cannabis, but no higher compared to the United States. Many coffee shops have been shut down because of how close they are to schools. Local authorities were afraid that the location of the businesses would influence the youth and take advantage of them.
Amsterdam's mayor, Eberhard van der Laan stated “I think the more relaxed you look at this phenomena, the easier people will stop with it because there is no thrill in using it [if it’s tolerated]". This is a common perception among many individuals within the Netherlands. While they fear substance abuse, citizens of the Netherlands are accepting of the decriminalization of cannabis because individuals will often start to find it "boring" and no longer want to consume cannabis. There is currently no movement towards decriminalization or legalization of cannabis for minors.
- Giraldo, Camilo. "Continued Opposition to Uruguay Marijuana Law and Challenge for Government". InSight Crime. Retrieved 18 November 2015.
- "Impact of Marijuana on Children and Adolescents". California Society of Addiction Medicine. September 2009.
- Szalavitz, Maia. "Is Medical Marijuana Safe for Children?". TIME.
- Gwynne, Kristen. "Why Teen Pot Smoking Could be a Good Thing".
- Gurciullo, Brianna; Mawdsley, Karen; Campbell, Katie. "The marijuana legalization movement begins in the states". The Center for Public Integrity.
- Tyler Cole, Sarah Trumble & Lanae Erickson Hatalsky, All State Marijuana Laws Are Not Created Equal, Third Way (February 17, 2016).
- How to get medical marijuana for minor patients in Pennsylvania, The Express-Times (July 6, 2016).
- Robert McCoppin, Children will get access to medical marijuana in Illinois, Chicago Tribune (December 23, 2014).
- Arielle Levin Necker, Malloy signs medical marijuana for minors bill, CT Mirror (May 17, 2016).
- Room, Robin. "Legalzing a Market for Cannabis for Pleasure: Colorado, Washington, Uruguay and beyond". Addiction: 345–349. doi:10.1111/add.12355.
- Lopez, German. "Why the first country to legalize marijuana might give up". Vox. Retrieved 18 November 2015.
- Walsh, John; Ramsey, Geoff. "Uruguay's Drug Policy: Major Innovations, Major Challenges". Foreign Policy at Brookings.
- Fernanda Boidi, Maria; Miguel Crus, José; Queiroloe, Rosario; Bello-Pardo, Emily. "Marijuana Legalization in Uruguay and Beyond" (PDF). Retrieved 8 October 2015.
- "Dutch Drug Policy". Holland. Retrieved 18 November 2015.
- Grether, Nicole. "In the Netherlands, 38 years of tolerating pot". Retrieved 18 November 2015.
- "Toleration policy regarding soft drugs and coffee shops". Government of the Netherlands. Retrieved 18 November 2015.
- "FAQ Coffeeshops in Amsterdam". I Amsterdam.
- Rolles, Steve. "Cannabis policy in the Netherlands: moving forwards not backwards". Retrieved 18 November 2015.
- McKenzie, Alecia. "Netherlands to see increase in youth smoking pot; taking steps to revise cannabis laws". The World Post. Retrieved 8 October 2015.
- MacCoun, Robert. "What Can We Learn from the Dutch Cannabis Experience". RAND.