Richard "Rick" G. Frenkel [1] (born 1966 or 1967 [2]) was an in-house intellectual property counsel and director of intellectual property at Cisco Systems.[3][4] He was once the anonymous author of the Patent Troll Tracker blog, focusing on the subject of "patent trolls" [2] and "a must-read blog among top intellectual property litigators".[3]
Dispute edit
In October 2007, Frenkel posted anonymous comments through his Patent Troll Tracker blog about a patent infringement case in which Cisco was the defendant.[3] Frenkel claimed that the plaintiff, a company named ESN, filed a lawsuit one day before the patent in the lawsuit was issued by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (which if true would have meant that ESN did not have legal standing[4]). Frenkel also suggested that ESN's local counsel may have improperly convinced the Clerk of Court of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas to change the date on the docket to reflect that the case was filed the next day.[3] At that time, a $15,000 bounty for his identity had also been offered [4][5] by Chicago attorney Raymond Niro Sr.[2]
Litigation claims edit
After Frenkel publicly revealed his identity on February 23, 2008,[5][6] in the entry titled "Live by anonymity, die by anonymity",[2] the attorneys for ESN, T. John Ward, Jr., the son of East Texas federal Judge T. John Ward,[4] and Eric Albritton, filed defamation actions against Cisco and Frenkel.[3] "The attorneys [were] seeking damages for shame, embarrassment, humiliation, mental pain, and anguish. Further, the attorneys state[d] injuries to their "business reputation, good name, and standing in the community, and [would] be exposed to the hatred, contempt, and ridicule of the public in general as well as of his business associates, clients, friends, and relatives."[4]
Issues edit
The case raised questions about the risks of blogging anonymously,[2] and received wide publicity in the blogosphere as it was thought that the lawsuits could result in precedents to be applied to future bloggers.[4] Subsequently, Cisco updated its policy on employee blogging.[7]
Trial edit
The Albritton case went to trial in Tyler, Texas on September 14, 2009.[8] After Judge Richard A. Schell ruled that Albritton had to prove actual malice to be eligible for punitive damages, the litigation settled.[9] The Ward case—which was filed against Cisco and not Frenkel—settled in January 2010.[10]
Career change edit
Frenkel left Cisco in August 2008 to join the Palo Alto office of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati as a patent litigator.[11] He was a partner with the firm.[12] At the time he joined the firm, he said he was done with blogging.[11] As of 2022, Frenkel was a partner at the law firm of Latham & Watkins.[13]
References edit
- ^ United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), Patent Attorney/Agent database entry for Richard G. Frenkel. Retrieved on March 15, 2008.
- ^ a b c d e Michael Orey, Busting a Rogue Blogger, BusinessWeek, March 27, 2008. Consulted on April 4, 2008.
- ^ a b c d e Asher Hawkins, Shut Up, Already!, Forbes.com, March 11, 2008. Retrieved on March 15, 2008.
- ^ a b c d e f Michelle Massey, Patent troll tracker sued for defamation, The Southeast Texas Record, March 13, 2008. Retrieved on March 15, 2008.
- ^ a b Niraj Chokshi, Mystery patent blogger is Cisco in-houser, Legal Week, February 26, 2008. Retrieved on March 15, 2008.
- ^ Stuart Weinberg, Controversial Blog on Patent Suits Is Authored by Cisco Executive, Wall Street Journal, February 25, 2008.
- ^ Lessons Learned….Cisco Updates Policy on Employee Blogging, The Platform, The Official Cisco Blog, March 24, 2008. Consulted on April 5, 2008.
- ^ Trial Kicks Off in Suit Over Blog Post By Cisco In-House Lawyer, Brenda Jeffries, Texas Lawyer, September 16, 2009. Consulted on July 24, 2010.
- ^ Troll Tracker Defamation Case Settles Before Going To Jury, Joe Mullin, The Prior Art Blog, September 22, 2009. Consulted on July 24, 2010.
- ^ Cisco Systems Settles Defamation Suit Over Blog Posting, Brenda Jeffries, Texas Lawyer, January 19, 2010. Consulted on July 24, 2010.
- ^ a b Cisco Blogger Decamps To Wilson Sonsini, Zusha Ellison, The Recorder, August 6, 2008. Consulted on July 24, 2010.
- ^ "Richard G. Frenkel". Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati. Archived from the original on November 25, 2009. Retrieved May 4, 2013.
- ^ Richard G. Frenkel Attorney Biography, Latham & Watkins
Bibliography edit
- Richard G. Frenkel, Intellectual Property in the Balance: Proposals for Improving Industrial Design Protection in the Post-TRIPS Era, 32 Loy. L.A. L. Rev. 531, 541 (1999) (pdf)
Primary sources edit
- Ward v. Cisco and Frenkel Case No. 2007-2502-A (pdf)
- Albritton v. Cisco and Frenkel Case No. 2008-481-CCL2 (pdf)
- Dennis Crouch, Troll Tracker, Defamation, and Splitting the Bar, PatentlyO blog, March 12, 2008