Comparison of browser engines (graphics support)

This article compares graphics support for several browser engines.

Explanation of the tablesEdit

Engine Status Embedded in
WebKit Active Safari browser, plus all browsers hosted on the iOS App Store
Blink Active Google Chrome and all other Chromium-based browsers such as Opera and Microsoft Edge
EdgeHTML Active Universal Windows Platform apps; formerly in the Edge browser[1]
Gecko Active Firefox browser and Thunderbird email client, plus forks like SeaMonkey and Waterfox
KHTML Discontinued Konqueror browser
Presto Discontinued formerly in the Opera browser
Trident Discontinued Internet Explorer browser and Microsoft Outlook email client

ValuesEdit

These indicate the level of support for the given item in each engine. By default, the most recent version of the engine is implied. However, a specific version number can be listed; when this indicates full support, it's the initial version of the engine fully supporting the item.

Value Meaning
Yes Fully supported
No Has never been supported
Partial Only some values are supported
Incorrect Not implemented correctly in all cases
Experimental May be incomplete or buggy
Nightly build Currently in development; full support is expected
Depends Only supported for the specified conditions
Dropped No longer supported

Image format supportEdit

Trident EdgeHTML Gecko WebKit Blink KHTML[n 1] Presto
JPEG 3.0 Yes 1.0 85 Yes Yes 1.0
JPEG 2000 No No No[2] Dropped[n 2] No No No
JPEG XR 5.0[4] Yes No[5] No No No No
GIF GIF 89a 3.0 Yes 1.0 85 Yes Yes 1.0
GIF 87a
PNG 1.2 3.1 Yes 1.0 85 Yes Yes 1.0
1.1
1.0
APNG No No 3.0 528 59.0 No 9.5
BMP Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 1.0
ICO Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 1.0
TIFF 5.0[4] Yes No[6] No No Yes[7] No
WebP No 17 [8] Experimental[9] 534.10[10] Yes[11] No 2.8.131[12]

JPEG featuresEdit

Trident EdgeHTML Gecko WebKit Blink KHTML[n 1] Presto
Operation mode Progressive 3.0[n 3] Yes Yes 85 Yes Yes 1.0
Baseline 3.0
Hierarchical
Lossless

GIF featuresEdit

Trident EdgeHTML Gecko WebKit Blink KHTML[n 1] Presto
GIF 87a Interlacing 3.0 Yes 1.0 85 Yes Yes 1.0
GIF 89a Binary transparency
Animation

PNG featuresEdit

Trident EdgeHTML Gecko WebKit Blink KHTML[n 1] Presto
Color mode[n 4] True color 3.1 Yes 1.0 85 Yes Yes 1.0
Grayscale
Palette-based
Alpha channel 3.1 Yes 1.0 85 Yes Yes 1.0
Gamma correction 5.0[13] Yes 3.5[14] Incorrect[n 5] ? No[16] Partial[n 6]
Color correction Yes 1.9 ? ? ? No
Interlacing Incorrect[n 7] ? 1.0 ? ? 4.0 1.0

See alsoEdit

NotesEdit

  1. ^ a b c d KHTML did not have any native image support. This was by design: in Konqueror, multimedia files were handled by KParts.
  2. ^ JPEG 2000 support was only available on the macOS platform prior to the release of 10.15 Catalina, and required QuickTime 7, since Safari 12 dropped official support for NPAPI plugins (including QuickTime).[3] (Note that the referenced link leads to the Mozilla Bugzilla, where this was brought up and confirmed.)
  3. ^ Trident only displayed progressive JPEGs after they were completely downloaded.
  4. ^ There are 15 combinations of the color modes in PNG but not all modes are available in every image editor.
  5. ^ Webkit incorrectly applies gamma correction to unlabeled PNGs.[15]
  6. ^ Presto supported gamma correction for all color profiles except for ICC-profile.[17]
  7. ^ In Trident, interlaced PNGs were displayed progressively, but in 1D instead of 2D.

ReferencesEdit

  1. ^ Mackie, Kurt (10 December 2018). "Microsoft Edge Browser To Get New Rendering Engine but EdgeHTML Continues". Redmond Mag. Retrieved 21 December 2019.
  2. ^ Bug 36351 - Support the jpeg2000 (jp2k) format, Mozilla
  3. ^ Bug 36351 Comment 150 - Support the jpeg2000 (jp2k) format
  4. ^ a b Protalinski, Emil (2010-03-16), Platform Preview gives Web developers first taste of IE9, Ars Technica
  5. ^ Bug 500500 - Add support for JPEG-XR/HD Photo, Mozilla
  6. ^ Bug 160261 - (TIFF) TIFF Support?, Mozilla
  7. ^ Faure, David, Re: Bug#15507: tiff, 'Open with:' -> many konqueror windows
  8. ^ WebP is supported in Edge
  9. ^ Bug 1294490 - Implement experimental WebP image support, Mozilla
  10. ^ Bug 47512 - Add support for decoding WebP image, WebKit
  11. ^ https://developers.google.com/speed/webp/faq
  12. ^ Opera 11.10 for Windows changelog, Opera Software
  13. ^ Windows Internet Explorer Platform Preview, Microsoft, 2010-03-15, archived from the original on 2010-04-19, retrieved 2010-03-20
  14. ^ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2009/06/color-correction/
  15. ^ Sivonen, Henri, The Sad Story of PNG Gamma "Correction"
  16. ^ Bug 179690 - PNG gamma correction doesn't work (bug 61829), KDE
  17. ^ Roelofs, Greg, Browser Gamma-Consistency Test