Indie Game: The Movie
Indie Game: The Movie is a 2012 documentary film made by Canadian filmmakers James Swirsky and Lisanne Pajot. The film is about the struggles of independent game developers Edmund McMillen and Tommy Refenes during the development of Super Meat Boy, Phil Fish during the development of Fez, and also Jonathan Blow, who reflects on the success of Braid.
|Indie Game: The Movie|
|Directed by||James Swirsky|
|Produced by||James Swirsky|
|Music by||Jim Guthrie|
|Edited by||James Swirsky|
|Distributed by||BlinkWorks Media|
|94 minutes (Canada)|
103 minutes (International)
After two successful Kickstarter funds, interviews were conducted with prominent indie developers within the community. After recording over 300 hours of footage, Swirsky and Pajot decided to cut the movie down to follow the four developers selected. Their reasoning behind this was to show game development in the "past, present and future" tenses through each individual's story.
The film shows the high level of personal expression that typically goes into independent games, through the story of three games: Braid was released in 2008, Super Meat Boy was preparing for its 2011 release, while Fez was struggling with development hell for several years.
Braid developer Jonathan Blow recounts his thought process for the game: how he wished to put his "deepest flaws and vulnerabilities" into it and how his initial design experience quickly turned from experimentation to discovery. He also talks about the aftermath of the game: When Braid comes out, it receives widespread critical acclaim, but Blow is disillusioned, when a large portion of players don't "get" the underlying message and themes of the game. He makes attempts to influence the audience's impression of the game through forum posts and blog comments, but this eventually turns him into something of a comic figure, which he feels uncomfortable with. The game remains a commercial and critical success.
Super Meat Boy developers Team Meat (Edmund McMillen and Tommy Refenes) set out to do a platform game that harkens back to their own childhood video game experiences. McMillen talks about his lifelong goal of communicating to others through his work. He goes on to talk about his 2008 game Aether that chronicles his childhood feelings of loneliness, nervousness, and fear of abandonment. He also sheds light on the level design techniques he uses, on how he teaches players to play without extensive tutorials.
About a year into development, Microsoft offers Team Meat a chance to take part in an Xbox Live Arcade promotion called "Game Feast", under the condition that they finish the game in a month, which they reluctantly accept because of their dire financial situation. The development goes into crunch time, and takes its toll on McMillen's marriage, and on the health of Refenes, who bears the brunt of the work. Refenes also laments how he sacrificed his social life to get the game done, but expresses gratitude for his family being supportive of his goal. The team successfully delivers the game, but come release day, the game is nowhere to be found on Xbox Live, which greatly upsets Refenes, who predicts low sales as a result. The game does eventually appear on the marketplace, and doubles Braid's sales, selling 20,000 units in the first 24 hours. McMillen is surprised by both the sales and touched by the fan reaction, and although Refenes, exhausted and cynical, is less enthusiastic, his joy shows through when he sees videos of people enjoying the game. The game eventually goes on to sell a million copies, providing a level of financial security to both developers.
Fez developer Polytron (Phil Fish and Renaud Bédard) is in the fourth year of the game's development: the game was first announced at Independent Games Festival 2008, which thrust Fish into the limelight as an "indie developer celebrity", but little was heard of the game since. The development is troubled casting doubt on the future of the project. Fish himself admits to his perfectionism protracting the development, as well as losing perspective over time about how good the game really is. Similar to Refenes, Fish also notes that he does not see himself doing anything else other than indie games, saying that Fez has become his identity over time.
Polytron prepares to present Fez at Penny Arcade Expo, despite the possibility of a lawsuit lingering: Fish's original business partner (Jason DeGroot, who does not participate in the film) is yet to sign his side of a final separation deal, and as such, he could potentially block Polytron from presenting at PAX. This causes Fish to suffer anxiety attacks over the course of the preparation. The Fez kiosk is set up nevertheless, but the show runs into problems, when last minute changes in the build cause the game to often hang up or crash, forcing Fish to occasionally restart the game. The players are unfazed and continue to enjoy the game nevertheless; Fish gives a number of interviews, and Jerry Holkins expresses his excitement about the product as well. Towards the closing of the show, Fish's new partner Ken Schachter announces that he and the former business partner had a meeting and have come to an agreement, which relieves Fish, who in the end is satisfied with the results of the show, and vows to continue working on the game and releasing it in 2012.
The film bookends itself with Jonathan Blow's opening monologue about how indie gaming differs by offering flaws and vulnerabilities, making the games more personal. During the closing credits, videos of other upcoming indie games are interspersed.
Indie Game: The Movie received a high level of interest from the gaming community almost from its inception. Rotten Tomatoes gives the film a rating of 93% based on reviews from 26 critics, with an average rating of 7.7/10. G4 TV praised the film saying "Indie Game: The Movie is definitely worth your time, and should be seen by everyone in the video game industry on the publisher, developer, and consumer sides." Ain't It Cool News echoed these statements, stating that "there are victories, defeats, tears and smiles. Indie Game: The Movie is a must-see doc for anybody that fancies themselves a gamer or for anyone who gets sucked into a good underdog story."
The film was criticized for its one-sided portrayal of Phil Fish's ex-business partner, Jason DeGroot, who was portrayed by Fish as trying to sabotage Fez. DeGroot was neither interviewed nor shown in the film, and the film's credits originally stated that he "asked not to participate" in the film. Shawn McGrath, who worked with DeGroot on Dyad, said on Twitter that the disclaimer was "bullshit," calling the filmmakers "liars." Ken Schachter, Fish's new business partner shown later in the film, was also the executive producer of the film. Several days later, the message in the credits was silently revised to state DeGroot "was not asked" to be in the film.
Indie Game: The Movie was also named 'Best Documentary' by the Utah Film Critics Association and nominated for a Canadian Screen Award at the 1st Canadian Screen Awards in the category of 'Best Feature Length Documentary'.
The producers chose a non-traditional distribution method for the film, coupling the usual film festival circuit with a focused theater tour and aggressive online distribution. Online distribution was initially via iTunes and the gaming platform Steam with a DRM free release, expanded later to other online distribution services and direct downloads from the producers' website. The result of their distribution experiment has been documented by the directors online. Over 50% of gross revenue came from online distribution. The film premiered on Channel 4 in the United Kingdom on 30 November 2013, and was preceded by the documentary How Video Games Changed the World.
On July 24, 2013, Indie Game: The Movie was rereleased with a special edition. Buyers of the new physical copy would receive a hand signed three-DVD box set including posters of the movie’s logo and additional packaging artwork designed by Edmund McMillen. The announcement of additional content being released as pre-purchasable downloadable content (DLC) for Steam users and as a new physical version for collectors was met with mixed reactions some of which questioning the uncommonness of DLC for a movie. Both the original and the Special Edition continue to rate positively on Steam. It features over 100 minutes of additional short documentary content to the original film, also created by James Swirsky and Lisanne Pajot, including epilogues for Fish, McMillen, and Refenes two years after the film’s conclusion.
Phil’s epilogue picks up ten months later as FEZ is nearing release, having been in its development cycle for five years. He discusses the game’s growth, improvement, and closure after the events in IGTM. It also features Polytron’s win at the Independent Game Festival for the Seumas McNally Grand Prize in 2012.
Edmund reflects on the “life-changing” experience following the release and subsequent success of Super Meat Boy. Discussing how he continues to strive to remain working hard towards game development and seeks creative inspiration for new projects.
Tommy talks about the success of Super Meat Boy on Xbox Live and Steam pushing them into a level of financial security. Tommy and Edmund say how happy they are to be able to support their respective families following the financial success of "Super Meat Boy".
The special edition also includes additional shorts regarding other independent game developer’s experiences such as Jason Rohrer’s Passage, Derek Yu’s Spelunky, and Steph Thirion’s Eliss, as well as two shorts regarding visual artist David Hellman’s thematic choices for the aesthetic of Braid and multiple others regarding McMillen's and Refenes' earlier works (Tri-achnid, AVGM, and Coil) including lessons learned and their experiences and influences in development. In many of the shorts, emphasis is placed on how each of the developer’s work was received and their experiences in dealing with the problems that their newfound notoriety brought. Short documentaries entitled “Edmund & Teh Internets”, “Tommy & Teh Internets”, and “Phil + Japan” all focus on each developer’s struggle with maintaining a professional presence online as newly established and critically acclaimed independent developers, similar to Braid developer Jonathan Blow’s struggles with popularity and presence on the internet in the original film.
Also featured is the trailer for the Special Edition, Phil Fish’s first impression of the original IGTM, Edmund McMillen showing their collection of official Super Meat Boy merchandise as well as the different kinds of fan-made submitted gifts they’ve received, and Tommy Refenes’ reflections the immediate day following the release of Super Meat Boy.
Dedicated to its own short entitled “GameJam” is a documentary about the “TIGJam” (The Indie Game Jam) hosted in Mountain View, California by Spelunky creator Derek Yu and other indie game developers in 2013. It focuses on the community around independent games development, in particular the “TIGSource” online community and participants talking about their passions and inspirations for game design.
- "Indie Game: The Movie About". Indiegamethemovie.com. Retrieved 17 April 2012.
- "Indie Game: The Movie by BlinkWorks". Kickstarter. 20 July 2010. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Indie Game: The Movie - The Final Push by BlinkWorks". Kickstarter. 23 July 2011. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- Kelly, Kevin (16 February 2012). "Indie Game: The Movie - The Interview". G4 TV. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- Munro, Shaun (19 June 2012). "Indie Game: The Movie Review: Informative, Emotional Documentary". WhatCulture.com. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Indie Game: The Movie's new credits put end to conflict". Destructoid. Retrieved 2013-08-17.
- Rougeau, Michael (July 30, 2013). "The rise, and completely predictable fall of game developer Phil Fish". Digital Trends.
- Klepeck, Patrick (21 June 2011). "Indie Game: The Movie Trailer Likely to Make You Tear Up". Giant Bomb. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Check out Indie Game: The Movie". IGN. 8 August 2011. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Support, Money Wanted For Spectacular Looking Indie Game: The Movie". G4 TV. 18 May 2010. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- McElroy, Griffin (19 May 2010). "Be a big Hollywood producer by funding Indie Game: The Movie". Engadget. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- Devore, Jordan (12 January 2011). "Indie Game: The Movie bound for Sundance". Destructoid. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Indie Game: The Movie (2012)". Rotten Tomatoes. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- Kelly, Kevin (2 February 2012). "Indie Game: The Movie - The Review". G4 TV. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Quint says Indie Game: The Movie is a must watch, whether you're a gamer or just like good documentaries! Sundance 2012!". Ain't It Cool News. 9 January 2012. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- Sarkar, Samit (June 15, 2012). "'Indie Game: The Movie' filmmakers resolve dispute by revising end credits". Polygon.
- Bradford, Matt (30 January 2012). "Indie Game: The Movie wins at Sundance Film Festival". GamesRadar. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Utah Film Critics Association Awards: Awards for 2012". Internet Movie Database. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Genie Awards: Awards for 2013". Internet Movie Database. Retrieved 9 August 2015.
- "Indie Game: The Movie: The Case Study". Indiegamethemovie.com. Retrieved 10 August 2015.
- Peel, Jeremy (29 November 2013). "Minecraft's going to be honoured on British telly tomorrow". PCGamesN. Retrieved 10 August 2015.
- "Special Edition DVD, Indie Game: The Movie". IndieGameTheMovie Shop. Retrieved 2016-02-22.
- "Indie Game: The Movie Special Edition runs to three discs, available as DLC". VG247.com. Retrieved 2016-02-22.
- "Indie Game: The Movie Special Edition DLC on Steam". store.steampowered.com. Retrieved 2016-02-22.
- TechnoBuffalo. "Indie Game: The Movie - Special Edition Coming This Month". TechnoBuffalo. Retrieved 2016-02-22.
- "Special Edition of Indie Game: The Movie spooled up for July 24". Engadget. Retrieved 2016-02-22.
- "The 17th Annual Independent Games Festival". igf.com. Archived from the original on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 22 February 2016.