Developmental coordination disorder

Developmental coordination disorder (DCD), also known as developmental motor coordination disorder, developmental dyspraxia or simply dyspraxia from the word 'praxis' meaning to do or act, is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by impaired coordination of physical movements as a result of brain messages not being accurately transmitted to the body. Deficits in fine or gross motor skills movements interfere with activities of daily living. It is often described as disorder in skill acquisition, where the learning and execution of coordinated motor skills is substantially below that expected given the individual's chronological age. Difficulties may present as clumsiness, slowness and inaccuracy of performance of motor skills (e.g., catching objects, using cutlery, handwriting, riding a bike, use of tools or participating in team sports or swimming). It is also often accompanied by difficulty with organisation and/or problems with attention, working memory and time management.

Developmental coordination disorder
Other namesDevelopmental motor coordination disorder, dyspraxia
Shoes with undone laces
Many people with dyspraxia have difficulty with shoe knots
SpecialtyPsychiatry, neurology
SymptomsMotor skills deficit and informational processing difficulties
ComplicationsLearning difficulties, low self-esteem, little to no engagement in physical activities like sports leading to obesity
Usual onsetEarly childhood
DurationLifelong
Differential diagnosisMotor impairments due to another medical condition, autism spectrum disorder, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, dysgraphia, joint hypermobility syndrome, fetal alcohol spectrum disorder
TreatmentOccupational therapy
Frequency5–6% (of all age groups)

A diagnosis of DCD is reached only in the absence of other neurological impairments such as cerebral palsy, multiple sclerosis, or Parkinson's disease. Onset of the condition is in early childhood and is lifelong. It is thought to affect about 5% of the population.

Signs and symptomsEdit

 
Signs of Dyspraxia 1

The World Health Organisation (WHO) recognise DCD as a condition, and have published their definition in the International Classification of Diseases. This describes DCD as:

6A04 Developmental motor coordination disorder

Developmental motor coordination disorder is characterised by a significant delay in the acquisition of gross and fine motor skills and impairment in the execution of coordinated motor skills that manifest in clumsiness, slowness, or inaccuracy of motor performance. Coordinated motor skills are substantially below that expected given the individual's chronological age and level of intellectual functioning. Onset of coordinated motor skills difficulties occurs during the developmental period and is typically apparent from early childhood. Coordinated motor skills difficulties cause significant and persistent limitations in functioning (e.g., in activities of daily living, school work, and vocational and leisure activities). Difficulties with coordinated motor skills are not solely attributable to a Disease of the Nervous System, Disease of the Musculoskeletal System or Connective Tissue, sensory impairment, and not better explained by a Disorder of Intellectual Development.

— The ICD-11 International Classification of Diseases 11th Revision (2018)[1]

The American Psychiatric Association (APA)'s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, DSM-5 classifies Developmental Coordination Disorder (DCD) as a discrete motor disorder under the broader heading of neurodevelopmental disorders.[2] It is often described as a disorder in skill acquisition or motor learning, where the learning and execution of coordinated motor skills is substantially below that expected given the individual's chronological age.[3] Various areas of development can be affected by DCD and these may persist into adulthood.[4][5][6]

In children, DCD may exhibit as delays in early development of sitting, crawling, walking; poor ability or difficulties with childhood activities such as running, jumping, hopping, catching, sports and swimming; slowness; frequent tripping and bruising; poor handwriting skills; difficulties with self care; difficulties with skills such as using cutlery or tying shoelaces; poor spatial understanding; difficulty following instructions; poor time management; and often losing objects.[7]

In adulthood, in addition to a childhood history as above, the condition may manifest as a difficulty learning new motor skills or applying skills in a different or busy environment, poor organisation and time management skills, missed deadlines and lateness for appointments (or earliness as a coping strategy), and awkward pauses before answering in conversation. There is often a history of underachievement in education or the workplace. Although skills can be acquired, such as neat handwriting, handwriting speed will then be much lower than expected. [7]

DCD has no cure. Often various coping strategies are developed, and these can be enhanced through occupational therapy, psychomotor therapy, physiotherapy, speech therapy, or psychological training.

Evidence from research and clinical practice indicates that DCD is not just a physical disorder, and there may be deficits in executive functions, behavioural organisation and emotional regulation that extend beyond the motor impairments and which are independent of diagnoses of co-morbidities.[8] In addition to the physical or motor impairments, developmental coordination disorder is associated with problems with memory, especially working memory.[9] This typically results in difficulty remembering instructions, difficulty organizing one's time and remembering deadlines, increased propensity to lose things or problems carrying out tasks which require remembering several steps in sequence (such as cooking). Whilst most of the general population experience these problems to some extent, they have a much more significant impact on the lives of dyspraxic people.[10] However, many dyspraxics have excellent long-term memories, despite poor short-term memory.[10] Many dyspraxics benefit from working in a structured environment, as repeating the same routine minimises difficulty with time-management and allows them to commit procedures to long-term memory.

People with developmental coordination disorder sometimes have difficulty moderating the amount of sensory information that their body is constantly sending them, so as a result these dyspraxics may be prone to sensory overload and panic attacks.[10]

Moderate to extreme difficulty doing physical tasks is experienced by some people with dyspraxia, and fatigue is common because so much energy is expended trying to execute physical movements correctly. Some dyspraxics have hypotonia, low muscle tone, which can also detrimentally affect balance.[11]

Gross motor controlEdit

Whole body movement and motor coordination issues mean that major developmental targets including walking, running, climbing and jumping can be affected. The difficulties vary from person to person and can include the following:

  • Poor timing.[12]
  • Poor balance[12][13] (sometimes even falling over in mid-step). Tripping over one's own feet is also common.
  • Difficulty combining movements into a controlled sequence.
  • Difficulty remembering the next movement in a sequence.
  • Problems with spatial awareness,[13][14] or proprioception.
  • Trouble picking up and holding onto simple objects such as pencils, owing to poor muscle tone or proprioception.
  • Clumsiness to the point of knocking things over, causing minor injuries to oneself and bumping into people accidentally.
  • Difficulty in determining left from right.
  • Cross-laterality, ambidexterity, and a shift in the preferred hand are also common in people with developmental coordination disorder.
  • Problems with chewing foods.

Fine motor controlEdit

Fine-motor problems can cause difficulty with a wide variety of other tasks such as using a knife and fork, fastening buttons and shoelaces, cooking, brushing teeth, styling hair, shaving,[11][15] applying cosmetics, opening jars and packets, locking and unlocking doors, and doing housework.

Difficulties with fine motor co-ordination lead to problems with handwriting,[11][16] Problems associated with this area may include:

  • Learning basic movement patterns.[17]
  • Developing a desired writing speed.[15]
  • Establishing the correct pencil grip.[15]
  • Handwriting that is difficult to read and may miss words in sentences or place words in the incorrect order
  • The acquisition of graphemes – e.g. the letters of the Latin alphabet, as well as numbers.

Developmental verbal dyspraxiaEdit

Developmental verbal dyspraxia (DVD) is a type of ideational dyspraxia, causing speech and language impairments. This is the favoured term in the UK; however, it is also sometimes referred to as articulatory dyspraxia, and in the United States the usual term is childhood apraxia of speech (CAS).[18][19][20]

Key problems include:

  • Difficulties controlling the speech organs.
  • Difficulties making speech sounds.
  • Difficulty sequencing sounds within a word, and
  • Difficulty sequencing sounds forming words into sentences.
  • Difficulty controlling breathing, suppressing salivation and phonation when talking or singing with lyrics.
  • Slow language development.

Associated disorders and secondary consequencesEdit

People who have developmental coordination disorder may also have one or more of these co-morbid conditions:

However, a person with DCD is unlikely to have all of these conditions. The pattern of difficulty varies widely from person to person; an area of major weakness for one dyspraxic can be an area of strength or gift for another. For example, while some dyspraxics have difficulty with reading and spelling due to dyslexia, or with numeracy due to dyscalculia, others may have brilliant reading and spelling or mathematical abilities. Co-morbidity between ADHD and DCD is particularly high; the overlap between the two disorders is believed to be about 50% (approximately half of people with DCD have ADHD, and approximately half of people with ADHD have DCD).[33][34][35]

Sensory processing disorderEdit

Sensory processing disorder (SPD) concerns having oversensitivity or undersensitivity to physical stimuli, such as touch, light, sound, and smell.[36] This may manifest itself as an inability to tolerate certain textures such as sandpaper or certain fabrics such as wool, oral intolerance of excessively textured food (commonly known as picky eating), being touched by another individual (in the case of touch oversensitivity) or it may require the consistent use of sunglasses outdoors since sunlight may be intense enough to cause discomfort to a dyspraxic person (in the case of light oversensitivity). An aversion to loud music and naturally loud environments (such as clubs and bars) is typical behavior of individuals with dyspraxia who have auditory oversensitivity, while only being comfortable in unusually warm or cold environments is typical of a dyspraxic with temperature oversensitivity. Undersensitivity to stimuli may also cause problems, as individuals do not receive the sensory input they need to understand where their bodies are in space. This can make it even more challenging to complete tasks.[37] Dyspraxics who are undersensitive to pain may injure themselves without realising it. Some dyspraxics may be oversensitive to some stimuli and undersensitive to others.[38]

Developmental Language DisorderEdit

Developmental Language Disorder (DLD) research has found that students with developmental coordination disorder and normal language skills still experience learning difficulties despite relative strengths in language. This means that, for students with developmental coordination disorder, their working memory abilities determine their learning difficulties. Any strength in language that they have is not able to sufficiently support their learning.[31]

Students with developmental coordination disorder struggle most in visual-spatial memory. When compared to their peers without motor difficulties, students with developmental coordination disorder are seven times more likely than typically developing students to achieve very poor scores in visual-spatial memory.[39] As a result of this working memory impairment, students with developmental coordination disorder have learning deficits as well.[40]

Psychological and social consequencesEdit

Psychological domain: Children with DCD may struggle with lower self-efficacy and lower self-perceived competence in peer and social relations. Some demonstrate greater aggressiveness and hyperactivity.[41]

Social domain: Children may be more vulnerable to social rejection and bullying, possibly resulting in higher levels of loneliness.[41]

DiagnosisEdit

Assessments for developmental coordination disorder typically require a developmental history,[42] detailing ages at which significant developmental milestones, such as crawling and walking,[43][44][45] occurred. Motor skills screening includes activities designed to indicate developmental coordination disorder, including balancing, physical sequencing, touch sensitivity, and variations on walking activities.[citation needed]

The American Psychiatric Association has four primary inclusive diagnostic criteria[45] for determining if a child has developmental coordination disorder.

The criteria are as follows:

  1. Motor coordination will be greatly reduced, although the intelligence of the child is normal for the age.
  2. The difficulties the child experiences with motor coordination or planning interfere with the child's daily life.
  3. The difficulties with coordination are not due to any other medical condition
  4. If the child does also experience comorbidities such as intellectual or other developmental disability; motor coordination is still disproportionally affected.[42]

Screening testsEdit

Currently there is no single "gold standard" assessment test for DCD.[46] Various screening tests may be used, including the following.

Screening tests that can be used to assess developmental coordination disorder
  • Movement Assessment Battery for Children (Movement-ABC – Movement-ABC 2)[46][47][48][49][50]
  • Peabody Developmental Motor Scales- Second Edition (PDMS-2)[46]
  • Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency (BOTMP-BOT-2)[46][51][52][53]
  • Motoriktest für vier- bis sechsjährige Kinder (MOT 4–6)[46][54]
  • Körperkoordinationtest für Kinder (KTK)[46]
  • Test of Gross Motor Development, Second Edition (TGMD-2)[46]
  • Maastrichtse Motoriek Test (MMT)[46]
  • Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS-III and WAIS-IV)[55]
  • Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WAIT-II)[citation needed]
  • Test Of Word Reading Efficiency Second Edition (TOWRE-2)[citation needed]
  • Developmental Coordination Disorder Questionnaire (DCD-Q).[56] The DCD-Q has been translated into many languages. For French-speaking populations, a Canadian-French version [57] and a European-French version[58] are available.
  • Children's Self-Perceptions of Adequacy in, and Predilection for Physical Activity (CSAPPA)[59]

A baseline motor assessment establishes the starting point for developmental intervention programs. Comparing children to normal rates of development may help to establish areas of significant difficulty.

However, research in the British Journal of Special Education has shown that knowledge is severely limited in many who should be trained to recognise and respond to various difficulties, including developmental coordination disorder, dyslexia and deficits in attention, motor control and perception (DAMP).[45] The earlier that difficulties are noted and timely assessments occur, the quicker intervention can begin. A teacher or GP could miss a diagnosis if they are only applying a cursory knowledge.

"Teachers will not be able to recognise or accommodate the child with learning difficulties in class if their knowledge is limited. Similarly GPs will find it difficult to detect and appropriately refer children with learning difficulties."[60]

A diagnosis of DCD is reached only in the absence of other neurological impairments such as cerebral palsy,[61][44] multiple sclerosis, or Parkinson's disease.

ClassificationEdit

Developmental coordination disorder is classified in the fifth revision of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) as a motor disorder, in the category of neurodevelopmental disorders.[62]

PrevalenceEdit

The exact proportion of people with the disorder is unknown since the disorder can be difficult to detect due to a lack of specific laboratory tests, thus making diagnosis of the condition one of elimination of all other possible causes/diseases. Approximately 5–6% of children and adults are affected by this condition.[2][63][43][64][65] and approximately 2% are severely affected.[7]

DCD is a lifelong neurological condition that is expected to be as common in males as it is in females.[4][5][6] Currently however, the diagnosis criteria favours males which results in over 80% of males being diagnosed before the age of 16 compared to only 22% for females.[citation needed]

ManagementEdit

There is no cure for the condition. Instead, it is managed through therapy. Physical therapy or occupational therapy can help those living with the condition.

Some people with the condition find it helpful to find alternative ways of carrying out tasks or organizing themselves, such as typing on a laptop instead of writing by hand, or using diaries and calendars to keep organized.[66] A review completed in 2017 by Cochrane of task-oriented interventions for DCD resulted in inconsistent findings and a call for further research and randomized controlled trials.[67]

Co-occurring conditionsEdit

DCD is know to co-occur with other Neurodevelopmental Disorders. Most commonly, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) co-occurs in an estimated 50% of cases, but other co-occurring conditions are Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD), Developmental Speech and Language Disorder and Developmental Learning Disorder.[1]

HistoryEdit

Collier first described developmental coordination disorder as "congenital maladroitness". A. Jean Ayres referred to developmental coordination disorder as a disorder of sensory integration in 1972,[68][69] while in 1975 Sasson Gubbay, MD, called it the "clumsy child syndrome".[42][70][71] Developmental coordination disorder has also been called "minimal brain dysfunction", although the two latter names are no longer in use.

Other names include developmental apraxia,[42] disorder of attention and motor perception (DAMP)[42][70] dyspraxia,[44] developmental dyspraxia,[42][72][73] "motor learning difficulties",[42][70] perceptuo-motor dysfunction,[42][70][69] and sensorimotor dysfunction.[42]

The World Health Organization currently lists developmental coordination disorder as "Specific Developmental Disorder of Motor Function".[44]

In popular cultureEdit

 
Daniel Radcliffe, actor, has dyspraxia

Notable casesEdit

People who have publicly stated they have been diagnosed with developmental coordination disorder include:

See alsoEdit

ReferencesEdit

  1. ^ a b ICD-11.
  2. ^ a b DSM-5-TR.
  3. ^ Smits-Engelsman et al. 2015.
  4. ^ a b Blank et al. 2019.
  5. ^ a b Saban & Kirby 2018.
  6. ^ a b Meachon, Semp & Alpers 2022.
  7. ^ a b c Dyspraxia Foundation 2022.
  8. ^ Green & Payne 2018.
  9. ^ Alloway, Rajendran & Archibald 2009.
  10. ^ a b c Biggs 2005.
  11. ^ a b c d Barnhart et al. 2003.
  12. ^ a b Missiuna et al. 2006.
  13. ^ a b Geuze 2005.
  14. ^ Wilson & McKenzie 1998.
  15. ^ a b c Polatajko & Cantin 2005.
  16. ^ Rosenblum 2013.
  17. ^ Lacquaniti 1989.
  18. ^ Vargha-Khadem et al. 2005.
  19. ^ Bacon & Rappold 2012.
  20. ^ Scharff & Petri 2011.
  21. ^ Fliers, Franke & Buitelaar 2011.
  22. ^ Lucas et al. 2016.
  23. ^ Dziuk et al. 2007.
  24. ^ Jeste 2011.
  25. ^ Miyahara 2013.
  26. ^ Pieters et al. 2012.
  27. ^ Van Waelvelde et al. 2012.
  28. ^ Pickering 2012, p. 28.
  29. ^ Poletti 2011.
  30. ^ Elbasan, Kayihan & Duzgun 2012.
  31. ^ a b Alloway 2008.
  32. ^ Schoemaker et al. 2001.
  33. ^ Barkley 1990.
  34. ^ Goulardins et al. 2015.
  35. ^ Cravedi et al. 2017.
  36. ^ Miller et al. 2007.
  37. ^ Fitts 2019.
  38. ^ Dyspraxia Ireland 2022.
  39. ^ Alloway 2007.
  40. ^ Alloway, Temple 2007.
  41. ^ a b Zwicker, Harris & Klassen 2013.
  42. ^ a b c d e f g h i Gibbs, Appleton & Appleton 2007.
  43. ^ a b Zwicker 2012.
  44. ^ a b c d Henderson & Henderson 2003.
  45. ^ a b c Kirby & Sugden 2007.
  46. ^ a b c d e f g h Cools et al. 2009.
  47. ^ Wright & Sugden 1996.
  48. ^ Venetsanou et al. 2011.
  49. ^ Ellinoudis et al. 2011.
  50. ^ Schoemaker et al. 2012.
  51. ^ Venetsanou et al. 2007.
  52. ^ Venetsanou et al. 2009.
  53. ^ Lucas et al. 2013.
  54. ^ Kambas et al. 2012.
  55. ^ Grant 2009.
  56. ^ Schoemaker et al. 2006.
  57. ^ Martini, St-Pierre & Wilson 2011.
  58. ^ Ray-Kaeser et al. 2019.
  59. ^ Hay, Hawes & Faught 2004.
  60. ^ Kirby, Davies & Bryant 2005.
  61. ^ Pearsall-Jones, Piek & Levy 2003.
  62. ^ DSM-5-TR, p. 74.
  63. ^ Blank et al. 2012.
  64. ^ Gaines et al. 2008.
  65. ^ CanChild 2016.
  66. ^ NHS 2019.
  67. ^ Miyahara et al. 2017.
  68. ^ Ayres 1972.
  69. ^ a b Willoughby & Polatajko 1995.
  70. ^ a b c d Gillberg & Kadesjö 2003.
  71. ^ Gubbay 1978.
  72. ^ Magalhães, Missiuna & Wong 2006.
  73. ^ Kirby et al. 2010.
  74. ^ Psynso 2022.
  75. ^ Gerken 2018.
  76. ^ Irvine 2008.
  77. ^ Walsh 2016.
  78. ^ Haskell 2015.
  79. ^ Hussey 2008.
  80. ^ Irvine 2013.
  81. ^ Beater 2019.
  82. ^ Hennessy 2018.
  83. ^ Williams 2013.
  84. ^ Thompson 2019.
  85. ^ Anchor 2021a.
  86. ^ Smale 2021.
  87. ^ Bain 2020.
  88. ^ Anchor 2021b.
  89. ^ Kemsley 2018.

SourcesEdit

Further readingEdit