Jennifer Baumgardner (born 1970) is a writer, activist, filmmaker, and lecturer whose work explores abortion, sex, bisexuality, rape, single parenthood, and women’s power. From 2013 to 2017, she served as the Executive Director/Publisher at The Feminist Press at the City University of New York (CUNY), a feminist institution founded by Florence Howe in 1970.
Fargo, North Dakota, United States
|Occupation||Author, journalist, film producer, cultural critic, activist, and public speaker|
|Period||Late 20th/early 21st century|
|Genre||Books, magazine articles, documentary films|
|Subject||Feminism, third wave feminism, bisexuality, single parenthood, sex, rape, abortion|
|Literary movement||Third wave feminism|
|Notable works||ManifestA: Young Women, Feminism and the Future|
She is most known for her contribution to the development of third-wave feminism.
Early and personal lifeEdit
Baumgardner grew up in Fargo, North Dakota, the middle of three daughters. She attended Lawrence University in Appleton, Wisconsin, graduating in 1992. While at Lawrence, she helped organize an anti-war “Guerrilla Theater,” led a feminist group on campus, and co-founded an alternative newspaper called The Other that focused on intersectional issues of liberation. She moved to New York City after graduation and in 1993 began working as an unpaid intern for Ms. magazine. By 1997 she had become the youngest editor at Ms.
While working at Ms., Baumgardner fell in love with a female intern, Anastasia. They broke up in 1996, but the relationship inspired her to write the memoir Look Both Ways: Bisexual Politics. In 1997 she began dating Amy Ray of the Indigo Girls; the couple broke up in 2002.
She currently lives in New York with her husband Michael and two sons, Skuli and Magnus.
In 1998, Baumgardner left Ms. and began writing independently for a variety of magazines and news organizations, including the New York Times and NPR. She has since written for numerous magazines, including Glamour, The Nation, Babble, More, and Maxim. Her books include Manifesta: Young Women, Feminism and the Future, Grassroots: A Field Guide for Feminist Activism written with Amy Richards, and Look Both Ways: Bisexual Politics. In 2004 she produced the documentary film Speak Out: I Had an Abortion, which tells the story of ten women's abortion experiences from the 1920s to the present, including the reproductive justice architect Loretta Ross, feminist and journalist Gloria Steinem, and activist Florence Rice. She has written about purity balls (rituals celebrating virginity), Catholic hospitals taking over secular ones and eliminating their reproductive services, rape, and breastfeeding her friend's son.
Baumgardner's work has been featured on shows from The Oprah Winfrey Show to NPR's Talk of the Nation, as well as in the New York Times, BBC News Hour, Bitch, and various other venues. She has keynoted at more than 250 universities, organizations, and conferences, including the National Coalition of Abortion Providers, Amherst College, Take Back The Night UW-Madison, and the New Jersey Women and Gender Studies Consortium. In 2003, the Commonwealth Club of California hailed her in their centennial year as one of six “Visionaries for the 21st Century,” commenting that “in her role as author and activist, [Jennifer has] permanently changed the way people think about feminism...and will shape the next 100 years of politics and culture.”
Contribution to Third Wave FeminismEdit
Through public appearances, books, articles, and film, Baumgardner promoted a positive, matter-of-fact, and accessible approach to speaking publicly about controversial issues—which she referred to as "common-but-silenced"—such as abortion, rape, and sexuality. Called "dependably attentive to the gray areas around divisive issues," this "simple" approach also elicits criticism of her work from feminists and other who find her "off-puttingly naive". In her 2009 collection of essays entitled F 'em: Goo Goo, Gaga, and Some Thoughts on Balls, Baumgardner described the Third Wave she helped to define and represent:
"The Third Wave grew out of an enormous cultural shift. By the late 1980s, a cohort of women and men who’d been raised with the gains, theories, flaws, and backlash of the feminist movement were beginning to come of age. Whether or not these individual men and women were raised by self-described feminists—or called themselves feminists—they were living feminist lives: Females were playing sports and running marathons, taking charge of their sex lives, being educated in greater numbers than men, running for office, and working outside the home. For those who were consciously feminist, the splits of the 1980s formed the architecture of their theories. Kimberlé Crenshaw’s description of “intersectionality” drew on the work of the Combahee River Collective and advanced the idea that gender might be just one of many entry points for feminism.
The Third Wave rejected the idea of a shared political priority list or even a set of issues one must espouse to be feminist. It inherited critiques of sexist dominant culture (having grown up in a feminist-influenced civilization) and embraced and created pop culture that supported women, from Queen Latifah to bell hooks to Riot Grrrl. Girlie feminists created magazines and fashion statements (and complicated the idea of what a feminist might look like). Sex positivity undermined the notion that porn and sex work are inherently demeaning, and revealed a glimpse of the range of potential sexual expression.
Trans feminism, both the idea (much of it from Judith Butler) that gender is performed and a growing belief that gender exists on a spectrum, complicated the legitimacy of women-only spaces as sites of unadulterated liberation. Reclaiming words like 'slut' and 'girl' was as urgent as protests had been. Transparency about whether a feminist had worked out her body image issues, felt upset by an abortion, or believed that any hair could be unwanted replaced strong, black-and-white statements. Activists spoke from personal places, not to overshare, but to tell the truth about their lives and what had happened to them.
Third Wave feminism was portable—you didn’t have to go to a meeting to be feminist; you could bring feminism into any room you entered. Where the Second Wave radicals believed in mass movement and the liberal feminists believed in creating women’s institutions to influence men’s, a Third Waver might say, “Every time I move, I make a women’s movement,”1 indicating a feminism that is more individually driven. Institutions like NOW and Ms. magazine attenuated, in part because Third Wave feminists didn’t need any members to be feminist."
Overview of major worksEdit
Manifesta: Young Women, Feminism, and the Future (2000)Edit
On October 4, 2000 Baumgardner and Amy Richards published their first co-authored book Manifesta: Young Women, Feminism and the Future. Speaking directly to young third wave feminists, Baumgardner and Richards wrote the book to inspire women of the current generation to consciously embrace the liberation of today while remembering the work of previous feminist generations, writing:
- “Consciousness among women is what caused this [change], and consciousness, one's ability to open their (sic) mind to the fact that male domination does affect the women of our generation, is what we need... The presence of feminism in our lives is taken for granted. For our generation, feminism is like fluoride. We scarcely notice we have it—it's simply in the water.”
Prologue: A Day Without Feminism In the prologue of Manifesta, the two authors recall the most vital achievements of women's liberation, which can be credited to the 2nd Wave of Feminists of the 1960s, 70s and 80s. Both of the authors, Baumgardner and Richards, were profoundly influenced by feminism from an early age, as both of their mothers took part in consciousness-raising groups, and Baumgardner's went even further to participate in the staged laundry strikes. So both of these authors are asking the audience to figuratively jump on a time machine and go back to the 1970s for a day. The purpose of this is to see exactly what the 2nd Wave feminists have succeeded in changing in a male-dominant patriarchal society, and what so many now take for granted - including the 3rd Wave feminists.
The authors are aiming their point towards all future feminists (particularly 3rd wave), who are often in conflict with the previous generation of feminists. The tension comes from the belief that 2nd Wave is exclusively white-middle class and over essentialist in the view of femininity. This conflict has led to an almost ideological split between the two factions, but Manifesta's prologue allows for the justification of the 2nd wave's actions. If 2nd Wave feminists not precipitated society to what it was for the 3rd Wave feminists, who knows how the power struggle might have unfolded. This is not taking away anything from the authors' identified group—the 3rd Wave feminists, it is just reminding all of the current feminists, not to criticize what they do not completely know or understand. The accomplishments of the previous generations can never be taken for granted, their success came from radical action which pushed the limits in every segment of society. They did what was deemed reasonably possible, and what the white-male patriarchal society would accept. From their success sprouts and blossoms another movement—the 3rd wave. Society was ready for this movement, people were ready to change the norms of white-male dominance, hence 3rd Wave can manifest in the success of the 2nd Wave, not treat it as its enemy. The two authors just want more harmony within the bigger picture.
Throughout the book the authors traces feminism's evolution from the First Wave suffragette movement to the Third Wave feminism of today, all the while encouraging readers to continue the feminist fight of previous generations.
Who are feminists and what is feminism?
Baumgardner and Richards ask the fundamental but often overlooked questions, "who are the feminists?" and "what is feminism?" They cut to the foundational questions framing contemporary and past feminist movements in order to expose the stereotypes, inaccuracies, or misconceptions that derail and devalue the movement. This goal not only contributes to an established canon of third-wave feminist literature, but also makes the movement more appealing to young women who are misled by negative or stereotypical media and popular culture representations of feminism. They start with foundational definitions of what feminism means to them, invoking politically and socially conscious women and men. They clarify that there is no one formal alliance composed of "the feminists," but instead, feminism is a fluid alliance among individual citizens. This definition displays the differences between how a movement may appear on the surface—cohesive and homogeneous—and how it actually is internally. This disparity may be positive, and lend weight to feminist struggles, but it may also be negative, when the movement as a whole is judged based on the actions of one or a few individual(s). The authors argue that the latter disparity demonstrates the oppressed status of women and feminist activists, as a whole group is easily reduced to one or a few individuals, particularly in media, which disseminates this incomplete illusion.
The authors use matter of fact language to address their next question: what exactly is feminism? Feminism is not only a movement for social, political, and economic equality among men and women, but also requires the freedom to access information and education. Race and ethnicity are key to the modern feminist movement. This natural partnership also invokes the fight for gay rights. Feminism involves men and women of diverse ethnicities and sexual orientations united with the goal to liberate all individuals. It is a movement with the very clear goals of social and political change. This change is epitomized by engagement with government and the law, in addition to broader societal norms and practices. Beyond this foundational definition of feminism, there exists ample elasticity for women to define feminism according to their personal experiences. Because the lived experiences of women are so diverse, feminism itself must accommodate for these differences.
However, because of this fluidity, some modern women in prominent leadership positions have uneasy public relationships with feminism. The authors cite the example of G. E. executive Sam Allison, who sits on the board of The Women's Center in Milwaukee, and claims that she is not a feminist, she is just an "advocate to end violence against women." The modern-day example would be Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg proclaiming that her book, Lean In, “is not a feminist manifesto — okay, it is sort of a feminist manifesto” (Hoedel, 2013, para. 10). These are two examples of the authors' assertions that issues separated from their feminist roots become depoliticized, and the fundamental causes of a particular societal problem are obscured. For example, the problem for Sandberg is an absence of women "leaning in" to positions of workplace leadership. This and other issues of economic development need to unequivocally identified as feminist issues in order to be dealt with equitably and effectively.
Grassroots: A Field Guide for Feminist Activism (2004)Edit
After the critical and commercial success of Manifesta Baumgardner co-authored yet another book with Amy Richards entitled Grassroots: A Field Guide for Feminist Activism which was published in January, 2005. The purpose of the book was to provide a “handbook” for social activism and to help readers answer the social justice question: What can I do? Based on the authors' own experiences, and the stories of both the large number of activists they work with as well as the countless everyday people they have encountered over the years, Grassroots encourages people to move beyond the "generic three" (check writing, contacting congressional representatives, and volunteering) and make a difference with clear guidelines and models for activism. The authors draw heavily on individual stories as examples, inspiring readers to recognize the tools right in front of them—be it the office copier or the family living room—in order to make change. Activism is accessible to all, and Grassroots shows how anyone, no matter how much or little time they have to offer, can create a world that more clearly reflects their values.
Look Both Ways: Bisexual Politics (2007)Edit
On February 20, 2007, Baumgardner published Look Both Ways: Bisexual Politics, the first book she had written without the co-authorship of Amy Richards. In Look Both Ways, Baumgardner takes a close look at the growing visibility of gay and bisexual characters, performers, and issues on the national cultural stage. Despite the prevalence of bisexuality among Generation X and Y women, she finds that it continues to be marginalized by both gay and straight cultures, and dismissed either as a phase or a cop-out. Woven in between her cultural commentary, Baumgardner discusses her own experience as a bisexual, and the struggle she’s undergone to reconcile the privilege she’s garnered as a woman who is perceived as straight and the empowerment and satisfaction she’s derived from her relationships with women.
Abortion & Life (2008)Edit
In October 2008, Baumgardner published Abortion & Life (Akashic), which attempted to reckon with the unease that even people within pro-choice circles feel about abortion with personal portraits, chapters on history, and an assertion that one could be pro-life and a feminist. Noted for its candor and lack of defensiveness, the book stated that "abortion is the result, not the cause, of social problems."
Soapbox, Inc. Speakers Who Speak OutEdit
Soapbox, Inc. is a non-profit feminist organization started by Baumgardner and Amy Richards in 2002. Baumgardner and Richards formed the organization with the purpose of providing a national platform for spreading their activist message. Since its creation in 2002 Soapbox, Inc. has come to represent dozens of authors, scholars, speakers, and artists at the forefront of feminist politics, and has developed a client base of more than 500 schools and organizations, including Planned Parenthood, St. Thomas University, Unitarian Universalist Association, University of Pennsylvania, and Shoreline Community College.
In 2007, they devised an innovative way of "bringing the campus to the speakers" with the creation of Soapbox Feminist Boot Camps. These week-long intensives immerse participants (of all ages and genders) in the practice of feminism and exposes the myriad of issues, approaches, organizations, and individuals that are the lifeblood of the movement. Currently these boot camps are the largest feminist immersion programs in the country.
The "I Had an Abortion" Project (2004)Edit
In 2004, Baumgardner created the "I Had an Abortion" project to encourage women (and men) to "come out" about their procedures. The campaign included t-shirts that said "I had an abortion," a film (made with Gillian Aldrich) documenting women's stories of abortion, a book, and a photo exhibit. The film features ten different women—one of which being famous feminist Gloria Steinem—openly speaking about their abortion experiences spanning over seven decades from the years prior to Roe vs. Wade to present day.
On the "I Had an Abortion" film website Baumgardner writes about her involvement with the campaign, saying:
"The I Had an Abortion project had many inspirations. Some were conversations I kept having with second wave feminists on this listserv called History-In-Action, where the women would talk about how infuriating it was that their experiences of abortion—often trauma-free and liberating—were not part of the media presentation or common understanding of the issue. Some were conversations with my frequent writing partner, Amy Richards, who is brave and open about her experiences with abortion. The final inspiration was frustration with how activists (myself included) yell loudly about abortion rights, but rarely place ourselves in the issue. What experiences have pro-choice and pro-life leaders and senators and congresspeople personally had with abortion?
Frustration with the yelling and the lack of personal stakes in reporting on this issue led me to want to approach it only personally—get right to the women and their stories, their faces and their lives, and get away from their political opinions. Thus, this is a pro-abortion rights project that is most concerned with creating space for women and men to speak honestly about their lives and their abortion experiences."
The "It Was Rape" Project (2008)Edit
After the success of the “I Had an Abortion” campaign Baumgardner began spearheading the “I Was Raped” project in 2008. She later changed the name to “It was Rape." Modeled after the 2004 abortion campaign, the project encouraged men and women to “come out” about their experiences with sexual assault, and included the production and distribution of “I was raped” t-shirts and a 2013 film, It Was Rape, documenting the stories of individuals who had experienced sexual assault in their lifetimes.
In a 2008 interview with Scarleteen, Baumgardner spoke about the campaign, remarking “The ‘It Was Rape’ Project is a documentary, t-shirt campaign, and resources designed to A) highlight the prevalence of rape in our culture and B) interrupt the silence and shame that surrounds it. The goal of this project is to add nuance to the cultural conversation around rape. The reality of rape is more subtle than the preconceptions suggest. The act of rape—as well as the emotions and reactions of the raped—fall somewhere outside of the black-and-white roles of perpetrator and victim. The current things we have in place for justice are also inadequate, since the vast majority of rape victims don’t want to or choose not to press charges. The aim of this documentary is to highlight these issues, as well as to give rape survivors a voice.”
- Baumgardner, Jennifer; Richards, Amy (2000). ManifestA: Young Women, Feminism, and the Future. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. ISBN 978-0-374-52622-1.
- ——; Richards, Amy (2005). Grassroots: A Field Guide for Feminist Activism. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. ISBN 978-0-374-52865-2.
- —— (2007). Look Both Ways: Bisexual Politics. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. ISBN 978-0-374-19004-0.
- —— (2008). Abortion & Life. New York: Akashic Books, Akashic Books. ISBN 978-1-933354-59-0.
- —— (2011). F 'em!: Goo Goo, Gaga, and Some Thoughts on Balls. California: Seal Press, Seal Press. ISBN 978-1-58005-360-0.
- Baumgardner, Jennifer; Kunin, Madeleine M.. (2013). We Do: American Leaders who Believe in Marriage Equality: Akashic Books. ISBN 978-1-61775-187-5
- "Welcome, Jennifer Baumgardner, the new Publisher/Executive Director of Feminist Press!". Feminist Press. 2013-07-31. Archived from the original on 2013-09-15. Retrieved 2013-08-02.
- "Commentary: Headhunted for Love". NPR.org. Retrieved 2015-10-18.
- Baumgardner, Jennifer. Would you pledge your virginity to your father?, Glamour,
- Baumgardner, Jennifer. Immaculate Contraception, The Nation, 7 January 1999[dead link]
- Baumgardner, Jennifer. Breast Friends, Babble, 2007
- "Jennifer Baumgardner." Soapbox Inc.: Speakers Who Speak Out. Soapbox Inc., 2011. Web. 21 Nov 2011.
- "10 Questions with Jennifer Baumgardner". Scarleteen. Retrieved 2015-10-18.
- "Bookslut | It's Complicated". www.bookslut.com. Retrieved 2015-10-18.
- Vincent, Norah (2007-02-18). "Both Sides Now". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2015-10-18.
- Baumgardner, Jennifer; Richards, Amy (2000). Manifesta: Young Women, Feminism, and the Future. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- Hoedel, C. (2013). http://www.kansascity.com/2013/03/22/4132641/lean-in-sparks-a-feminist-firestorm.html
- Baumgardner, Jennifer; Richards, Amy. Grassroots: A Field Guide for Feminist Activism. Farrar Straus, and Giroux, 2004.
- Baumgardner, Jennifer. Look Both Ways: Bisexual Politics. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2004
- "I Had An Abortion: Photos." Speak Out. Accessed 18 January 2013.
- Dominus, Susan (2008-04-04). "Rape Worn Not on a Sleeve, but Right Over the Heart". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2015-10-18.
- Corinna, Heather (2 April 2008). "10 Questions with Jennifer Baumgardner". www.scarleteen.com. Retrieved 2 March 2018.
- Official website
- The Third Wave Foundation
- Interview with Jennifer Baumgardner and Amy Richards
- Activist Mamas: An Interview With Jennifer Baumgardner and Amy Richards article by Amy Anderson in mamazine published January 15, 2006
- Looking both ways with Jennifer Baumgardner article by Mandy Van Deven in feministing published April 16, 2007
- Look Both Ways: Baumgardner Makes Bisexuality Visible article by Eleanor J. Bader in AlterNet published March 7, 2007
- All women are bi like me, journalist says book review by Susan Comninos in the San Francisco Chronicle published March 4, 2007
- Can You Be a Feminist and Anti-Abortion? article by Mandy Van Deven in AlterNet published September 25, 2008