Days of Shame

Days of Shame refers to the antisemitic June 1934 doctor's strike at the Hôpital Notre-Dame in Montreal, Quebec, Canada.[1] For four days, all interns at the hospital walked off the job to protest the hiring of a Jewish senior intern, Dr. Samuel Rabinovitch. The strike ended when Rabinovitch resigned his position.[2][3]

BackgroundEdit

Samuel Rabinovitch (1909–2010), a young physician from a family of Jewish doctors, had been the highest ranking graduate of his class from the Université de Montréal. Following his graduation, he was offered a senior internship at several hospitals in both Canada and the United States, eventually accepting the offer from Hôpital Notre-Dame in his hometown of Montreal. He was the first Jewish intern to be hired at a French Canadian hospital in history.[4] All applications from French Canadian graduates that year were also accepted.[5]

Days of ShameEdit

Rabinovitch's appointment was immediately met with backlash. Members of the public in Quebec sent letters to the hospital claiming that Catholics were being replaced by Jews, that the French Canadian population had been abused under the banner of tolerance, and declaring that they had a right to refuse to be treated by openly Jewish doctors.[6] In early June 1934 a petition signed by doctors and interns of Notre-Dame was submitted to the hospitals board, requesting that the contract between the Hospital and Rabinovich be rescinded. After a lengthy deliberation by the hospital board it was decided to uphold the contract and hire Rabinovitch.[7]

At midnight on 14 June 1934, thirty-two resident doctors at the hospital walked off the job rather than work with Rabinovich, refusing even to treat patients in critical condition. By 17 June the strike had expanded to include interns from five other Montreal hospitals, with interns at a further three hospitals signing a petition in support of the strike, and with several hundred nurses threatening to join the strike.

Quebec nationalist groups and media such as the Saint-Jean-Baptiste Society and Le Devoir quickly backed the striking interns, with the latter publishing stories referring to Rabinovich as "the foreign physician" and alleging that he had links to "high finance."[7] The strike also spread to target other Jewish doctors, such as Abram Stillman, a postdoctoral urologist at Hôtel-Dieu de Québec. Stillman's supervisor, Oscar Mercier, barely defended him, merely stating that he was "just a visitor" who could not be taking a job from a French Canadian as he was "not occupying an official position."[4] Only a handful of French Canadians publicly supported Rabinovitch, notably Le Canada [fr] editors Olivar Asselin and Edmond Turcotte, who decried the antisemitic conspiracies that were spread on front-page headlines by the press.[8]

On 18 June, after efforts from Montreal's Jewish community to solve the situation came short, Rabinovitch formally resigned from his position. His letter of resignation, which was published publicly in several newspapers, stated that he "bemoaned the fact that so many French Canadian physicians, namely graduates, should have ignored the first duty of their oath," but that the "distressing, serious and dangerous condition to which the patients of the Nôtre-Dame and other hospitals have been exposed" left him with no choice.[9]

Following Rabinovitch's resignation, the striking doctors returned to work at 7:30 PM on 19 June 1934. None of them would face any disciplinary sanctions for their actions. On 22 June 1934, an interview with three of the strikers was published in L’Ordre in which the strikers denied being motivated by antisemitism, stating instead that they had legitimate concerns about competition between Jewish and Catholic doctors for limited internships, and about Catholic interns being forced to spend an entire year practicing alongside a Jew.[10]

AftermathEdit

After his resignation, Rabinovitch left Canada to take up an internship in St. Louis, Missouri, specialising in internal medicine. He would remain there until his return to Montreal in 1940.[11] The Université de Montréal increased its restrictions on the admission of Jewish students after the Days of Shame.[12]

The impact of the Days of Shame, along with other antisemitic events, led the Jewish community in Quebec to establish their own hospital, the Jewish General Hospital. Funds for the new hospital were obtained through charitable drives headed by Allan Bronfman, Sir Mortimer Davis and J. W. McConnell.[13]

ReferencesEdit

  1. ^ Bérard, Frédéric (18 November 2020). "Une bien sale histoire". Journal Métro (in French). Retrieved 3 August 2021.
  2. ^ "Montreal Internes Strike". The New York Times. 17 June 1934. p. 16. Retrieved 3 August 2021.
  3. ^ "Hospital Strike Spreads; Internes of Four Montreal Institutions Join Protest". The New York Times. 18 June 1934. p. 5. Retrieved 3 August 2021.
  4. ^ a b Miller, Yvette Alt (18 July 2021). "Montreal's Days of Shame: When 75 Doctors Went on Strike until a Jewish Doctor Resigned". Aish.com. Retrieved 21 July 2021.
  5. ^ Bélanger, Claude (23 August 2000). "Chronology of the Notre-Dame Hospital". Quebec History. Marianopolis College. Archived from the original on 23 July 2021.
  6. ^ Halperin, Edward C. (June 2021). "'We Do Not Want Him Because He Is a Jew': The Montreal Interns' Strike of 1934". Annals of Internal Medicine. 174 (6): 852–857. doi:10.7326/M20-7121.
  7. ^ a b Tulchinsky, Gerald (2008). Canada's Jews: A People's Journey. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. ISBN 978-0-8020-9386-8.
  8. ^ Dupuis-Déri, Francis (29 April 2019). "De l'antisémitisme à l'islamophobie: de la grève de 1934 à la loi 21" (in French). Archived from the original on 29 April 2019.
  9. ^ Wilton, Peter (9 December 2003). "Days of shame, Montreal, 1934". Canadian Medical Association Journal. 169 (12): 1329.
  10. ^ Robinson, Ira (2015). "« Maîtres chez eux »: La grève des internes de 1934 revisitée". Globe: Revue internationale d'études québécoises (in French). 18 (1): 153–168. doi:10.7202/1037882ar.
  11. ^ Lazarus, David (25 November 2010). "Doctor was central figure in 1934 hospital strike". Canadian Jewish News. Retrieved 21 July 2021.
  12. ^ "Dr. Sam Rabinovitch and the Notre-Dame Hospital Strike". Museum of Jewish Montreal. Archived from the original on 9 June 2021. Retrieved 21 July 2021.
  13. ^ Fong, William (2008). J.W. McConnell: Financier, Philanthropist, Patriot. McGill-Queen's Press. ISBN 978-0-7735-7468-7.